8 ms·
GLP-1 pills are coming, and they could revolutionize weight-loss treatment
- CharlieDigital 2y agoCurious if there's been any accounting on the long term impact in terms of cost on the healthcare system. On the one hand, obesity is associated with many other ailments such as heart disease, diabetes, etc. that cost the system a lot of money. On the other hand, well, longer life spans impacting Social Security, Medicare, etc.
- swyx 2y ago??? how is cost on the healthcare system the thing to be worried about over longer lifespan and quality of life? strange thing to focus on lol but i think if you think it thru, 1 should dominate 2, and 2 should be reduced as well.
- CalRobert 2y agoPeople who need to ensure these programs are well funded definitely need to consider it.
- freedomben 2y agoAre you prepared to make the doctors work for free?
- rowanG077 2y agoBecause it's literally a large chunk of the economy? Why wouldn't you worry about that. I certainly don't like to see a society where the young are enslaved by the old to pay for their medical treatment.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoHealth care costs is how individual people’s terrible lifestyle decisions end up impacting everybody else. If somebody wants to live some awful unhealthy lifestyle it really should be their own choice to do so. Except for the fact that it drives up everybody’s insurance premiums, and in countries where the government either partially or entirely subsidises healthcare costs, it gives the government an outright moral mandate to start nannying everybody’s health choices. If somebody wants to live an obese lifestyle, I really think that’s up to them. But I’d be much happier about it if it didn’t cost me so much money.
- rickbutton 2y agoDo you think addicts should receive treatment? Do you think that people who make bad decisions deserve to live? Do you extract the exact amount of value from society relative to the amount you put in, or do you take more than you give? Are you sure? Please explain. Your perspective is frankly disgusting. I hope you don't have any vices. The point of a society is to pool resources together to improve the collective. Different people in different positions of power and ability have different needs. Hopefully you don't personally have any power to exclude people from that group. I hope that the powers that be don't decide that you deserve less for some reason.
- AmericanChopper 2y agoI don’t think being addicted to laziness and having a glutinous appetite is exactly comparable to say, being addicted to heroin. But yes, I do think addicts should receive treatment, just as I think obese patients should (and do) receive treatment for all the diseases they end up with. But addicts, like the obese, impose many of the costs of their own bad life decisions onto others. It’s what you’d call a negative externality, and if some magic treatment came along to fix drug addiction, I would also be very happy to see that negative externality addressed.
- rickbutton 2y ago> I don’t think being addicted to laziness and having a glutinous appetite is exactly comparable to say, being addicted to heroin. Your opinion is that of a petulant child. Many years of research has shown that obesity is not this simple. Many chemical processes take place that influence one's ability to make better health choices, and many external factors put constraints on those choices as well. This is the exact same thing as hard drugs. Being obese is not a moral failing. When you say things like this, you show your true colors. You are not extending humanity to obese people, and it is very obvious. I sincerely hope you reconsider your opinions. I hope you don't have any obese people in your life, or at least hope they don't read these messages. I think they would be disappointed to hear what you think of them. And again, I hope you don't have any vices and are the perfect model of health, otherwise this would be a quite silly opinion to have. EDIT: I've been rated limited on comments so I'll post my last response here instead: I have nothing further to say to this other than that you should consider talking to someone about your clearly deep-seated hatred for those who don't fit your model of participant in society; it doesn't seem healthy. Find an obese friend and show them your comments and watch their face as they read them. I wonder if you will find the humanity in their response that you are lacking here.
- CharlieDigital 2y agoI mean, I'm contributing to the Social Security system here so I'd like to know how it's going to impact my long term retirement. There's nothing malicious about it; purely a question of accounting and math.
- selectodude 2y agoWe can probably just extrapolate the numbers from people quitting smoking.
