3 ms·
I would say that brain asymmetry probably is not the cause of hand and leg asymmetry. It has to do either with venomous [1] plants and animals or with muscle us
by emporas 2y ago
I would say that brain asymmetry probably is not the cause of hand and leg asymmetry. It has to do either with venomous [1] plants and animals or with muscle use and fatigue.
When the hand is stung or burned it performs a quick centrifugal movement instinctively. Then many mammals can suck some blood out with their mouths. That minimizes the venom in circulation, and some additional time to get to the heart might be less damaging, especially when the venom is not very plentiful like bees, scorpions etc.
When the venom is of a big quantity, like big snakes then probably it doesn't make a difference.
One other factor is muscle isolation and helping the heart to not get tired from work. Considering that the whole point of gyms is muscle isolation, which is very difficult to achieve normally, a human or monkey cracking nuts or cracking bones for hours, it will tire the left side (where the heart is located) much more increase palpitations, and consequently the risk for heart attack.
That last one could be tested, working more using the left hand -> increase palpitations or not. As a counter example, the chimp when it cracks the turtle, it works with both hands [2].
[1] Venomous not poisonous i misspoke previously.
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7dRvX2f9Rs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7dRvX2f9Rs
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoYour reasoning makes no sense. Using your left hand to crack nuts vs your right hand makes no difference as far as your heart is concerned. If you are working hard enough to increase your metabolic rate, then your heart will be pumping faster in either case. Also, your theory that increased exercise leads to heart attacks is the opposite of reality!
- emporas 2y agoExercise prevents heart attacks when you have excessive calories, you get adequate sleep and do not sleep outside in the winter, you have a dry place to stand and are not out in the rain and so on. Exercise leads to muscle loss when the fat reserves are depleted and calorie intake is limited. Anyway there are ways to falsify or verify that hypothesis, but it needs some resources, not much but still, it needs time and subjects to test the hypothesis on. So for the foreseeable future, it will stay as it is, a hypothesis.
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoIf your hypothesis was true, then it'd be glaringly obvious, because there'd be a high correlation between left handedness and increased lifespan.