3 ms·
Including Pike County, PA as part of the New York City area is kind of wild, too, from someone who grew up there. If you're making $190K and living in Pike Coun
by ryandrake 2y ago
Including Pike County, PA as part of the New York City area is kind of wild, too, from someone who grew up there. If you're making $190K and living in Pike County, you're living like a Sultan of a country with a palace made entirely of gold.
- wbl 2y agoNot all goods are nontradeable. Flights and lodging at a destination cost the same to everyone as do iPhones etc.
- FredPret 2y agoAs an immigrant from the 3rd world -> Canada, I found a surprising number of things fit this bill. Some things have a global market and everyone is paying ~ the same price everywhere. - Meat, to an extent - Any oil-derived product - Electronics - Software - IP - Cars - Clothes Of course there are always local taxes, regulations, and logistical considerations that skew the price this way or that way by 10-30%, but these markets can be pretty efficient.
- jacurtis 2y agoWhile I do agree with you, that doesn't really impact salary all too much. Allow me to explain. Taxes, Housing, Transportation, and Insurance is what eats up most of your expenses anyway. Housing varies wildly across the world. Many parts of the US now cost > $3,000 /mo to rent a median home. Most of those homes are probably selling for ~$500k putting your mortgage at current interest rates in the same ballpark of $3k /mo. For somoene making $120k that is 1/3 of their income. For someone making the national average (around $70k) that is 1/2 their total income. Just to mention, those areas (Seattle, San Fran, NYC) where you see $250k-300k salaries, those people are paying much higher than these figures. Probably $5-6k in rent or buying modest homes that just happen to cost $1.25M-1.5M In the US you also can pay $1,000 (or more) /mo for health insurance. Most other parts of the world don't have this expense. As of 2024, the average price of a new car is now $47,000 in the USA. Now not everyone is buying a new car but the used car market swells based on this figure. Then you pay 15-30% in taxes on average for most people here. So You add all that up and probably 2/3-3/4 of your money is gone. I agree with you that things like clothing, consumer goods, software, meat, and oil are largely comparable globally now, but these goods only account for probably 10-20% of a person's monthly expenses. Not to mention retirement. Because all these costs are so high, it means I need to put a larger percent of my paycheck to retirement so I can survive a few years of not working before I die. When basics like healthcare and housing are as high as I outlined, it means more money needs to go to retirement, which is money that can't be spent on these basic goods that you mention. So yes, these goods you call out are in fact comparable around the world. But they only account for a relatively small portion of someone's expenses. The outstanding expenses are the most variable (housing, transportation, insurance, taxes).
- FredPret 2y agoBefore I moved from my very cheap birth country to the entirely-not-cheap area known as Toronto, I thought along these lines and was concerned that my standard of living would be the same or lower. However, surprisingly, I found it to go up a lot. - Real Estate did take up a larger % of my budget, but it was nicer - The globalized products are only a small % of the budget but they're relatively much cheaper so I can have more/better/both Of course this doesn't mean expensive cities are perfect or even good. I later moved from Toronto to Alberta and it's night-and-day better. Of course the lifestyle is different and some might not like that. There's a big qualitative angle so you can't really compare these things on a spreadsheet, but more after-tax dollars is almost always better.
- stn8188 2y agoThis is true but the number of people who commute from Pike County (and the whole tri-state/NY-NJ-PA corner) down to the crowded parts of North Jersey and even NYC is insane. I live just across the river from Pike County and experience the traffic though our small town.
- shmatt 2y agoThe pay is for the office location, not home location. And as a tech corp employee in NYC I have multiple coworkers commuting 2h each way 2-3 times a week (including from the Pike County area). Rural PA has become pretty popular for the 4br SFH for sub-$1M crowd