4 ms·
Is it, though? Your entire body and brain is a complex and messy chemical reaction. The opening sentence of the wikipedia article on addiction currently reads
by ben_w 2y ago
Is it, though?
Your entire body and brain is a complex and messy chemical reaction.
The opening sentence of the wikipedia article on addiction currently reads: "Addiction is a neuropsychological disorder characterized by a persistent and intense urge to use a drug or engage in a behavior that produces natural reward, despite substantial harm and other negative consequences."
The page then lists "eating or food addiction" as examples, with food addiction being its own entire page.
- Alupis 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thierrydamiba 2y agoI think the best example here is compare the crimes people commit to get burgers and the crimes they commit to get fent.
- ben_w 2y agoThat would only work if you could get fentanyl for a few dollars at every fast food joint. Or if burgers were a thing you had to go to an illegal dealer for.
- Alupis 2y agoHow about people just try not up-sizing their drink and fries? Or order one burger instead of two or three? These are all choices.
- ben_w 2y agoWhy do you think people persistently, for years, keep choosing something that harmed their bodies? Just because you can do something, doesn't make it a "just" for everyone: • Without any training, one day I decided to put one foot in front of the other and keep going, and managed 42 km, a literal marathon in distance — but it's obvious that, even though I was walking, most people can't do that. • When I was at university, I gamified my diet to be the lowest cost without feeling hungry, and in retrospect that was probably 1100 kcal/day and only even safe because it was limited to term time, and it's really obvious that most people can't do that. • Concersely, when I was on antidepressants and did graze myself into obesity, there simply wasn't a part of my mind aware of what I was doing to myself. I've lost that weight, but the strech marks are still there a decade later.
- Someone1234 2y agoI'm going to change one word of what you posted: > I realize people are trying to make over opiod abuse into some sort of addiction. It makes it easier to not blame the person and absolves them of all personal responsibility for their condition - they just can't help themselves, don't ya know! I change one addiction to another addiction. If people find the above distasteful, I agree, but my question is why do you believe one thing for food addiction and another thing for other addictions?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Alupis 2y agoLet me ask you, does one become addicted to opioids by accident? Or did they make a choice to start using opioids? So their addiction was a choice - and now they have developed a chemical dependency which is no longer a choice. There is no such chemical dependency from eating two cheeseburgers for dinner instead of one.
- beeboobaa3 2y ago> There is no such chemical dependency from eating two cheeseburgers for dinner instead of one. Apparently not in your body, no. Or maybe you just failed to recognize what addiction is, and managed to overcome it. Good job! Now stop trying to pretend that your lived experience equals everyone else's because it clearly doesn't.
- ben_w 2y agoIf they started using them without informed consent, was it a choice? And even then, you do have a chemical dependancy on enough calories, that dependency led to an evolved response mechanism, that mechanism is exploited by junk food manufacturers. That the substances your body and brain produce in response to food stimuli are endogenous (made in your own body) rather than exogenous (made outside) doesn't make them magically less potent — some of us can get past this with our willpower*, but observationally it's obvious that most of us can't. * I seem to have a lot of willpower, but I suspect that's mainly that my conscious self is fairly oblivious to my body's needs, as my willpower also leads to me pushing myself too hard in various different ways.
- tmpz22 2y agoCan you acknowledge your own bias in condemning people who don't achieve the same thing you have achieved? Can you acknowledge any advantages you may have had that made it easier for you to succeed in this particular endeavor?
- Alupis 2y ago[flagged]
- JoshTriplett 2y ago> That is just not the reality though. You make a choice. Brains are fascinating. There is a choice being made every time someone with gambling addiction goes to gamble or someone with a smoking addiction goes to smoke, but that doesn't mean they're not experiencing addiction/withdrawal distorting the ability to make that choice in a healthy fashion. Some people do manage to quit smoking by just making a decision one day to stop and sticking with it, with no assistance whatsoever; that doesn't mean they weren't experiencing addiction/withdrawal. There are, in fact, mechanisms that encourage addictive behavior, ranging from social media use to alcohol to food to MMORPGs. Not everyone who uses those things, even to excess, has an addiction. But some do. And breaking that addiction is laudable, whether with or without assistance.
- rixed 2y agoThis is not about that. This is about why you consider some bad habits are addictions and some others are not. I don't know, maybe you are right, but you haven't provided any beginning of an answer yet. Rather, you sound like you would be saying that "quitting alcohol is merely a question of personal choice" if you had struggled with alcohol rather than weight.
- datavirtue 2y agoRight, or you can just own up to the fact that you do not have discipline and are indeed making detrimental choices for yourself. That alone is transformative, accepting responsibility.
- croes 2y agoThat doesn't prove it's an addiction. More likely it's listed as one so insurance company pay for the drugs. Addiction treatment gets payed, low self control not. Half Bake- Thur good goes to rehab NSFW https://youtu.be/uUPHlAbAf2I?si=TVVxffFprAtdJyAk https://youtu.be/uUPHlAbAf2I?si=TVVxffFprAtdJyAk