5 ms·
I agree. It is a scandal that reporters constantly focus on the individual tax bill of investors while completely ignoring taxes paid by the corporations they o
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
I agree. It is a scandal that reporters constantly focus on the individual tax bill of investors while completely ignoring taxes paid by the corporations they own.
The solution is simple: stop taxing corporations and replace it with taxes on capital gains/etc. (Also, while we are at it, equalize the taxation of cap gains, dividends and interest.)
- scarmig 14y agoIndeed. Corporate taxation makes for good applause lines, but at least in our particular system it's basically a giant target for "lobby for special tax breaks, but only if you're rich enough to hire a staff of lobbyists." My favored solution is having two taxes: a heavily progressive consumption tax, and a flat capital gains/etc. tax. Because what people usually are bothered by are the Paris Hiltons of the world, not the humble billionaire featured in the article.
- msellout 14y agoHow about an externality tax? Anything that hurts anyone else, even via causing jealousy, gets taxed as appropriate for the size of the externality.
- scarmig 14y agoTaxing externalities is, of course, a good idea, and key to any functioning system of property rights. I don't believe they should be used for revenues, because once you do that, it misplaces the incentive: now the government makes more revenue per unit externality. So I favor a flat rebate for all externality taxes.
- dtby 14y ago[Hopefully you've got showdead on.] I find this to be a somewhat odd position. I think it's much more morally defensible to argue for raising corporate taxes and eliminating capital gains taxes. This acknowledges that corporations owe their existence to the state, while natural persons do not. Is your position based on the premise that personal income taxes are good and necessary? Or, perhaps, an acknowledgement that dismantling that system is probably unattainable?
- KaoruAoiShiho 14y agoWouldn't that be great for foreign investors?
- yequalsx 14y agoIt's a simple sounding solution but I'm skeptical of the issue being that simple. There's a world of difference between GE style corporation and an S-corp owned by a single person. The GE type corporations effectively pay very little tax in the present system. They also have the right to spend an unlimited amount of money on election campaigns. In the U.S. system corporations are treated as persons. If a person makes an income (profit) they get taxed. What we presently have is a broken system in my opinion. The very rich earn their money through capital gains and the capital gains tax is very, very low. The very wealthy in the U.S. do not pay a fair share of the tax burden or for the cost of government. Perhaps eliminating corporate taxes while simultaneously greatly increasing capital gains taxes would be good. There could also be some bad consequences to eliminating corporate taxes altogether.
- twoodfin 14y agoThe very wealthy in the U.S. do not pay a fair share of the tax burden or for the cost of government. They don't?? The top 1% of taxpayers paid 36.7% of all income taxes in 2009[1] (yes, that includes capital gains). The top 10% paid 70%! [1] http://ntu.org/tax-basics/who-pays-income-taxes.html http://ntu.org/tax-basics/who-pays-income-taxes.html
- yequalsx 14y agoOne needs to look at overall tax receipts. Not just income taxes. The very wealthy primarily pay capital gains taxes and not income taxes. Also, the 36.7% figure is not meaningful without knowing the percentage of wealth the very rich control.
- luminaobscura 14y agoso actually Top 10% pays more than 70% of the taxes when we also consider capital gains (because they are the ones who play with the capital) well, i think we all should be grateful for the %10, we are basically funded by them. Thank you rich folks!
- 14y ago
- rubashov 14y ago> replace it with taxes on capital gains The reasons capital gains taxes are lower than income seem sound to me. You want capital formation and savings. There's only a problem because the government inflates the currency and manipulates interest rates down. This subsidizes speculation. The solution is just higher interest rates.
- rprasad 14y agoThe problem is not that capital gains are taxed at lower rates; the problem is that the rate differential between capital gains and ordinary income is currently too large. It incentivizes fake investment (in speculative investments) rather than savings (ordinary income) or businesses (which earn ordinary income). Higher interest rates will help increase savings, but it will do little to address the incentivization of speculative markets caused by the tax rate differential. The solution is to increase interest rates and reduce the tax rate differential (either by increasing capital gains taxes or lowering income taxes).
- rubashov 14y agoThe successful speculations are predicated on artificially low interest rates and subsidized leverage.
- msellout 14y agoThe amount of savings in the economy is exactly equal to the amount of investment. Changing the capital gains tax rate does not affect how much investment takes place, but instead affects the choice of investment vehicle.