8 ms·
Indian entrepreneur, industrialist, and philanthropist, Ratan Tata, dead at 86
- insiderinsider 2y agoOne of the best humans of the world
- sandeep1998 2y agoOm Shanti
- hackernewds 2y ago[flagged]
- saagarjha 2y agoThat's because it's the moral equivalent of posting "RIP" or similar.
- alienonwings 2y agoThat's "RIP" for Indians.
- pknerd 2y agoHindus, precisely.
- infocollector 2y agohttps://www.reuters.com/world/india/ratan-tata-indias-tata-conglomerate-dies-age-86-2024-10-09/ https://www.reuters.com/world/india/ratan-tata-indias-tata-c...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ravins 2y agoOm Shanti
- wanderingmind 2y agoPeople will talk about his different contribution to economy and philanthropy. However, my favorite is the story where he instructed his hotel employees to treat stray dogs well if they enter the premises. For a man of his wealth and power, to care about a stray dog truly speaks to his humble nature. RIP Sir, you were a crown jewel of the post independence India. https://m.economictimes.com/magazines/panache/ratan-tata-instructs-taj-hotel-mumbai-to-be-a-refuge-for-a-stray-pup-picture-goes-viral/articleshow/110569888.cms https://m.economictimes.com/magazines/panache/ratan-tata-ins...
- talonx 2y agoI came here to comment about the same thing.
- aitchnyu 2y agoOn one hand, stray dogs are a joy for many Indians. For many months the highlight of the day was going to a cafe at 10 pm in middle of work and throwing bones to the assembled dogs. On the other hand, they enter homes and kill babies, attack children and adults and carry rabies epidemics. Right thing to do is to prevent more strays from happening.
- blackwateragent 2y agoA little ignorant here, could you explain a little more on this part. > the highlight of the day was going to a cafe at 10 pm in middle of work Is it 'normal' to have to work late to 10pm, or does it mean second job, etc.? Or was that just a typo and you meant 10am? My gut instinct is 10am, but wanted to ask directly out of curiosity if I was wrong and get a better cultural understanding.
- k1kingy 2y agoNight shift/2nd shift is a thing.
- blackwateragent 2y ago
- RigelKentaurus 2y agoHe was one of the few industrialists who gave capitalism a good name. He was never one to do ostentatious displays of wealth or buy islands. He used his vast wealth and influence in the best possible way. RIP.
- hackernewds 2y agoThey gauge he would've been the richest person in the world at many points, if not for his generous philanthropy
- codetiger 2y agoWhile the internet is flooded with thousands of posts about his demise, this statement you made is what I 100% agree.
- 2Gkashmiri 2y agoAs someone who stays far from politics, ratan tata and tata group in particular are the extraordinary entities who do opposite of enshitification. They dont cut corners (like everyone) and are highly regarded as being genuinely good. Case in point. From a tax perspective, historically reliance indistries was always known for being sneaky around taxes, dodging taxes, finding loopholes and such. Tata OTOH, they are historically regarded as being much more honest and trustworthy in this regard.
- profsummergig 2y agoTata could have been much, much bigger. But to the extent they could get away with it, they refused to pay bribes to politicians and government employees (they couldn't refuse to pay "any and all" bribes, for they would have been shut down completely if they took that posture).
- 2Gkashmiri 2y agoyeah. there is a difference between "Speed money" and actual bribes for officials to look the other way when you are doing clearly not legal stuff.
- profsummergig 2y agoIn India it's not even "speed money" that you used to have to pay (don't know how bad it is these days). It's "being allowed to play" money.
- 2Gkashmiri 2y agowell yeah. if you put it that way, i can talk about indirect taxes and corruption is from even smallest of government employees all the way to the top. we call it "service charges". the officer has discretion to impose taxes, interest or penalty and on payment of service charges, discretion to look away, not mention the issue for later on. in case the issue arises, or goes to litigation, service money ensures the officer will say yes its good to any reply you give.
- uptownfunk 2y agoOne of the greatest entrepreneurs in the world. I hope they make a movie on him and his life.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoAn actual news report would be helpful from any of the 15 other submissions OP: Indian tycoon Ratan Tata dies aged 86 https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cjd5835mp4ko https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cjd5835mp4ko
- oguz-ismail 2y ago[flagged]
- mcint 2y agoYou have a chance to speak eloquently or clearly against his life, his work, or his impacts. I'm curious to hear a contribution to conversation, but I find it easiest to guess a dislike the idea of very wealthy individuals.
