3 ms·
Over the years I've developed what I call the "lefthanded scissors" analogy: people assume that everyone's mind is wired the same way and that all good programm
by pjc50 2y ago
Over the years I've developed what I call the "lefthanded scissors" analogy: people assume that everyone's mind is wired the same way and that all good programmers are good in the same way and think in the same way, but what if that's not true? What if different people have a predisposition (like lefthandedness) to prefer different tools?
Then a righthanded person picks up the lefthanded scissors and deems them weird and uncomfortable. Which they are .. for the right hand of a right-handed person.
Other popular examples of such taste controversy are Python's semantic whitespace, the idioyncracies of Perl, the very unusual shape of J/APL, and anyone using FORTH for non-trivial purposes.
edit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41766753 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41766753 comment about "other people's Lisp" reminds me, that working as a solo genius dev on your own from-scratch code and working in a team inside a large organization on legacy code are very different experiences, and the "inflexibility" of some languages can be a benefit to the latter.
- arethuza 2y agoI've seen Common Lisp source code that I didn't even recognise as Common Lisp because of over-enthusiastic use of reader macros... Edit: I should also mention that once I worked out how reader macros worked I went on to enthusiastically (ab)use them for my own ends...
- blenderob 2y agoIf there has been over-enthusiastic use of reader macros, I think we will have to admit that the over-enthusiastic developer is no longer writing Common Lisp code. Those reader macros have morphed the language into a new bespoke language. So it is then natural for a new developer to face a steep learning curve to learn that new bespoke language before they can make sense of the code. I'm not condoning overuse of macros. I'd hate to be working with such code too. I'm only stating that Common Lisp is that language that can be programmed to become a different language. They call it a "programmable programming language" for a reason.
- sceptic123 2y agoI would say the analogy fails because it's not about discomfort or weirdness (or taste); left-handed scissors just don't work if you try to use them right-handed. But right-handed scissors don't work if you try to use them left-handed either. So it's not about taste or preference, left handed people learn how to use right-handed scissors, but they can also use left handed scissors in a way that a right-handed person would struggle to. All that said, the analogy still works because most people don't understand why it doesn't work.
- adamc 2y agoAs a lefty who has used right-handed scissors in many situations all my life, it isn't that simple. I can cut with right-handed scissors. It requires changing the way I use them in a way that is a bit weird and unnatural, but it works. It's very much about what is comfortable for people.
- sceptic123 2y ago100% agree that to make them work in the wrong hand you need to use them in a way that feels weird but the original comment was: > a righthanded person picks up the lefthanded scissors and deems them weird and uncomfortable. Which they are .. for the right hand of a right-handed person. What I disagree with is the idea that you can know, just by picking up a pair of scissors if they are left or right-handed. Except for ergonomically shaped ones!, you can't immediately tell. It's only obvious that something is wrong when you try to use them, and even then, I don't think many people would know why.
- kayodelycaon 2y ago> What if that's not true? It is definitely not true. The existence of neurodivergence is proof enough. I can visualize an entire application in my head like it is a forest. I can fly around and see various parts and how they fit together. I am unable to juggle the tokens necessary to do logic and basic math in my head but I have no trouble reading a graph in understanding the relationships between numbers. No matter how many times I try to read it, Lisp is completely inscrutable to me. It requires the same token juggling math does.
- eikenberry 2y agoI've always preferred to use classical "fine" artists as an metaphor for development language preferences. Artists don't just pick up any medium at a whim, most have specific mediums that they excel in and ignore the others. For example Van Gogh produced his most famous works in oil paints. He had worked in other mediums but his talent definitely seemed to shine when working in oils and when he first found oils he took to them quickly and adopted them as his primary medium. Most people definitely seem to have specific preferences built into their talents. I don't see why programming or programming languages would be any different from any other medium or art form.
- Jach 2y agoIn baseball and other sports, pros and cons of different styles are readily and honestly talked about, even when coaches have a bias. See e.g. https://blog.paddlepalace.com/2014/01/coaching-tip-playing-the-seemiller-or-american-grip/ https://blog.paddlepalace.com/2014/01/coaching-tip-playing-t... for table tennis. Few comparable articles in programming exist; either people can't conceive of other styles or contexts, or just want to talk about the superiority of their bias regardless of context. If downsides are mentioned at all it's often not about the preferred thing, but some deficiency of something else. A commonly made up deficiency attributed to Lisp is that it's particularly bad at large scale, either in teams or program size. That would surely be surprising news to the teams doing stuff today or in the past, some responsible for multi-million lines of code systems (some still in operation). Or to use an old example, the documentation for Symbolics Computers, pictured here in book form: https://www.thejach.com/public/symbolics-books-EugyAAEXUAUG_id.jpg https://www.thejach.com/public/symbolics-books-EugyAAEXUAUG_... Such a set of books doesn't come from a "lone wolves only" ecosystem and heritage. Not to mention doc and so on not shown for applications they made for 3D graphics or document editing (https://youtube.com/watch?v=ud0HhzAK30w https://youtube.com/watch?v=ud0HhzAK30w)