4 ms·
People seem to be in the habit of mistaking "description" with "explanation" or predictive power. I have no doubt that you can describe short term stock market
by Anon84 18y ago
People seem to be in the habit of mistaking "description" with "explanation" or predictive power. I have no doubt that you can describe short term stock market fluctuations in many different ways (fractals and multi-fractals being one of them) that still doesn't get you anywhere close to explaining or predicting those fluctuations. There is good reason for this, of course. Mainly, that short term behavior is mostly psychological. If investors are happy (confident, bull, whatever you want to call it) prices go up, if they are unhappy (scared, bearish, etc) prices go down. To this short time scale behavior you have to add the long time scale component that makes the average market value increase at roughly 10% a year, and the "invisible hand" effect that makes individual stock prices converge (eventually) to the correct value.
IMHO, It's the combination of these three effects that make (short term) stock market fluctuations practically unpredictable.
Here's an hilarious description of this "market sentiment"...
“You have to remember two things about the markets.
One is that they are made up of very sharp and
sophisticated people, these are the greatest brains.
And the second thing you have to remember, is that
the financial markets, to use the common phrase, are
driven by sentiment.
What does that mean?
What does that mean? Well, things, lets say, are just
going along as normal in the market. And then,
suddenly, out ot the blue, one of these very sharp
and sophisticated people says “MY GOD, SOMETHING
AWFUL IS GOING TO HAPPEN! WE LOST EVERYTHING! OH MY
GOD, WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO, WHAT ARE WE GOING TO
DO?!? SHALL I JUMP OUT OF THE WINDOW? LET’S ALL JUMP
OUT OF THE WINDOW! SELL, SELL, SELL! Precisely. And
then, a few days later, this same, sophisticated
person says ‘you know, I think things are going
rather well’ and everybody else says ‘I agree with
you, I think we’re rich.’ [...] And that’s what we
call market sentiment.”
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/k2rLNuMggOKSJWHSpY http://www.dailymotion.com/video/k2rLNuMggOKSJWHSpY
- mitko 18y agovery nice video. Surely, psychology factors play quite a part in the way market works. And also having several variables determined by such factors in chain you can expect to have big fluctuations - exactly the ones that the Gaussian("normal distribution") portfolios fail to explain. the last part of the video explains an example of such chain- and the effect- the subprime crisis.