4 ms·
The trials and tribulations of the poor and rich ends of the spectrum don't tend to surprise me, but the wildly varying ways the middle class perceives their in
by petercooper 14y ago
The trials and tribulations of the poor and rich ends of the spectrum don't tend to surprise me, but the wildly varying ways the middle class perceives their incomes always does.
It surprised me that a family bringing in $900 a week ($47k per year) doesn't feel comfortable in Des Moines (statistically it's above local median). But then they note every 2 weeks they pay $375 for health insurance.. 20.8% of their pre-tax income! Yet their "state and federal" taxes are only about 10%?
For all the bleating about paying "less tax" than other countries, it's ironic that an ostensibly "free market" healthcare system is less efficient, more cartel-like and wildly more expensive for its users than, say, the "socialist" one in the UK where you could live well on the same money and still be paying your fair share without getting any handouts.
- rubashov 14y ago> ostensibly "free market" healthcare system Some guy said of sick care in America: The American health care system is socialism without a central plan, and capitalism without markets or prices. You really have to pick one or the other of socialism or the free market. Our current system is the worst of both worlds.
- michaelochurch 14y agoYou really have to pick one or the other of socialism or the free market. Our current system is the worst of both worlds. That is the essence of contemporary corporatism. It has nothing to do with capitalism or socialism, because it's neither system. The problem is one of social topology, from which money disparities follow, but it's otherwise not really about money per se. Modern corporatism works like this: a well-connected, parasitic elite (~0.5%) gets the best of both systems: the chance of personal enrichment and the freedom of capitalism, and the safety net (up to outright governmental favoritism, as seen in corporate welfare) and low minimal expectations of socialism. The other 99.5% get the worst of both systems.
- ams6110 14y agoAre you excluding the "free" healthcare in the UK from your definition of "handout"? What "fair share" of taxation would they be paying in the UK?
- scarmig 14y agoI've always thought that the most damning part of the UK-US comparison is this: The United States government spends substantially more per capita on healthcare than the UK (a number which, to be clear, excludes people's private spending and if anything understates things because it doesn't include the cost of tax breaks for employer plans), but fails to guarantee healthcare to everyone and has developed an underclass of people who have substantially worse healthcare than many second world countries. The UK system is, in many ways, unique, in that it's severely underfunded but gets outstanding bang for buck. I wouldn't recommend it here, because I'd be pretty skeptical we could transplant the necessary consensus political support and willingness to say no to stupid treatments.
- pacaro 14y agoHere's my take on the UK health care system - these are just anecdotes, but they are illuminating in their own way. I broke my collarbone (clavicle, whatever) snowboarding - I go to see an orthopedic surgeon, or rather I go to the local hospital's orthopedic department and see somebody who I assume is a surgeon (he was in fact an MRCS) who tells me, "Collarbones heal on their own just fine in about 95% of cases" - my response - "According to this very out of focus x-ray I was given in France, my collarbone is in a gazillion pieces - maybe I'm in the 5%" - to which he replies - "Collarbones heal on their own just fine in about 95% of cases, I can write you a sick note". My nephew, my brother's child, was born with what at the time was assumed to be a hole in the heart but which later turned out to be a particularly obnoxious genetic disorder (CHARGE), my brother and his partner lived in a central London hospital for six months while their son lived on life support and underwent open heart surgery. He will need a fairly high level of medical support his entire life, the cost to his parents $0 - in the US this could bankrupt an extended family.
- 14y ago
- deelowe 14y agoIf the american healthcare system is "free market," then I need to retake macro economics. It's such a regulated mess, I don't even know where to begin to point out the flaws in that statement. But, just as an example, I called to get standard billing rates for a specialist a few years ago and they said that patients weren't allowed to receive that information. Free market my arse.
- dialtone 14y agoYour sentence is strangely ironic... You want a completely free market without regulations and yet you are complaining that a company doesn't give out standard billing rates. The idea of the non-regulated free market is that you'd choose with your wallet by going for another health care provider that tells you the billing rates. If you want to force companies to reveal standard rates you are adding regulation. So is regulation needed or not? Not even Adam Smith argued for a free market without regulation... He himself even identified several pain points and warned against "laissez-faire" economy.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIn India's free market healthcare system, I had no difficulty finding out billing rates. The common stuff (e.g., cost of a hospital room or a blood test) was posted on the wall, and the doctors gave me details on more specific stuff. That's at least one data point suggesting that in a free market, prices will become transparent.
- muhfuhkuh 14y agoJapan does that, too. They have a big book doctors follow for every procedure. Their system is regulated, price-fixed, and universal.
- rdl 14y agoPretty much true of dental, optical, and veterinary care in the USA, too (which are often paid directly out of pocket; dental and vision insurance is just a taxable vs. untaxable thing, but doesn't really spread risk like insurance). Rather than focusing on the "meaningful use" EHR stuff, I wish the government would demand machine-readable and easily accessed pricing (list, prevailing, medicare, and all negotiated insurance, as well as actual collection rates) for services, at least from any doctor who accepts medicare or medicaid. Publish this, let people build awesome tools.