5 ms·
The Age of Depopulation
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> Eventually, in 1994, the economist Lant Pritchett discovered the most powerful national fertility predictor ever detected. That decisive factor turned out to be simple: what women want. Because survey data conventionally focus on female fertility preferences, not those of their husbands or partners, scholars know much more about women’s desire for children than men’s. Pritchett determined that there is an almost one-to-one correspondence around the world between national fertility levels and the number of babies women say they want to have. This finding underscored the central role of volition—of human agency—in fertility patterns. I want to draw attention to this specific quote, because it gets to the root cause of the depopulation situation. Fertility rates are aligning to desired fertility of women, and while this perspective might seem dated based on the 1994 date in the quote, I believe there is substantial evidence that this thesis still holds true today (citations provided in my comments in the subthread below). If this is indeed the case, and population decline is truly caused by aggregate intentional choice with regards to reduced/lower fertility, it is unlikely this (if one considers it a challenge) can be solved for by increasing fertility rates via policy. Therefore, humanity should attempt to forecast the future, and plan mitigations and contingencies around the fact there there will be less humans and labor in the future.
- FirmwareBurner 2y ago[flagged]
- toomuchtodo 2y agoPick up a copy of Empty Planet: The Shock of Global Population Decline by Darrell Bricker and John Ibbitson; ISBN13: 9781984823229. Contains interviews with women indicating what I quoted from various cultures. Women want less children than men and society want them to have (TLDR). https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/545397/empty-planet-by-darrell-bricker-and-john-ibbitson/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/545397/empty-planet... (“Once a woman receives enough information and autonomy to make an informed and self-directed choice about when to have children, and how many to have, she immediately has fewer of them, and has them later.”) https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(20)30677-2/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6... | https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30677-2 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(20)30677-2 ("Our findings suggest that continued trends in female educational attainment and access to contraception will hasten declines in fertility and slow population growth. A sustained TFR lower than the replacement level in many countries, including China and India, would have economic, social, environmental, and geopolitical consequences. Policy options to adapt to continued low fertility, while sustaining and enhancing female reproductive health, will be crucial in the years to come.") https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#what-explains-the-declining-fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#what-explains-the-... ("Our World in Data: What explains the declining fertility rate?") https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2024/07/25/the-experiences-of-u-s-adults-who-dont-have-children/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2024/07/25/the-exp... ("Pew Research: 57% of adults under 50 who say they’re unlikely to ever have kids say a major reason is they just don’t want to; 31% of those ages 50 and older without kids cite this as a reason they never had them") https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-data https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-... ("64% of young women say they just don't want children, compared to 50% of men.") https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-68402139 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-68402139 ("Why South Korean women aren't having babies: The reason women are not having children now is because they have the courage to talk about it.")
- Hutrio 2y ago[dead]
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago> Pick up a copy of Empty Planet Haven't read this, thanks for the recommendation. > Once a woman receives enough information and autonomy to make an informed and self-directed choice about when to have children, and how many to have, she immediately has fewer of them, and has them later. I do not agree with this premise. > adults under 50 who say they’re unlikely to ever have kids say a major reason is they just don’t want to This is like asking the anorexic why they don't eat and believing them when they tell you that they're "just not hungry".
- toomuchtodo 2y agoReality stands on its own without belief in it. Even in countries with robust (ie expensive) pro natalist fiscal policy, it does not materially improve the fertility rate. I ask, out of curiosity, what you do believe the culprit is and what your data to back the assertion is (if the cause is not empowered women making fertility choices). https://reason.com/2023/05/02/storks-dont-take-orders-from-the-state/ https://reason.com/2023/05/02/storks-dont-take-orders-from-t... ("South Korea spent more than $200 billion subsidizing child care and parental leave over the past 16 years, President Yoon Suk Yeol said last fall. Yet the fertility rate fell from 1.1 in 2006 to 0.81 in 2021. The amount of money required to trigger even these small effects is enormous. In "The Economic Consequences of Family Policies," published in the Journal of Economic Perspectives in 2017, researchers found "one extra percentage point of GDP spending" on early childhood education and child care programs was "associated with 0.2 extra children per woman." In the U.S., where the 2022 GDP was $25.46 trillion, that would mean spending more than $250 billion.") https://www.nber.org/papers/w23051 https://www.nber.org/papers/w23051 ("The Economic Consequences of Family Policies: Lessons from a Century of Legislation in High-Income Countries")
- RGamma 2y agoKinda wonder if/how we could/should turn having (and caring for!) children into its own serious career. As in: Have 8 well-tended children and you're top 10% of disposable income (someone needs to work out the math on this).