- mcint 2y agoArguably black-bar material. Outside view, it seems like he served a tenure atop a group comparable to Disney, in breadth, scale, and market share across many industries in India, as a magnate. Notably, in the period of massive telecom rollout in India. Largest wholly owned and most advanced subsea fibre network, carrying around 30% of the world’s internet routes - Brave.com's Llama, sourced from Tata sites Note "30% of the world’s internet routes" is BGP burden to other operators, but by the same token, a sign of widely distributed control of networks. As an investor, "first Indian to buy a stake in Xiaomi" among dozens of startup investments. "Some senior executives from Xiaomi were quoted saying that they would seek Ratan Tata’s advice on how to expand globally." As a philanthropist, perhaps larger still in relevance to seeding, supporting, & growing the hacker community, his philanthropy on US college campuses in tech, biotech & genetics, and scholarships, serve to support more bright, hungry, creative individuals to learn in the US.
- hackernewds 2y agoI'm finding it really tough to understand your comment across the flipflopping of formats. Here’s a clearer and more concise version of your text: Comment from mcint on HN: From an external perspective, he can be viewed as a magnate who led a group comparable to Disney in terms of breadth, scale, and market share across multiple industries in India. His leadership was particularly notable during the massive telecom rollout in the country. He oversaw the largest wholly owned and most advanced subsea fiber network, responsible for carrying around 30% of the world’s internet routes (source: Brave.com’s Llama, via Tata). While the "30% of the world’s internet routes" signifies a burden on BGP for other operators, it also highlights the distributed control of global networks. As an investor, he was the first Indian to acquire a stake in Xiaomi, among many other startup investments. Some Xiaomi executives even noted that they sought Ratan Tata’s advice on global expansion. As a philanthropist, his contributions are even more impactful. He has supported the hacker community, donated to US college campuses in tech, biotech, and genetics, and funded scholarships to foster talented, driven individuals who come to learn in the US.
- benjaminwootton 2y agoIs this a GenAI comment responding to a GenAI comment?
- hyperbrainer 2y agoTata as a company has had near-unrivalled impact on the economy of India. Godspeed. RIP
- boilerupnc 2y agoOm Shanti
- rocode2 2y agoFor those who don’t know, Om shanti means may he rest in peace. Its usually chanted during cremation as Oooooommmmm Shantiii. Om (the same sound as you chant during yoga sometimes) in this context is like a moment of silence Shanti means peace, in this context, eternal peace.
- Gentil 2y agoI don't think people outside India understand what Tata means. Who Ratan Tata was. He was not some random rich person who did some philanthropy. ~66% of everything that Tata companies make goes back to philanthropy and the people of India. And these days to people where Tata companies operates (I presume). To the TATAs, people are of primary importance. They are a behemoth of a group comparable to Samsung or other big companies/conglomorates. They don't deceive, they don't put money over people. Because their mission IS to the people. You can buy a Tata product with a level of trust that no other brand can provide. Seeing TATA along with a product is more than enough. They are the best definition of capitalism I have ever come across. This is why you don't see Ratan Tatas in billionaire's list or rich people's list. Everything India is because of the Tatas. They single handledly is responsible for building India's foundations. Whether it is in Health, Nuclear, Tech or anywhere. You will see Tata's presence everywhere. I genuinely shed a tear today morning because of his passing. And I am not sure I would do the same for any other business man. Today is indeed a sad day. May he rest in peace.
- pkphilip 2y agoThe reputation of the Tata group is not as stellar as it was under the leadership of JRD Tata. Nonetheless, it is one of the few large industrial groups in India to go above and beyond their commercial interests to look at the interests of Indians as a whole. I remember the day JRD Tata died. I was still in college then and I had an overwhelming sense of grief over his death. It was a huge loss to lose a man of his caliber and my grief was for the country. With Ratan Tata, it is similar but not on the same scale as JRD.
