4 ms·
The Top Gear review was somewhat staged for effect, but did point out a real shortcoming with the vehicle. Top Gear reviews hardly make a difference anyway, I
by ams6110 14y ago
The Top Gear review was somewhat staged for effect, but did point out a real shortcoming with the vehicle.
Top Gear reviews hardly make a difference anyway, I think anyone who has watched even a few episodes knows they exaggerate negatives for entertainment value almost constantly; the Tesla was hardly their only "victim" in this regard.
- ender7 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Gear_controversies#Tesla_Roadster_review http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Top_Gear_controversies#Tesla_Ro... Basically, they imagined the worst that could possibly happen, but when it didn't happen, they pretended that it did anyway. This is kind of like saying "we reviewed your iPhone app. Because apps can crash, we wrote a review describing all the way your app crashing ruined various real-life activities we had, even though your app never actually crashed."
- sambe 14y agoTop Gear is highly influential both in terms of viewing figures and general perception. Of all the people I know who saw the episode, they all had genuine reservations and believed it to be about accurate journalism, not comedy. Second, as another reply points out, they did not really point out genuine shortcomings but rather fabricated events and used strawmen. If you analyse existing usage of sports cars, you will probably find the vast majority are used for short and medium distance driving on the road, not cross-continent or highly intensive race track driving. Hence the design and marketing of the Tesla.
- anothermachine 14y agoIf they take Top Gear seriously, the people you know surely are not intelligent enough to amass the resources to by a Tesla roadster.
- jomohke 14y agoIt's not a matter of intelligence. It may be a comedy, but most of their reviews are grounded in some level of truth, and for many people the segment will have been their only exposure to electric vehicles.
- aggie 14y agoNot to mention they pulled the same "joke" when reviewing the Nissan Leaf.
- sliverstorm 14y agoref. the poor Morris Marina
- baggers 14y agoI'd also bet that Ariel did pretty well after the top gear review of the Atom.
- ScottBurson 14y agoThey convinced my wife she didn't want a Prius. I bought her one anyway, and she loves it. As far as I'm concerned, the Top Gear guys are hucksters.
- pkulak 14y agoThe Prius hate is amazing. They drive it on a race track and conclude that it's a crappy car. Because, apparently, that's what that car was built for...
- jlgreco 14y agoI don't get what is so amazing by it. I would be surprised if they came to any other conclusion... it's Top Gear for crying out loud.