10 ms·
California first state to ban 'sell by' 'best before' label to reduce food waste
- Cypher 2y agoIt's dumb, I don't like shopping without it
- DamonHD 2y agoWe basically already have this in the UK, and is is helpful. But we still waste too much! One of the local groups that I work with (ish) saves huge amounts of stuff from supermarkets regularly that would otherwise be discarded.
- rramadass 2y agoYou might find this documentary interesting - https://www.divethefilm.com/ https://www.divethefilm.com/ As a person who grew up (and currently live) in India and who spent a decade-and-half in the US, to see the amount of perfectly good food thrown away in the developed world is infuriating and morally inexcusable.
- JamesBarney 2y agoFood waste isn't a problem. If the US threw out 20% less food all the same countries would struggle with food security and hunger. If the US consumed less food, less would be grown. It wouldn't change the price of rice or wheat in India. Almost all the food imported from the US to India for instance is consumed by the middle class such as tree nuts (almonds) and are not staple foods consumed by those struggling to eat. There isn't that much rice or wheat that's imported. In addition India has lots of tariffs to drive up the price of imported food from the US to protect local farmers. None of the cause of food insecurity is Susie throwing out a mayonnaise container that might be perfectly fine but past the best by date.
- rramadass 2y agoYou misunderstood my comment. I just used the US and India as examples of the developed world and developing world with which i have personal experience to assert that much much more food is wasted in the former than in the latter. It is not about sending food from one to the other but managing it more effectively when you have people desperately needing it in their own countries (eg. Charities/NGOs, Homeless Shelters, Low-Income groups, Schools etc.). It is well-known that in the developed world the economically impoverished cannot afford healthy food and thus rely on cheap junk-food with the consequence that they suffer more from Poor Health/Obesity/etc. which leads to an unmanageable pressure on the healthcare system and a downward spiral in overall economic output. Everybody suffers as a result. The above linked documentary is pretty good about highlighting the problem in the US. Also watch this documentary Waging a Living to understand how tough life is for the economically underprivileged in the US - https://www.pbs.org/pov/films/wagingaliving/ https://www.pbs.org/pov/films/wagingaliving/ Finally note that in 2016 France became the first country to outlaw food wastage by supermarkets which should be adopted by all other countries. See https://zerowasteeurope.eu/library/france-law-for-fighting-food-waste/ https://zerowasteeurope.eu/library/france-law-for-fighting-f... and https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/is-frances-groundbreaking-food-waste-law-working https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/is-frances-groundbreaking-...
- bofadeez 2y agoYou waste too much. What other people do is not your business.
- mrweiner 2y ago> You waste too much. You have no information about how much waste they produce. > What other people do is not your business. We cant comment that grocery stores throw out too much food because it’s not our business?
- bofadeez 2y agoYou can't comment on what sovereign individuals, who have no voluntary contractual obligation to you, do with their private property. That's because you have no ownership over their physical flesh. They own 100% of their body.
- mrweiner 2y agoA grocery store is not a person. And besides that, laws and regulations exist specifically to restrict what people are able to do. Nobody is entirely sovereign. Sure, if you discover an island and you decide to live there, maybe you’re sovereign and can act however you want. But we live in a collective. That’s just the way it works.
- vfclists 2y agoWill it be replaced with a "Produced on XXXX" date? If you don't know when a product is considered unsafe, then at least you should know when it was produced to know if it is fresh enough for "YOUR"your consumption. It shouldn't be up to the govt to decide what is or isn't fresh enough for you. That is your choice.
- argiopetech 2y agoIs the current system of "Use by" not also entirely driven by government regulation, from the requirement to the ∆T? Agreed that a "Produced on" date is better.
- iterateoften 2y agoI second this motion 100% Confusing use by labels only benefit corps by allowing them to over buy and then let their inventory spoil on the shelf while they charge full price for year old garbage. If customers knew when their food was made, people would be grossed out and not buy rice cooked 8 months ago from the refrigerated section. it would force corps to have more sales to rotate inventory more often.
- Suppafly 2y ago>If customers knew when their food was made, people would be grossed out .... it would force corps to have more sales to rotate inventory more often. That sounds like it would increase food waste because consumers have no idea how long things commercially prepared should be allowed to be sold for and would be basing it on flawed assumption from their own cooking.
- eqvinox 2y ago> There are more than 50 different date labels on packaged food sold in stores, but the information is largely unregulated and does not relate to food safety. WTF? How is this not regulated? It feels like one of the very first things you'd stick some regulation on…
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWhy?
- jjk166 2y agoIt's regulated on products where it matters. For many foodstuffs though, they don't really become unsafe, at least not on reasonable timescales. You probably don't want to drink a soda you found from 1996 but even if you did it would probably just be flat and maybe taste a little funky.
- digital-cygnet 2y agoTitle is a little misleading, as attested to by several comments here. It's more a standardization (which, yes, does include "banning" the non-standard labels) Relevant quote: > The law is set to take effect in July 2026, establishing a new standard for food labeling in California. It will require the use of “Best if Used By” label to signal peak quality and “Use By” label for product safety, an approach recommended by federal agencies
- s1artibartfast 2y ago[flagged]
- squigz 2y agoWhy does that framing confuse you?