- Gentil 2y agoProbably. I don't think it's possible to please everybody. Also, under Rata Tata, Tata went truly global. I can only presume that it means increased responsibilities & increased issues. JRD Tata didn't go through the same problems as Ratan Tata did. And I don't mean that JRD Tata struggled less. Or more for the matter. The problems were simply different. There is also the fact that we humans are connected 24/7 unlike previous generations. This also means you don't hear the negativity or problems like we do today about someone. This is the norm these days. If you need to find the same for older generations, you really need to dig through it. I say this cos everyone I admire from yester generations come out with a lot more mistakes and issues as I learn more about them. I find it humane. It just makes them human. What I admire about Ratan Tata is that he tried to be better person. As much as he can. And he was one of the nicest human as well. That is enough. :)
- pkphilip 2y agoThis is a huge blow. For those not familiar with the history of Tata group of companies and their influence over India, they will not understand the significance of this death.
- ksampath02 2y agoMay he rest in peace, his name will be remembered and impact felt for long.
- throwaway10oct 2y agoThrowaway account here, but I think we should be cautious about hero worship. While it's true that Tata has contributed positively in many areas, there are also significant controversies surrounding his legacy—like leasing coal mines for just 25 paise for 999 years before independence(1), among other issues(2) It's important to consider both the positives and negatives to form a well-rounded opinion. Let's aim to be informed and objective rather than blindly idolizing anyone. (1) https://www.firstpost.com/business/a-tata-coalgate-999-yr-mine-lease-at-25p-a-bigha-502200.html https://www.firstpost.com/business/a-tata-coalgate-999-yr-mi... (2) https://www.bhopal.net/the-ugly-face-of-tata/ https://www.bhopal.net/the-ugly-face-of-tata/
- fakedang 2y agoSo Ratan Tata was responsible for leasing coal mines in 1946 when he was 9 years old? At those prices, the guy was a **ing prodigy. This is like aiming for the trees and missing the forest - the corrupt entity here is the Indian government which facilitates such corruption and monopolization and makes it hard for new entrants to compete.
- eklavya 2y ago[flagged]
- mlnj 2y agoI too am a big fan of not supporting hero worship. But what we should recognize is the deeds that they perform and the values that they uphold rather than supporting them in everything they do. Having met the guy multiple times growing up he always stood out to me as a very humble man that loved the people and the institution he built. His love for dogs was something that helped me be closer to animals. With regards to the comments about post-independence industrialization, most countries go through that phase where industrialists of the time stand to gain very lucrative opportunities to build value.
- tightbookkeeper 2y agoExactly. Contribution ethic vs purity ethic.
- __coder__ 2y agoHe was very humble person , never showed off his wealth, and mostly followed responsible capitalism, these are the reason why many indians see him as an inspiration. RIP sir
- p2hari 2y agoom shanti.
- alienonwings 2y agoOm Shanti
- Karrot_Kream 2y agoEven among the diaspora Ratan Tata is well known and loved. A shining gem in a country full of corruption. Om Shanti Sir.
- Imustaskforhelp 2y agoAs an Indian , this news is absolutely heartbreaking. Ratan Tata was a gem to India May his soul rest in peace. This news has really taken me a back
- yas_hmaheshwari 2y agoI am with you. I am personally feeling bad that he died. Can't remember any time in recent history when a person with whom I have no personal connecting died, and it is impacting me so much
- shipp02 2y agoJRD Tata and Ratan Tata are among the most honorable men with pure hearts, never affected by avarice or hatred. Tales of their generosity and kind hearted nature will continue to inspire me. They are shining examples of how capitalists can help uplift society. RIP
- screye 2y agoFor some context, this is the end of an era for the Tata family. They've had an odd pseudo nepotistic passing-on-the-torch framework for 100+ years now. The Tatas adopt promising children in the extended family, instead of passing ownership by birth order. Ratan Tata's father was adopted into the extended family, and Ratan later got adopted by the main line of the family to be groomed into heir apparent. Keeping up with the tradition, Ratan never married or had his own children. Cyrus Mistry, the head of another billionaire family, became one with the Tatas through marriage & mergers. Cyrus was groomed to be the next heir apparent. Unfortunately, he met an untimely death from a car accident in 2022. 2022 marked move away from the century long tradition of keeping it in the family. The new CEO is a self-made man with no relations to the family or the Tatas' shared religion (Parsi). Usually this merit based system would be cause for celebration, but the Tatas hold a paragon-esque reputation among well-run old-money family-owned institutions. It'll be interesting to see if the company loses it's heart as it slowly morphs into a faceless conglomerate. RIP to Ratan.