- rickbutton 2y agoI wrote a few paragraphs of response to this assuming that you are implying that there is a level of death/disease that is acceptable because treating it would not be cost-effective, but I deleted it because it would be uncharitable to assume you think that. It would be interesting to see this information, but would not be useful to act on. If the answer was "it costs more to keep more people alive" (hint: it does, that is why we let so many die of preventable illness), should we keep less people alive and healthy? The pursuit of economic growth at all costs is a disease far more dangerous than anything you would treat in a hospital.
- crmd 2y agoIn my view, the sole focus of the healthcare system should be maximizing human wellbeing. Humanity’s GDP is around $100 trillion per year. There is plenty of money for healthcare with many orders of magnitude to spare for other endeavors. Bean counting here feels like Google in the early ‘00s proposing to make office supply expense reduction a business priority.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> is plenty of money with many orders of magnitude to spare Putting infinite value on anything is a great way to incentivise a system that delivers little to none of it.
- rickbutton 2y agoThere should certainly be measurements taken, costs considered, alternatives approached when building our healthcare system. No one has ever implied otherwise, ever. To imply that there is some level of healthy after which it doesn't make sense to seek improvement is the dehumanizing and anti-social part. What is the point of building an economy at all if not to improve the lives of the population? Opinions in this thread already seem to be that "people are healthy enough, and if not, it is due to their own choices" rather than "we should carefully consider how to optimize this system for efficiency" while focusing on the actual goal of improving lives for the average person as well as those who need more healthcare.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> imply that there is some level of healthy after which it doesn't make sense to seek improvement is the dehumanizing and anti-social part No it's not. Every doctor triages. And every medical system has internal cost limits, whether implicit or implict, universal or variable, past which it will not treat. Sometimes that's enforced by gatekeeping entire categories of treatments; in other cases we have patients individually reviewed, e.g. for organ transplants. If managing obesity is less expensive than treating it, there is a legitimate question around how the cost of that treatment should be split between the public and the individual. (Whether that cost be an explicit split or gatekeeping the treatment to only the most morbidly obese.) Thankfully, that's not the case--treating obesity, even chronically with super-expensive drugs, is still cheaper than the status quo.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Curious if there's been any accounting on the long term impact in terms of cost on the healthcare system Savings on the order of $100bn per year [1]. > longer life spans impacting Social Security, Medicare, etc. An obese person dying early may well wind up costing the system more than a healthy person dying old. (Most medical costs are incurred terminally. The obese have more-complicated terminal paths.) [1] https://healthpolicy.usc.edu/research/benefits-of-medicare-coverage-for-weight-loss-drugs/ https://healthpolicy.usc.edu/research/benefits-of-medicare-c...
- teqsun 2y agoI'm curious: is the appetite suppressant effect of GLP-1 different from the one from amphetamines?
- ct520 2y agoYes. Having used both I can say indeed it is. Not only does GLP-1 slow digestion which limits what you can eat and when it also is being study for its effects on alcoholism etc reducing cravings. I and many people I know noticed the difference in cravings were not limited to food.
- teqsun 2y agoInteresting, thank you.
- tmikaeld 2y agoDoes it affect libido?
- vundercind 2y agoOddly enough, no. It seems to affect a different desire pathway than dopamine and such. It’s not anhedonic, good stuff is still good and you still want it. Even food! It doesn’t make food not-pleasurable, just reduces hunger. It only seems to affect very particular kinds of cravings associated with food and addiction/compulsion, not sex drive (though maybe for “sex addicts”? IDK)
- ct520 2y agoI agree with statement. Nothing really to add in to your response, just seconding it.
- petesergeant 2y agoI can’t speak to amphetamines specifically, but re other stimulants, there’s more of a noticeable fullness effect on GLP-1 meds.
- swyx 2y agofor those who are interested in a cheaper, partially generic, pill based option for weight loss, i was just referred by a friend to the naltrexone + bupropion + metformin solution offered by hims (not linking because their website is terrible for learning anything without giving all your health info). he lost 30lbs in 3 months on it. i've just started so i cant vouch but just sharing that non GLP1 appetite suppression solutions that work exist.
