5 ms·
I like the idea behind Hipmunk, but it doesn't really work with how I personally pick travel. I generally have an airline in mind first. If I want to fly to S
by rdl 14y ago
I like the idea behind Hipmunk, but it doesn't really work with how I personally pick travel.
I generally have an airline in mind first. If I want to fly to Seattle, I basically know my choices are VX, UA, AK. If I want to fly to Hong Kong, I'll try hard to be on CX, or failing that, SQ, or UA (to use the eBayed SWU to be in business for +$300 over cheap coach). To Kuwait, UA or LH.
Alternatively, I want to know "when will flights to (exotic destination) be cheap" -- the best choice for that is still Kayak. Flyer Talk is also a good source of information, because when an airline runs a 3x miles qualifying special, a $500 transpac costs about $0 if you value the miles to hit a tier.
If I need to fly at specific times, it's usually bounded on one side -- get from point A to point B either leaving as late as possible or arriving as early as possible. Longer layovers aren't a big deal, so it's search for the relevant time first, then optimize.
For hotels, it's the same thing -- I know of a specific hotel I want to use (Pen or MO or one of the good SPG properties in BKK), or I'm trying to maximize SPG status/points and shop Starwood, or want to find something as cheap/deal as possible (usually Vegas). Couch-of-friend or AirBnB also come in, especially if the preliminary hotel search fails. I rarely care where in a city I'm staying as much as the property itself.
There clearly is something better than the current travel sites, but for me, Hipmunk isn't it (yet).
- dbaupp 14y ago> I generally have an airline in mind first Isn't the point of the flight search sites to list all/most of the options that do a given trip, so you don't have to think about the details of which airlines fly where? (This is assuming there aren't other reasons, like rewards programs with specific airlines or safety concerns.)
- rdl 14y agoThere are lots of prices not in GDSes, so they won't appear on Hipmunk. :(
- shalmanese 14y agoWelcome to being an outlier.
- davidw 14y agoYep, my guess is that people who instantly grok > when an airline runs a 3x miles qualifying special, a $500 transpac costs about $0 if you value the miles to hit a tier. Are a small percentage of people who fly. Of course, they probably spend a lot of money flying, so are worth their own sites, but they're likely a different target.
- rdl 14y agoI think most people who fly live in crappy underserved markets with a single airline, so there's really only one choice anyway. The people with discretion are in multi-airline hubs (or within driving distance of multiple), or flying international routes (where anyone who does it frequently probably does have strong preferences). The tool I want is ITA/GFS + certain Sabre features + Kayak + Tripit + Flyertalk, all rolled in one. Would be appealing to a few hundred thousand (or maybe a few million) flyers, but people who fly a lot, and often in premium cabins; 10-100x more flight dollars, maybe 10x more flight miles, than the infrequent holiday market.
- saryant 14y agoIf I were trying to get into this market I'd try to find something I could sell to United 1Ks and AA ExPlats. I'll take ten of them over 100 leisure flyers. That market, however, is probably booking directly through their respective airlines or a corporate TA. Makes it tough to break into.
- rdl 14y agoNot always; there are a lot of the hardcore travelers who hate their corp TA, and who want to maintain status with 2+ airlines. Add in hotels, and there's a market. Especially if you fly international a lot -- the foreign airlines are usually pretty bad at handling principals who make their own travel reservations, and most of the <40yo tech/law/etc. professionals who have to travel a lot prefer doing their own arrangements (with help) to blindly trusting someone else. There's also a market for people who fly a huge amount but are cheap and micro-optimizers. Not enough $ to get United Global Services, but 1K, and 1K doesn't actually help much except at the airport (and clearing waitlists). The other market might be lazy/late optimization. i.e. passively looking at your travel patterns, and if I see you fly in J/F SFO-IAD-KWI once a month for 6 months, proactively negotiating a rate with UA for you to do so at a discount in the future. That's not something UA will offer, but something a company or group could push for based on observed travel, especially if they can present LH as a credible alternative.
- gcb 14y agoHear this guy. The hole purpose of being the best tool is to expose the effectiveness of the insider to the regular folk. If anyone thinks "the best travel search" shouldn't do all this guy says and more, then go back to using aol or something