3 ms·
If the money that would have been taxed doesn't go to the shareholders as dividends, then it goes to the shareholders as cap gains when they sell their shares.
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
If the money that would have been taxed doesn't go to the shareholders as dividends, then it goes to the shareholders as cap gains when they sell their shares.
- rayiner 14y agoThat's an even stronger argument to taxing dividends the same as ordinary income. Say 10 people each invest $100 in a business. After 1 year of operation, the business generates $10,000 in profits. The business is taxed as a separate person, and has $6,500 left. With the $1,000 of initial capital, it's worth $7,500. Now, say one investor sells his shares for $7,500 / 10 = $750. How much richer is he? ($750 - $100) = $650. Now, say instead the company pays out all of its profits as a dividend. Each investor receives $6,500 / 10 = $650. The $100 of original investment will of course be recovered when he eventually sells his shares. In each case, the investor is $650 richer than he was previously. What amount should he be taxed on? $650! His net gain is $650. Why should be he taxed any differently on this net gain of $650 for a passive investment than someone who earns $650 in exchange for services?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI'm all in favor of taxing everything similarly. If a person makes $1000 pre-tax on a $100 investment, we should tax the $900 in a single chunk. The tax rate should probably be the same as the individual income tax rate, and it should be the same regardless of whether it is long or short term capital gains, dividends, interest or royalties. My objection is to breaking the tax up into pieces X+Y, and then acting as if the investor only paid Y. That's just a way of complicating the tax system and pretending investors pay less than they really do.
- rayiner 14y agoSay you have a corporation C, owned by an investor I. When C makes $100 of income, it's not I's money. It's C's money. When C pays $35 of taxes on that $100, I isn't paying it. If C pays out a dividend to I, and I pays $10 on it, he's not being taxed ($35 + $10 = $45). He's paying $10. C and I are separate legal persons. Everything is accounted that way. E.g. when the U.S.'s GDP is calculated, C's income ($100) and I's income ($65) are added up and contribute $165 to the U.S. GDP. Yes, the taxes on C reduce the amount available for C to pay I as dividends. But that's true in any transaction between two people. The taxes on my income reduce the amount available for me to pay my nanny, but you don't add together the taxes I pay and the taxes she pays when computing her tax rate.