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think it is confusing because I dont think that replacing the texts "enjoy by" with “BEST if Used by” will have the impact the California legislature says it will of 20% reduction in statewide food waste. It is confusing because I'm not sure if they are just boldly lying and actually that delusional.
- ttyprintk 2y agoNo, the confusion is over the price of an item beyond its magical date. The pipelines producing milk and eggs perpetually need shelf space tomorrow, so the date is an ordinal signal. These rules are the same independent of the political persuasion of the farmers and grocers involved.
- candiddevmike 2y agoDo you think this will lead to some kind of price decay scheme based on freshness? I occasionally see something like but nothing regular enough to plan shopping around buying almost expired products.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago>It will require the use of “Best if Used By” label to signal peak quality and “Use By” label for product safety Who are these people that were confused by "Best by" but understand "best if used by"?
- adamredwoods 2y agoThe same ones that began the meat safe handling instructions (1994), maybe? https://www.meattrack.com/labeling/history/ https://www.meattrack.com/labeling/history/
- audunw 2y agoI think they should have used the labels we’re using here in Norway. I find them very clear: - “Last consumption date” (maybe not safe to eat after this date) - “Best before” - these days they sometimes also add “.. but often good after”
- s1artibartfast 2y agoWhat you said is basically the law, except that the often good after part would be illegal
- devonbleak 2y agoIt's not about confusion/clarification it's about legal definition. Currently, because there's no legal definition around it, companies can throw any arbitrary date on a "best by" label on a product. And what we've found is that it's being abused as an artificially short faux expiration date to drive consumers to discard the still-fine-to-consume product and buy another one. This is good for the company who increase their sales but bad for pretty much everybody else because it increases food waste and the energy/resources that were consumed to create it.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThey still can. There is no definition and it is at the manufacturers discretion. The law changed absolutely nothing about how best by dates are determined, just the wording. The law literally is about the wording.
- hollerith 2y ago[flagged]
- squigz 2y agoPretty sure nobody is telling you you can't do either of those things.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- DrillShopper 2y agoSpoiler alert: you can now currently ignore the dates on the things in your fridge. Nobody is going to prosecute you for it.
- iterateoften 2y agoMaybe grocery stores should be forced to better their inventory control. My “fancy” neighborhood grocery store (upgraded from Vons to Pavilions supposedly as a mark of affluence) I have to check every item because sometimes premade foods like Mac and cheese and those “Kevin” chicken packs are 1-2 months past the best by date. I think food should have a “made on date” in addition. I know on some items you can tell by the code, but for a lot of premade items like flatbreads, etc in the deli they just have a label of when they should be removed from the shelf. Grocery prices are already high. If I buy a premade Mac and cheese and it is 1 month expired, how old is it really? 6 months? A year? Sometimes I pick up one pack that is about to pass the best by date and the best by date of the one next to it is 6 months from now. That means the one that is about to pass is at least 6 months old. How is it right that I have to pay full price for cooked items that are a year old? Modern grocery stores are nasty since they started extending best by dates longer and longer and replaced most fresh deli items with factory made package food that you have no idea when it is made.
- balderdash 2y agoTotally agree on the packing date. Why not just have three dates: “Packaged”, “Best by”, and “Expiration” I feel like that would be extremely clear for people
- homebrewer 2y agoThe proper solution is to put a sticker with the new "use by" date on top of the old one when it expires, like they do in my country. Keeps food waste and prices to a minimum. Of course, you will end up in a hospital now and again, but the last time that happened to me was ten years ago, which is a worthwhile tradeoff to keep grocery store owners happy and the government service (which is supposed to supervise all this) well greased.
- mytailorisrich 2y ago>Maybe grocery stores should be forced to better their inventory control. Throwing away stuff is a loss for stores. They don't want to and make a lot of efforts not to. The thing is that it is extremely difficult to impossible, especially when consumers demand full shelves all the time. On the other hand, expired items on shelves is just a shoddy practice.
- chadbennett 2y agohttps://archive.is/2O8wZ https://archive.is/2O8wZ
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41765006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41765006
- 486sx33 2y agoI guess the question I’ve always had with the “sell by” label is, how much longer is the food good for after that date? A “best before” date would at least give me a chance at not messing that up. However it’s all just a shot in the dark anyway isn’t it ?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoI noticed that the wording on my raw chicken from Whole Foods changed to "best if used by" from "use or freeze by." I worry because they aren't equivalent. Is Amazon just weaseling so they can sell older food? Why can't we just use expiration dates? How long is this safe to eat?
- FloatArtifact 2y agoI doubt it'll lead to to difference in food waste reduction. People often forget different dates are not going to change that. It's an inventory problem, at home and in the grocery store. Barcodes should include all embedded information about the food. It's abit ridiculous, but imagine checking out at the grocery store. A barcode should be embedded with information on the receipt. A the barcode that allows you to ingest your entire shopping cart in one go. It could contain price, nutritional information, serving size, band and so on. Scan one bar coat with your phone and update your home inventory. It's all a matter of infrastructure.