3 ms·
I'm not convinced this is true. You see, way back in the day in 1997 when I was doing web dev, everything worked the way PHP does. ColdFusion, ASP (not ASP.net,
by jerf 14y ago
I'm not convinced this is true. You see, way back in the day in 1997 when I was doing web dev, everything worked the way PHP does. ColdFusion, ASP (not ASP.net, ASP), PHP, and almost everything else that was seriously trying to do web pages worked that way. It took the community collectively a long time to stop seeing URLs as identifying anything but specific files. This is back when having those files be programs was still a bit of an innovation.
After 15 years of one of the biggest bursts of innovation the open source world has ever seen, and with such diversity in frameworks that the mind boggles, nobody has returned to this model successfully. I've got MVC-inspired designs coming out my ears, continuation-based designs, frameworks just beginning to incorporate web sockets deeply (instead of as an afterthought), GWT, ASP.net, and other attempts at building a fundamentally different model and compiling it into another, and everything under the sun... but no return to the page-is-program model.
I don't think it's the key to PHP's success, because even in the competitive-yet-very-fertile soil of the web framework world, nobody else can make it work anymore. I think it's vestigial, and nothing else.
(Personally I think the key is simply that everybody has deployed it, and since there's basically no way to force every web hosting company to support Language X simultaneously, PHP isn't going away until the entire concept of web hosting goes away. Which isn't anytime soon.)
- mechanical_fish 14y agoThe page-is-program model still works as well as ever. It's just that, if your problem is so simple that the page-is-program pattern is most appropriate -- for example, if you are eight years old and you want to build a page that serves up a different picture of a dinosaur every time it gets reloaded -- you should just use PHP. Why choose anything else? It's true that other languages have not wasted a lot of time trying to displace PHP as the language of choice for anonymous random dinosaur servers. That's because there's no money in fighting PHP on its home turf. The turf just isn't worth enough. "Vestigial" is the wrong word. That's like describing a screwdriver as "vestigial" because the impact driver has been invented. Sure, impact drivers can accomplish many things that mere screwdrivers cannot, but that doesn't mean that screwdrivers aren't still useful, and numerous, and popular.
- jerf 14y agoVestigial is the right word; a characteristic of a surviving species that isn't particularly relevant to the question of why they survive. While debate goes back and forth between the various potentially-vestigial organs we may possess, it seems clear that if the appendix contributes anything to humanity's survival, it isn't very much. Also, vestigial tends to imply it isn't actively harmful, which I don't think it is because PHP certainly works just fine with other models as well. (If it were only page-as-program, I'd have another opinion... but it would probably also not be doing anywhere near as well on very large sites and we probably wouldn't still be talking about it as anything but a historical language.) You may disagree that my characterization is correct, but it is certainly the characterization I intended to convey. That's why I parenthetically commented that I think the real reason it has carried on is another one, to contrast the relevant characteristics to the irrelevant ones. Creating a new "PHP-killer" and focusing too much on the vestigial features of PHP is a recipe for failure.
- cturner 14y agoI think z92 is on to something. Ease of install is part of the same pattern. PHP has always been easy (with connections to a free database), and got easier with good package management systems. What's coldfusion like for ease of install, ease of install with database access? ASP for Windows was huge. It was even easier to get started on than PHP because you just needed to install IIS from a EXE and you could reference access files. The only reason it's not still massive is that MS moved on.
- ChikkaChiChi 14y agoTo further your point, if C# MVC4 ran flawlessly on a free and open mono/nginx type setup, I'd run to it like a forlorn lover across an open meadow. There are alternatives, but nothing that simply 'just works' like PHP seems to.
- debaserab2 14y agoI think the argument being made here is not that page-is-program model is superior; it's that it's much easier to understand for newbies coming into the field.