- petesergeant 2y agoThis is sold as Contrave / MySimba, albeit adding metformin to the mix is a little unusual https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naltrexone/bupropion https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naltrexone/bupropion
- stanford_labrat 2y agoFor those not aware: Metformin is a popular (unapproved?) nootropic.
- nkozyra 2y agoMy guess is metformin is here because of its effects on blood sugar. It is available as a prescription drug for this purpose.
- r00fus 2y agoSome people who come off the GLP-1 meds (acheiving goal weight) are recommended by their docs to take metformin as a maintenance drug to stabilize weight.
- petesergeant 2y agoI had an endo suggest that to me. In addition there's been a flurry of Peter Thiel types mentioning it as a life-extension wonderdrug.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- FiReaNG3L 2y agoOverconsumption leading to widespread obesity while a large fraction of the world is hungry - the capitalist solution? Let's invent a pill so we can eat EVEN MORE.
- marcellus23 2y agoThese drugs don't magically let you eat more and not gain weight. They reduce appetite and slow metabolism so you eat less.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sgillen 2y agoTo be fair the pill actually makes people eat less.
- calyhre 2y agoIt's actually a pill to eat less, seems to be a hunger suppressant
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- freedomben 2y agoThis is the opposite of that. It's an appetite suppressant so you eat less, not more.
- singhrac 2y agoI feel like this is a weirdly cynical response. GLP-1s actually inhibit appetite. I took a friend on them once to a nice cafe I’d found and even though he agreed their pastries were delicious he didn’t finish his and took it home. There seem to be pretty clear signs that GLP-1 inhibitors are decreasing overall food consumption. I’m not even sure this is a capitalist solution. Sure, Novo Nordisk is making a ton of money with these pills at the moment, but at least externally it seems like their decisions are controlled by the foundation (of course, money talks and no one is immune). I know plenty of people who are scared of needles and I’m not sure they should have to suffer from diabetes if they should develop it. Separately, and I’m not an expert but slightly more knowledgeable than a layperson, but food scarcity is rarely because of overconsumption in the global West. The blame usually lies with corrupt local organizations working with NGOs and poor quality transmission routes rather than global food markets.
- dilawar 2y agoHow does it work? Does it reduce the calorie intake by decreasing the appetite? Your body burns more calories because the drug sets the thermostat higher?! Or something else? I don't know how to feel about the idea that we need treatment for being overweight in general.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIt patches a reward center in your brain, reducing appetite, but also patching addiction reward center activity. https://recursiveadaptation.com/p/the-growing-scientific-case-for-using https://recursiveadaptation.com/p/the-growing-scientific-cas... > The consistency that I'm hearing from all across patient groups is gain of control, whereas previously, there was a loss of control… All of a sudden they're able to step back and say, 'oh, well I had this shopping phenomenon that was going on, gambling, addiction, or alcoholism, and all of a sudden, it just stopped,' - Dr. Gitanjali Srivastava, Vanderbilt Medical Center
- HarHarVeryFunny 2y agoDo we know what the long-term affects are? Is there any lasting benefit if someone stops taking these types of medication? If one does keep taking it indefinitely, does the addiction-suppression effect stay the same, or reduces over time?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThere are side effects, but the risk profile is known (is my understanding). It is (at this time) believed to be a forever drug, just like diet and exercise stop working if you stop them. A longer term fix is likely gene therapy (Fractyl Health has a clinical trial in progress, REMAIN-1) vs chronic maintenance. GLP-1s allow us to poke at the human to see what happens. Gene therapy will, hopefully, allow us to implement a permanent fix vs a hotfix (once the risk profile of such a genetic modification is better understood). https://www.remain1study.com/remain-1-study/ https://www.remain1study.com/remain-1-study/
- petesergeant 2y ago… what? Rybelsus has been out forever. I’ve used it, injected semaglutide, and injected tirzepatide, ama I guess
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoDid you ever get depression as a side effect?
- petesergeant 2y agoNo, but I take an SSRI for GAD anyway, which might be a confounding factor
- ChemSpider 2y agoWhich one worked best for you?
