4 ms·
Will Carbon Capture Be Ready on Time?
- calinet6 14y agoOf course not. By the time we see enough effect from carbon, it will be too late to reduce the emissions. Before that time, no one will invest in the commons as they don't derive any individual benefit. Humans are imperfect sensors and even more imperfect judges of issues at this large scale. We see it even at such small sizes as our economy, much less the global ecosystem. We operate on such small scales of time and space that we first need an extension of our collective ability to perceive before we will solve this problem that is so much larger than us. Perhaps there is room for technology there.
- DennisP 14y agoThere are a lot of ways to sequester CO2 besides just injecting it underground somewhere. Biochar, for example.
- stuff4ben 14y agoAlso with a link the other day to something about graphene I got to thinking, "Graphene is just carbon, why not convert CO2 to graphene?". Turns out someone already did: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/06/110620161308.htm http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/06/110620161308.ht...
- MikeCapone 14y agoAll I've read about CCS over the years make it sound more like a marketing/stalling tactic. There are huge problems to be overcome, most of the worst kinds of coal plants aren't compatible with it anyway, and there are big risks from leaks, etc.. All the effort put into making it happen should probably be used on long-term solutions rather than a band-aid. More wind, more solar, more geothermal, more hydro, more investments in efficiency, and grid-scale liquid-metal batteries (see this TED talk: http://www.ted.com/talks/donald_sadoway_the_missing_link_to_renewable_energy.html http://www.ted.com/talks/donald_sadoway_the_missing_link_to_... ) seem to be a better bet.
- DennisP 14y agoI did the math on those liquid-metal batteries a while back, and figured out that getting an adequate amount of grid storage would take about a thousand years of antimony production. Tom Murphy's Do the Math blog is pretty good for this sort of thing. Most renewables can't scale up to run civilization (nor can their combination), and storage is an unsolved problem at the scale we'd need. The two non-fossil energy sources that could do the job are solar (not counting the storage problem) and advanced nuclear.
- MikeCapone 14y ago> I did the math on those liquid-metal batteries a while back, and figured out that getting an adequate amount of grid storage would take about a thousand years of antimony production. Could you elaborate on that? Do you mean at current rates of production? You do realize that supply has no incentive to exceed demand, correct? If demand increases rapidly, there will be a huge incentive to increase production. As far as I know, antimony isn't rare and there's no reason why we could produce significantly more and match demand for these types of batteries.
- DennisP 14y agoHaven't been able to find it...I think it may have actually been 1000 years magnesium, 10,000 antimony, but I'd have to figure it again to be sure. I calculated by assuming each metal was about a third of full-load weight of a shipping container, taking the storage capacity they claimed per container-size battery, and using Tom Murphy's estimates of how much storage we'd need. I did assume current production rates. However, increasing the mining output by a factor of hundreds wouldn't necessarily be trivial. For example, wikipedia reports that China has annual antimony production of 120K tonnes, which is 89% of the world's total. The largest deposit is only 2.1 million tonnes. Wiki also mentions that "antimony was identified as one of 12 critical raw materials for the EU in a report published in 2011, primarily due to the lack of supply outside China." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antimony#Top_producers_and_production_volumes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antimony#Top_producers_and_prod...