4 ms·
Since there's a lot of negativity about Indians in the comments here: I just worked for a startup with many Indians (including the founder). It was all fine,
by eru 2y ago
Since there's a lot of negativity about Indians in the comments here:
I just worked for a startup with many Indians (including the founder). It was all fine, and I liked my coworkers. I can understand that other people had different experiences: companies and people differ.
For context, everything was remote, and I worked from Singapore. I'm not India, but I do like to prepone my meetings.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- p_l 2y agoThe big problem are WITCH companies (of which "C" is for Cognizant usually) and those that, through osmosis or purposeful actions, copy their practices. The contracting companies probably single-handed build and maintain lots of racist stereotypes against indians, because the level of service those companies offer is always unmitigated failure, even internally. I once accidentally stumbled into working on a contract through WiPro myself, and it was a horrific experience. The way I see it, the line workers that end up the target of ire and stereotypes are just victims of actions taken way above them. The people who can, apparently avoid working for them, or use every opportunity to escape. Those who can't yet but have ambition for more, apparently use every opportunity to escape - whether it is by jumping ship on H1B, or otherwise. Those currently stuck are in no way encouraged to do a good job, and for obvious cost cutting you get people who were in no way prepared to do the job. Occasionally a client will get angry enough and they will pull an actually skilled person to smooth the ruffled feathers, someone they usually trot for dog&pony show when winning the contract as example of who is supposed to work on it. But the "important" people, upper management who decide to contract with WITCH, and the upper management of WITCH who run such strategy, they all profit. The managers and/or C-level who outsource sight-unseen with no quality enforcement disappear with their rewards before institutional inertia stops papering over their decisions. The WITCH companies pocket huge amounts of money while paying pittance to line workers and providing worse than zero service.
- eru 2y agoYeah, that sounds pretty dreadful. A few jobs ago, when I was working for a third-tier legacy bank, my manager joked that all the outsourcing they were doing was actually really useful and pragmatic, because it means they can fail their IT projects cheaper. (The implication being that their projects were by and large inevitably doomed anyway.)
- commandlinefan 2y ago> a lot of negativity about Indians There isn't, though. There's a lot of negativity about _H1B_s in the comments here, but you conflate that with Indian.
- dang 2y agoThere was, unfortunately, but most of it has since been (correctly) flagged.
- ssbash 2y agoRespectfully, I don’t think enough has been removed. As someone with Indian heritage it’s super disheartening to see plenty of comments negatively generalizing a diaspora of over 1B people. Treating anyone who presents as Indian as apart of cultural monolith is absurd. I was born and raised in the US, and have no connection to the alleged cronyism or caste-based discrimination. Many of these comments make blanket statements about Indians. I don’t think the same moderation guidelines are being applied in this case. Replace Indians with Europeans, Black people or any other ethnicity and it should become clear that this violates the site’s guidelines. Here are a few top level examples: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41786112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41786112 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41786205 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41786205 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41786534 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41786534
- eru 2y ago> As someone with Indian heritage it’s super disheartening to see plenty of comments negatively generalizing a diaspora of over 1B people. The diaspora is only a few dozen million, isn't it? I don't think you want to count every Indian inside of India as being in the 'diaspora'? Nitpick aside, I agree. (I wrote the original comment above.)