3 ms·
Could you define "middle class", and perhaps explain how income inequality "destroys" it? By most common definitions, your statement can't be true. Taking a ty
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Could you define "middle class", and perhaps explain how income inequality "destroys" it? By most common definitions, your statement can't be true.
Taking a typical relative definition, if the middle class is [50-X%, 50+X%], then by definition the middle class always makes up 2X% of the nation and nothing can destroy it.
If you take an absolute definition of middle class (i.e., middle class = home with X ft^2/person, tv, car, refrigerator), then inequality is pretty much unrelated to how many people are middle class.
In short, for your claim to be true, you must be using some uncommon definition of middle class. It would help to explain what it is.
- irishcoffee 14y agohttp://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/01/13/a-shrinking-middle-class-means-a-shrinking-economy/ http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/2012/01/13/a-shrinking... Go to figure 6.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoUsing that definition (people in the range of [0.5 x median, 1.5 x median]), the middle class has only shrank because more people have become rich. http://www.nationalreview.com/agenda/288306/guest-post-scott-winship-obama-administrations-questionable-mobility-claims-reihan-sal http://www.nationalreview.com/agenda/288306/guest-post-scott... The number of people who are middle class or higher has remained contant since 1970. Using Alan Krueger's definitions, all inequality has done is moved people from middle class to rich. Is that a bad thing?
- bonaldi 14y agoYes, if it leaves in its wake massive income inequality. The middle class is the engine of wealth generation. It both spends high proportions of its income and has enough income to start new enterprises. A middle class drives an economy. What you are asking is if it's OK for the middle class of merchants to shrink because many are now rich enough to be lords and kings. That may be, but it still leaves a society with no merchants: only the very poor and very rich.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIt both spends high proportions of its income and has enough income to start new enterprises. Why can't a middle class person who became "rich" (although most people don't consider >1.5x median to be rich) do the same thing? Suppose my income dropped dramatically and I suddenly entered the "middle class" (by Alan Krueger's definition - I'm actually middle class by the definition of most people). How would this make it easier for me to start new enterprises?
- bonaldi 14y agoWhy can't a middle class person who became "rich" (although most people don't consider >1.5x median to be rich) do the same thing? Starting new businesses: It's more a matter of "Don't" than "Can't." A middle-class person who became rich is either tending the business that got them there or has otherwise lost the impetus of need that drove them to start a business. If your income suddenly dropped dramatically, what would you do: adjust to your new income level and be happy, or strive immediately to retain your previous level? Spending income: It's easy to spend 99% of a median income. It's almost impossible for the very wealthy to spend anything like what they make. Additionally, there are only so many needs to be filled. It's more economically productive to have a very large number of people willing and able to buy modestly priced items than it is to have a very small number wanting to buy very highly priced items.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoYou clearly haven't read any of the articles cited in this thread. Alan Krueger defines middle class as more than $25k/year, but less than $75k/year (at contemporary income levels). Rich is presumably $75k or more. The middle class has shrank because people have moved from $65k to $85k. This has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with the very wealthy. If you have evidence that people going from $50k to $80k is bad for the economy, go ahead and present it. You haven't yet. All you've presented are vague misconceptions and demonstrated you don't understand the numbers under discussion.
- 14y ago
- batista 14y ago>Could you define "middle class", and perhaps explain how income inequality "destroys" it? It's political economy 101. I don't understand your bizarro counter-arguments. Take the first for example: >Taking a typical relative definition, if the middle class is [50-X%, 50+X%], then by definition the middle class always makes up 2X% of the nation and nothing can destroy it. It cannot destroy the existence of the category named "middle class", but it can very much destroy its living conditions. It's not just being in the 50%+-X range, it's also what that range represents in purchase power. >If you take an absolute definition of middle class (i.e., middle class = home with X ft^2/person, tv, car, refrigerator), then inequality is pretty much unrelated to how many people are middle class. Only in a bizarro world where the wealth is magically readjusted to account for inequality. In the real world this inequality is caused by wealth moving from the middle to the upper classes. For example, a company moves its factories to China. The middle class families making a living around the US factory and the nearby city are devastated, but the company executives get even richer because of the higher margins.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIt's not just being in the 50%+-X range, it's also what that range represents in purchase power. In the US, the purchasing power of that range has dramatically increased over the years. We live in bigger houses, consume better medicine, more food, more education, more and better electronics and entertainment, etc. I think you'll be hard pressed to find a single category in which contemporary Americans have less than 1970's Americans, for any reasonable value of x. If you dispute this, go ahead and find that single category. Only in a bizarro world where the wealth is magically readjusted to account for inequality. In the real world this inequality is caused by wealth moving from the middle to the upper classes. Are you seriously calling a world of economic growth and technological process "bizarro world"? We have become vastly wealthier than we were at any historical period, ignoring short term fluctuations (e.g., recessions). In the 1970s, the bottom 11% didn't have flush toilets. http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/database/article_display.cfm?HHID=372 http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/database/article_display.cf... For example, a company moves its factories to China. The middle class families making a living around the US factory and the nearby city are devastated, but the company executives get even richer because of the higher margins. Hahaha! Now I know you are writing a parody of something - first complaining about inequality, then complaining about wages becoming more equal.