5 ms·
Better discussion by Perun https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A (there is a saying or word for titles as qu
by verdverm 2y ago
Better discussion by Perun
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qnoKpXvj41A
(there is a saying or word for titles as questions, and the answer is always no)
- shawn_w 2y agoBetteridge's law of headlines.
- Pet_Ant 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- googledocsftw 2y ago"Are Betteridge headlines dead?"
- verdverm 2y ago"Is this the one weird trick to rule them all?"
- aspenmayer 2y agoPerun seems to know his stuff. That said, I’d be curious to know more about his research process, as well as that of other Russia-Ukraine war mappers/vloggers. Determining whether grainy drone footage is current or past alone seems difficult to me as an outsider and fan of their work, though I wish it weren’t necessary and that the war were over.
- verdverm 2y agoPerun brings lots of citations and discusses his sources regularly, and always adds caveats. I wouldn't liken his weekly video to those of the daily mappers or telegram video collectors. Very different kinds of content.
- aspenmayer 2y agoI wasn’t meaning to compare them negatively and I don’t really follow other channels on that topic besides maybe Task & Purpose I think it’s called. Not dismissing anything Perun or others have done, just acknowledging that it’s hard to reason about how he goes about gathering the info. I hear him saying he does research, but not the process.
- matusp 2y agoTbh Perun often just takes a report released by RUSI, ISW, or other war think tank and does some narration over it. On top of that, he often extrapolates from very small or noisy data.
- ls612 2y agoHis real talent is to find a bunch of these OSINT reports on a topic, combine them, and then apply his knowledge of economics and game theory and military history and theory to explain what it all means. As a PhD economist I can clearly tell he understands economics and has a talent for teaching it I only wish I did.
- red-iron-pine 2y agodid you expect him to have access too, and release, classified data? What insights do you expect him to have over multi-billion-dollar intelligence and counter-intelligence efforts? like, nearly all commentators, everywhere, are talking about OSINT releases from RUSI or CNA or whoever. and those are based on scraps from official UKR, NATO, RUS, etc. releases.
- hajile 2y agoPerun took a side. A major result is that he often either downplays or outright ignores things that don't agree with his world view. Look at his deductions then see how things actually went. There's almost always a massive discrepancy vs the actual outcome.
- moi2388 2y agoNot really. I find he’s pretty darn accurate. He also usually gives multiple potential outcomes depending on decisions being made
- the_af 2y agoThat video by Perun is 2 years old, while TFA is from today. Surely there have been additional lessons learned in two years?
- verdverm 2y agoNot really, the conclusions are basically the same between both 1. There are no wonder weapons, nor are weapons obsoleted so easily. You cannot look at one in isolation of the larger context. The incidents in one war do not inform the use in all wars or operations. 2. Militaries view these types of things as part of a larger system, the parts of which are combined to create a desired effect. It is situational and Russia C&C is not the same as other countries C&C. 3. War has pro/con evolutions, as the drones progress, so does the anti-drone tech. These same helicopters were allegedly instrumental in preventing Ukraine's counter offensive in Zaporizhzhia, with their standoff anti-tank missiles, popping up above the trees, outside the range of manpads
- the_af 2y ago"Not really" means the war and its tactics haven't changed at all in two years? I find that very hard to believe. I agree with your three points, but they are very high level, a bit like quoting Sun Tzu. The question is whether the attack heli is becoming rapidly obsolete (or at least, relegated to less relevant roles), and I think it might. Other weapon systems have, after all. -- Edit: I love that I got downvoted for asking this even though, sure enough, Perun indeed uploaded a recent video reviewing his opinions of the attack helicopter! Oh, well... that's HN for you.
- kergonath 2y ago> "Not really" means the war and its tactics haven't changed at all in two years? I find that very hard to believe. In this specific respect, not really. Neither Ukraine or Russia really gained air superiority and MANPADS are common. In that context, attack helicopters are not a great weapon. It does not mean that it would be the case in all future wars. Some countries are more capable than Russia. Sure, better anti-drone weapons would help, but it’s a bit early to call helicopters obsolete. Pretty much in the same way as it was premature to call the main battle tank dead as a concept last year.
- szvsw 2y agoAm I the only person who is shocked to realize that this is the same Perun who does strategy gaming YouTube tutorials on a related channel!? I had seen a bunch of his Terra Invicta content… had no idea he also did actual military analysis? Is that what he does professionally in some capacity or is he just an amateur interested in this stuff with a fairly well researched YouTube channel?
- krapht 2y agoI believe in his earlier videos he mentioned that he isn't able to discuss Australian defense procurement on YouTube due to a conflict of interest with his day job.
- moritonal 2y agoI mean, as I watched him destroy my personal definition of what a military industry might look like in X4 I did start to make the connection with the similar sounding war economist I followed.
- endominus 2y agoComplete with slideshows about what he was doing, how he planned to do it, and the logistics involved with becoming the supreme arms dealer and private army to half a dozen governments.
- grotorea 2y agoHe actually started with strategy gaming, then when Russia invaded he started his slideshows on the main channel and ended up with another channel for gaming.
- ls612 2y agoImportantly he correctly predicted the entire broad course of the evolution of the war in the past two years in his first video on like day 10 of the conflict. I’m always impressed by his analysis each week, definitely a channel worth following and binge watching.
- 2y ago
- angry_octet 2y agoPerun is joke among military analysts, who are mostly impressed by how much money he has managed to grift from uninformed, but convincingly spun, waffle.