- petesergeant 2y agoTirzepatide by far
- andrewmcwatters 2y agoGLP-1 freaks me out after I read from plastic surgeons that it ages your skin from the inside out.
- CJefferson 2y agoRead what, where?
- throwup238 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41240240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41240240
- vundercind 2y agoPlastic surgeons and cosmetic companies are rushing to convince people that the same effects you see from any weight loss are worse with GLP-1 agonists, to court a market with demonstrated willingness to spend money on (among other things) their looks. Plastic surgeons, I expect, are especially concerned about a large reduction in volume of lipo & related procedures, and are eager to get the message out that “no, you still need to come pay us to cut on you!”
- andrewmcwatters 2y agoYeah, a number of independent plastic surgeons are just coming to the same conclusion then, for people who are still going to see them for excess skin removal. OK, sure. There was a large amount of skepticism in the original HN thread, but it strikes me as weird and dangerous, along the same lines of COVID-19 deniers.
- vundercind 2y agoTrade groups and publications exist. Getting this kind of thing into the air is a big part of their job.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoI have such pills with the same active substance as ozempic. So-so effect, also the protocol is to take one two hours before the first meal, making me delay breakfast.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y ago[flagged]
- Duhck 2y agoas an american who avoids sugar and processed foods (like seed oils) its virtually impossible to eat out or buy anything beyond whole foods. Everything is contaminated. Combine that with forever chemical use in packaging, pesticides in non-organic produce, our food supply chain is killing us. I buy eggs from reputable regenerative free range, non-vegetarian fed chickens. I order my poultry and beef from regenerative farms across the country who are verified organic + grass fed + grass finished. I bake my own bread and cook 95% of the meals I eat at home. It costs an arm and a leg and isnt convenient but I feel much better.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoSo what you say means that I’m going the US only for a short visit, I’m basically fucked, because none of your options are easily available when living in a hotel for a week or two.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> processed foods (like seed oils) Huh, apparently this originates with Joe Rogan [1]. In any case, I'm happy you found something that works for you. But you can find the quality you're looking for in restaurants in any Tier 1 city and most wealthy suburbs. (We absolutely have an issue with poorer communities having a choice between canned and fast food, in essence.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seed_oil_misinformation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seed_oil_misinformation
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Americans could probably start with putting less sugar into bloody everything and reducing portion sizes It's not just America. "Obesity in India has reached epidemic proportions in the 21st century, with morbid obesity affecting 5% of the country's population" [1]. (It's about 7% in America [2].) Meanwhile in China, "the incidence of overweight and obesity among school-age children...was 15.5% in 2010, rising to 24.2% in 2019 and soaring to 29.4% in 2022" [2]. Same story in Vietnam: "The prevalence of overweight among children aged under 5 years increased from 5.6% in 2010 to 7.4% in 2019. For overweight and obesity among children aged 5 to 19 years, prevalence rose from 8.5% and 2.5% in 2010 to 19% and 8.1% in 2020, respectively" [3]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_India https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obesity_in_India [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10357130/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10357130/ [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9947684/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9947684/
- frankzander 2y agoBut why? Just eat no crap and work out. This is long lasting if it's a full life change.
- evilfred 2y agogreat, tell that to my grandma with high blood pressure and diabetes
- pfortuny 2y agoThere are many people in their 50-60s who can neither “eat no crap”, as you state it nor “work out”.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hbosch 2y agoThere is theory, and then there is practice. A 300lb person will have trouble just "eating less" and "working out", because both of those things put incredible stress on a person's mind and body. Immediately working those lifestyle changes into an obese person's life is not like flicking a light switch, even for the overweight person who looks at themselves in the mirror and cries about how they look, "just eat less" and "just move more" are ideas that are psychologically difficult to put into action. With GLP-1 medications, it is considerably easier to do the first part of "eating less". An obese person can lose over 20% of their body fat in a year, which will reduce the probability of injury when they begin working out. There is hardly any downside to developing medication to help people manage their weight to below obesity, and incredible upside. Maybe another example would be: why do you use VSCode to do your programming? Hell, why do you use a computer at all? You should probably do it the hard way, on a sheet of paper... there is no reason to use a keyboard when you could just use your hands, right? GLP-1 agonists are just tools like anything else. They make difficult tasks easier.