- HeuristicsCG 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- adamc 2y agoI think the author is right that comparatively few people have really bent their heads around this. But I am reminded of the Club of Rome studies in the 1970s, when a more Malthusian future seemed inevitable. Trends don't necessarily continue; very often, they change the circumstance that gave rise to the trend in some way. When populations are half what they are now, housing will likely be cheaper, wages higher, the share of wealth controlled by the elderly lower. Maybe that will change the trend. Interesting times coming. Not necessarily happy ones, but.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoAbandoned houses with no youthful labor to repair will have little value as a place to live. It’s not like available housing in Montana will change prices near NYC.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIt would be wise to build today for service life of whatever is being built (housing, infrastructure, etc) that anticipates many less humans available in the future to maintain.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y agoThat just front-loads a cost that is no more affordable today than it will be later. Everything is so expensive now that we're constantly trying to cut corners just to be able to pay for it. We can't add another 80% (or more) to that so that old geezers 100 years from now won't have to put new shingles on the roof.
- Retric 2y agoBuilding for longer lifespans is generally fairly cheap. You’d be amazed with how far a 10% larger budget can take you, but builders are selling to buyers who don’t really understand the trade offs.
- Retric 2y ago
- aklemm 2y agoWhat's the case for higher population? As someone who spends time actually in the wild, my perspective is we've used up enough of that and can't afford to take any more. Population growth seems required by modern economies, but is there some other requirement I'm not aware of making that growth desirable? Let's fix the growth-based economies and move on with fewer but better-off people.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoHigher population spreads out the cost of technology making it affordable. Right now 5 workers support every retiring boomer, this will drop to less than 2 in our old age. Spending time in the wild may be more unlikely as the time required to maintain a lifestyle grows beyond the number of hours in a day.
- kiba 2y agoPollution has more to do with high intensity resource usage and unpriced negative externality than the # of people who are alive. For example, meat is much more energy intense because you require farmland to not only feed people, but also the cows. It also pollutes more, in addition to being more expensive to buy, but not expensive enough to cover all the damage being done to the environment. Also, increased efficiency is a form of economic growth. We are after all doing more with less. Another important thing to consider is that population size allows and enable certain economic activities to exist. For example, I go to theater and do theater activities, but theater can only exist if enough people go to theater. That threshold can be more easily reached if your theater is in a city. If you want computer to exists, you need a certain amount of specialists dedicated to that. You need a large population because not everyone cares about computing and there are essential tasks that first need to be taken of such as agriculture and grocery stores and trains. Finally, economic growth is desirable the same reason improving technology is desirable. It enables more capabilities. The bad side is when we abuse these capabilities, not that these capabilities are bad in itself.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago> What's the case for higher population? I don't think you understand the math of this. It's not that anyone wants a higher population, it's that the spectrum is a little screwed up. There's this line in the middle (fertility rate 2.1), and anything to the right of that is "population spirals out of control". Then everything to the left of it is "human extinction in just a few centuries". We're currently on the "human extinction in a few centuries". And all the arguments that we're not are positively stupid. People seem to think that we're like moose on some island, that "population bounces back" (it does for animals, because their fertility rate never goes below replacement, so when population pressures subside, their populations recover). Every time you ask "what's the case for higher population", you're actually helping to murder our entire species. If you were rational, you'd be pushing the idea that we need that 2.1 fertility rate, the one that doesn't result in higher population, and doesn't result in human extinction.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marcusverus 2y ago> So far, government attempts to incentivize childbearing have failed to bring fertility rates back to replacement levels. Future government policy, regardless of its ambition, will not stave off depopulation. I find this to be amusing, because as far as I can tell government policies are a major cause of depopulation in the first place. Women don't want to have children because having children is no longer a net positive. Having children is no longer a net positive because they are not relied upon in old age--the government will support you with medicare, medicaid, etc. If women felt that having children was a requirement to be taken care of in old age, they'd go right back to having four kids each. On the bright side, this problem seems likely (in the absence of extreme levels of immigration) to solve itself naturally. As the population curve inverts further, we'll have fewer resources to take care of our elders, and young women will realize that having a few kids (who can support them later) is vastly preferable to the alternative of spending their old age in squalor--just as it used to be.
- RGamma 2y agoYou may be overestimating the subjective importance of elderly care/life span maximization. I think many would be just as fine with assisted suicide in that setting. I, for one, would rather not end up as a demented mummy which I've seen plenty enough of. Sure there's pre-terminal scenarios where adult children may be of help, but different living arrangements could mitigate that. IIRC I've read that even pre-modern cities have often suffered from below replacement fertility, propped up by countryside migration. Children are decent laborers for subsistence farmers. But yeah, as others have pointed out, it may well be a socially contagious mood that's causing the current trend. Personally, I'd like to think it's having to do with our imposing technosphere causing wildlife extinction, global warming, etc and a desire for better balance, but that may be too optimistic.
- spacemadness 2y agoI find it disturbing how obsessed HN is with population decline. There is a new article about it every few days.
- seacos 2y agoProbably because there's a lot of smart people here. Demographics is the one trend that overpowers any other. Technologies, Productivity, GDP, Debt, Religion, Culture, all pale in comparison. Paying attention to that is important. Although I understand your sentiment, in the end we're all dead.
- aklemm 2y agoThe lords of tech are obsessed with it because they exploit the macro economy so it makes sense the accolytes here would follow suit
- theageofdecay 2y ago[dead]