3 ms·
What country wouldn't love to have a Google? And the US wants to break its good fortune up. Like all dominant companies, Google will eventually fall via strang
by WalterBright 2y ago
What country wouldn't love to have a Google? And the US wants to break its good fortune up.
Like all dominant companies, Google will eventually fall via strangulation by its internal bureaucracy. There's no reason to hand the market over to another country.
- mulmen 2y agoWhy would this breakup hand anything to another country? Competition is good for the economy. Breaking up Google allows new innovators to thrive.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Why would this breakup hand anything to another country? For the same reason Google is dominant today. Hobbling American business creates opportunities for other countries to take the top dog position.
- Apocryphon 2y agoWhy should the market care about the fate of nations?
- nickpp 2y agoWhat do you think innovators will feel when they see the government breaking up a private company? Do you think they’ll be more or less motivated to create one to meet the same fate down the road in the unlikely case of success, after immeasurable difficulties and struggle? Ever heard of second order effects and chilling effect of regulation?
- Apocryphon 2y ago"More room for us to grow."
- nickpp 2y agoGrow - why?! So we can be the next company squished by the bureaucrats?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Apocryphon 2y agoThe next company to devise new ways to outwit antitrust action via loophole legalities devised by their armies of lawyers funded by all of the money they've made operating in the competitive space cleared out by antitrust action.
- nickpp 2y ago> armies of lawyers Which no startups have. So, antitrust favors incumbents, of course. > money they've made operating in the competitive space cleared out Again, not startups. It’s incumbents that take advantage of opportunities like that.
- Apocryphon 2y agoStartups do not have to worry about such issues until they themselves become incumbents, which they do after the previous incumbents were brought low by antitrust action.
- nickpp 2y ago> they themselves become incumbents […] after the previous incumbents were brought low by antitrust action Haha, you’ve never built a startup have you? Try it and let me know how easy it is to become incumbent. :)
- Apocryphon 2y agoAntitrust solves this
- Apocryphon 2y ago2017 article so pretty old by now, but: > Microsoft in the year ended June 2016 had $20.1 billion in foreign income and a domestic loss of $300 million. Microsoft’s income tax expense was $3.3 billion, for an effective rate of 16.5%. Alphabet, the parent company of Google, posted a $4.7 billion tax expense, or 19%. Such “avoision” will continue as long as foreign income is subject to lower rates than domestic. https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2017/04/18/what-americas-biggest-companies-pay-in-taxes/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2017/04/18/wh... > There's no reason to hand the market over to another country. Who's to say that the other country's Google-killer won't prove to be a greater boon to American consumers? Let the global market decide.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Who's to say that the other country's Google-killer won't prove to be a greater boon to American consumers? If you do it by hobbling American businesses, they aren't a greater boon.
- Apocryphon 2y agoBut maybe the consumers derive greater service satisfaction or pay less. Why should the American customer care for the plight of American businesses?
- nickpp 2y agoAs a consumer a care greatly about the fate of businesses: they are the ones providing the services and products I enjoy. The government gives me nothing. Less than nothing, actually, since they are taking most of my income for the crap they provide. And I care about every single business since I know that the more competition there is - the better and cheaper the products and services will be.
- Apocryphon 2y agoRight, and in this hypothetical scenario, foreign businesses are providing you with potentially higher-quality services and products at lower costs.
- causal 2y agoNobody's proposing killing Google. You think this is bad because you cannot imagine an alternative history with better competition between multiple Googles