- mandeepj 2y agoIt’s notable here - Cyrus was fired from his Chairman position before his untimely death
- ankit219 2y agoMany Indians (esp entrepreneurs) don't realise it, Ratan Tata's conduct is the default expectation how the successful and hyped people in India are to behave (not taking a moral stand, rather a factual one) in the society. He was known to be humble and kind and never made headlines for the wrong reasons. Many would do extensive PR, while he stayed away from the limelight. It's remarkably difficult in a country where the heroes are few and get a huge coverage if they want it. Whenever a big brand wants to enter India and (due to FDI rules) has to partner with an Indian brand, invariably they go with Tata (Starbucks, Foxconn). The image of being upstanding, clean, and good at execution is hard earned.
- stonethrowaway 2y agoIn other words, avoid pathological behaviour.
- pphysch 2y agoWhat does "default expectation" mean here? Didn't the Ambanis just have the most opulent wedding of the 21st century?
- Gentil 2y agoThe default expectation here means "doing the right thing while no one is looking". Ambanis is far far away from it. I am sorry. Ambanis are not everyone's favourite. Definitely not even comparable to the Tatas. I can see why the hustle culture folks and fast money folks like ambanis. But that is not Shri Ratan Tata or Tatas at all. I will quote Shri Ratan Tata himself: "They are business men(Referring to Ambanis). We are industrialists." That quote properly differentiates the differences between them IMO. Not just the perception about them. But also how they think.
- ankit219 2y agoIn Indian society terms, I meant there is a behavior a society will approve of and expect from successful people. If they do not follow this norm (so to speak), they will be criticized for whatever they are doing. Ambani's wedding was a huge talking point in India, and most people did not like the display of spending power. It's not legally wrong obviously, but it's not an accepted social behavior. We expect the uber successful people to do the right thing by other people all the time, work towards uplifting the society, and be cognizant of other peoples' lives and challenges, not show off when you know other people are suffering, and be empathetic. A tall order, but this is pretty much how Ratan Tata would be described. He is not alone, there is Choksi family (Asian Paints) who are also similarly humble and upstanding, and quite a few others who built business from British times to the socialist times and then the liberal era.
- amarsharma 2y agoExtremely saddening to hear this, he was an inspiration growing up as a technologist and entrepreneur. Tata does a lot of philanthropy and does a lot of free cancer treatments, aside from all the great industries he has built. Om Shaanti https://www.tata.com/community/health/tata-memorial-centre https://www.tata.com/community/health/tata-memorial-centre
- m0llusk 2y agoHe had a great life. Is dying at 86 really unexpected or sad? It seems to me like an expected end. Exactly how long should he live for his passing to be normalized?
- StackRanker3000 2y agoIsn’t it normal and human to be sad about someone’s passing, even if it’s expected?
- stareatgoats 2y agoIt is. But it is also perhaps interesting to note that most people seem to rate deaths differently depending on the age of the person. A young person cut down in their prime is a special kind of tragedy, so is the death of toddlers and young children. The passing of an old person, who by all accounts have outlived most other people on earth as far as we can tell, is saddening, especially to the people in the near family. But perhaps not shocking and traumatizing, as the other examples might be. Just observing, not saying that this is how it should be.
- salesynerd 2y agoI guess we are in agreement here. As far as I understand, the word shocking is used, in this context, at the unexpected happening of the event; not that the event happened. If I remember the sequence of events correctly, he was admitted to the hospital for a routine checkup and on Monday, his team had released a statement on his behalf that he was recuperating. Another reason that a lot of Indians found this news shocking is because of the value and emotions attached to the name, "Tatas". Post India's independence, they were instrumental in helping India industrialized; the other were the Birlas.
- dotps1 2y agoI'm sure he was an amazing capitalist, but my experience with Tata consulting was the worst. I worked for a division of GE during the Immelt years that outsourced large portions of IT to Tata, and was in charge of the transition. It was a masterclass in waste and inefficiency. Definitely one of the larger nails in the coffin of a former Fortune 5 company.
- gautamsomani 2y agoHave same thing to say. I worked for a very large e-commerce company in India, who when they were building their DC, contracted TCS. TCS gave a nightmarish experience on execution and ethics. They were horrible.
- justmarc 2y agoI for one would love to read about these types of stories, I'm sure many on HN too. I started a thread here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41800114 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41800114 let's see if people pick up on it.