- mwmisner 2y agoLike much of life it's more complicated than simple rules. It works for some people, but does not for everyone. As someone that has struggled with diet for the last decade or so these drugs have been a life saver. I've been able to eat healthy and feel full instead of being stuck in a cycle of eating right for a while and then eventually breaking under load. I've been able to have a consistency in the last 6 months on the drugs that i never thought I was capable of. I've even been able to build up a weight lifting plan that actually works for me and I feel good after the day. There are lots of problems with drug reliance still to be worked out, but I'm excited for the chance to rebuild my habits into something good and work my way off to something normal. Related, exercise is awesome but has little impact on long term weight loss! Check this out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSSkDos2hzo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSSkDos2hzo
- inSenCite 2y agooh hey, big pharma touting a miracle drug to Solve Problems?! This time it's different I'm sure. It's like we are doomed to repeat the same awful cycles again and again instead of dealing with our cultural problem with consumption
- globular-toast 2y agoI find it crazy that they were able to do what they did to cigarettes, essentially marginalising them by banning all marketing etc., but rather than do anything about McDonalds, Kellogs and other junk food companies we have to resort to people injecting or taking pills for life.
- ripply 2y agoIt may take another 10-20 years but I think this will eventually happen. I agree it’s criminal to permit marketing of this stuff. It took a very long time to get to this point with cigarettes but also realize that in other countries smoking is still a normal thing particularly Europe. Right now there is still a lot of money being made on producing super addictive junk food and therefore strong lobbying.
- thrownawaysz 2y agoGood! I'm on liraglutide (Saxenda) for almost 3 months now (can't get semaglutide (Ozempic) in my country without being diagnosed with diabetes) Anyway. Food cravings gone, I was eating like 10 times a day before that. At least, but sometimes even more. Now I'm on intermittent fasting/OMAD and has 0 problems. No hunger, no cravings. Feeling significantly better. Lost 43 pounds so far (rougly 3 pounds per week)
- cat_plus_plus 2y agoI mean always good to have options, but weekly injection is painless and more convenient, plus no need to worry about dosing inconsistency from taking pills on full vs empty stomach.
- snapplebobapple 2y agoMeh, 10-12 grams of inulin plus a teaspoon of allulose has accomplished the same thing for me. Just be prepared for the fart armageddon that comes with the inulin and will last for 3-4 weeks as your gut biota adjusts. My regime for informational puprposes, consult your doctor before you try anything obviously: 3 restorafiber gummies in the morning, 3 in the evening a half teaspoon of allulose in the morning and evening (tastes sweet, I just dissolve it on my tongue). Costco sells 2 large 140 gummie jars for 29 bucks (46 servings) where I live and the "wholesome, non-gmo pure allulose" brand is available from iherb for 19 bucks for 80 daily servings, which puts the cost of this regime ~86 cents a day.
- DavidNich 2y agoI’ve heard about GLP-1 pills being used for weight loss, and while I haven’t tried them myself, I know they help regulate blood sugar and can suppress appetite, which can be useful for some. It’s important to keep in mind they’re still a medical treatment, so it’s good to speak to a professional before starting. Personally, I’ve had success with intermittent fasting and HGH therapy. I started HGH treatment due to a deficiency, and it’s made a huge difference for me, especially in terms of energy levels, recovery, and muscle tone. Combining fasting with HGH therapy has really helped me stay on track with my fitness goals, and I feel much more in control of my body and my health. If you're curious about how hormones like growth hormone and testosterone compare and impact your health, you might find this link helpful: https://medzone.clinic/growth-hormone-vs-testosterone-the-differences-and-the-similarities/ https://medzone.clinic/growth-hormone-vs-testosterone-the-di...