4 ms·
On the contrary, this is a excellent example of the benefits of open publishing. A very dubious paper is hyped in the press and the actually published work is a
by alex_stoddard 14y ago
On the contrary, this is a excellent example of the benefits of open publishing. A very dubious paper is hyped in the press and the actually published work is available to all to be read and critiqued as thoroughly as it deserves. This, in my opinion, is completely independent from issues with the benefits and problems of peer review.
- zerostar07 14y agoPLoS articles are peer reviewed as well. I was commenting about the standards PLoS sets for itself by allowing this article with this title.