- dotps1 2y agoI'll just share a little more here. The scale of the outsourcing I am talking about is far greater than whatever you're imagining. We brought teams of people from India over to the US, housed and fed them, so they could be able to work with their counterparts overseas. On the India side we found their operating infrastructure to be woefully inadequate, so we helped them build entirely new facilities with perimeter fences, proper security, the works. After all was said and done, the skills of the people we were getting were on par with someone with no programming experience that skimmed a java book in their spare time. The code quality was abysmal at best, and this was in the days before source control was popular. One of the other huge problems was just the time zone difference. You get into work in the morning to have a meeting with some second-shift team in India, and find out about all of the work that didn't get done because they didn't know what they were doing .. spend the time to correct them, they say they will fix it the next day .. next day comes, same issues, no progress, repeat ad nauseum. It physically hurt to be a part of all of this.
- 4ggr0 2y agoRIP, as one says. That being said, it always irks me when people worship "philantropic" billionaires. I'm sure he's done good things. But there are no ethical billionaires in capitalism. TATA is a giant corp with a lot of influence, I can't believe that they're a 'honest company which doesn't bribe, pays their taxes and are otherwise clean'. Would probably be the first case of an ethical corporation/billionaire :) Certainly cool that he helped stray dogs and people with cancer, but come on people, see through the corpo propaganda. Sounds the same to me as "[INSERT US BILLIONARE] has donated 5 milion dollars to [CUTE CAUSE], what a hero! (ignore the atrocious things done by their corps and themselves)."
- atonse 2y agoSure but you have to grade on a curve. When you actually see how some of their peers act, compared to them, the Tatas are gems.
- 4ggr0 2y agoSure, yeah. My reactionary, immature answer to this is, "someone who has murdered a single person is not that bad when compared to a serial killer", but i certainly get what you mean :)
- orochimaaru 2y agoHow exactly do you plan to do business in India without the bribes? In fact after a certain scale you need to bribe in the US too. It’s just that it’s legalized in the US as lobbying and PACs.
- sgaur 2y agohttps://youtu.be/NzxVjUF6NQ0?t=1739 https://youtu.be/NzxVjUF6NQ0?t=1739 - here's Ratan Tata's answer - "I want to go to bed knowing I didn't do it".
- orochimaaru 2y agoThat point is subjective. Now, this anecdote is from almost 30 years ago and pretty sure things have changed. But when I went to get my India DL you can go directly to the RTO or you go thru a “driving school”. I went thru the school - why? Because they grease the skids to get the DL. Did I bribe? No. Does the school share “profits” - I’m pretty sure they do. So like everything else with the government in India, if you’re using agents to get your work done you’re technically not bribing. But you are.
- wuschel 2y agoThere is more to the story than I can tell here, unfortunately, but at least I can write this: During my work for Bentley Motors I was at one of the Geneve Motor Shows in the 2010s. During my stay at the fair, a new (1500 USD) Tata car was introduced. I visited the Tata stand with a friend, looking at their new car, which was quite the contrast in product philosophy, design and target group to the Bentley models. Thanking our host at the Tata stand for our personal tour, I gave him the invitation to return him the favour and show him the Bentley models and stand. To my great surprise later that day Ratan Tata came to the Bentley stand with what appeared to be his family (some male and female family members) - and I was able to show him around. We could not talk much due to the bodyguards and press, but he seemed distinct in demeanor to his sons and entourage. Apart from the colourful and diverse customer group, I met Piech, other industrial magnates of our time, but Ratan managed to retain a humble and human aura. I sympathized with him.
- ryzvonusef 2y agoRatan Tata never married or have kids, so those weren't his sons, maybe other relatives or colleagues/employees.
- wuschel 2y agoYou are definitely on point. I naturally made this assumption and thought that to be true until when I wrote my comment today.
- linksnapzz 2y agoDefinitely a contrast with Piech; who had once been described as "just a monocle and persian cat away from being the villain in a James Bond movie".
- bongoman42 2y agoYes, I had the chance to meet him once because he invested in our company and paid a visit. He walked around the office and met folks, was warm and approachable even more so than our own executive team. Massively underrated guy.
- cosmos_sajal 2y agoIf there's something everyone should learn from Mr. Tata, "Be Humble"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 725686 2y agoI worked for a few month on Tata Consultancy Services in Mexico City, and hated it.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoFor better and for worse this man left a massive impact on his country, and in many others surrounding. Maybe my favorite is their JV with Starbucks, which had just enough Indian touch to be special. I'll take an Indian Starbucks location over an American one anyday. RIP.