3 ms·
Lots of people wonder if it was justified. Since then many historians have examined this and concluded that many of those bombing increased enemy support for t
by bluGill 2y ago
Lots of people wonder if it was justified. Since then many historians have examined this and concluded that many of those bombing increased enemy support for the war and so were counter productive. Bombing of munitions factories and other military installations is still useful, but bombing cities like was often done in WWII is not considered a good idea.
- oneshtein 2y agoTell this to Russians.
- CamperBob2 2y agoWell, Hitler could have told them that, certainly. Doesn't matter whether you're talking about the UK or Ukraine... bombing civilians pisses them off and redoubles their commitment to the fight. It's a waste of munitions, because you'll never kill enough civilians to matter.
- hollerith 2y ago>you'll never kill enough civilians to matter. -- unless you use nukes.
- bluGill 2y agoEven then I question if you can do so. You can level your enemy perhaps, but if the enemy is the US or Russia they have provisions to end the whole world after you level all their cities and so you don't win. If it is anyone else they might not end the world themselves, but there are good odds many countries that otherwise hate each other will join together to destroy you because they don't going nuclear to be an option for the next country. (basic physics and engineering can build a nuclear bomb - it isn't easy, but several countries have proven it can be done and most suspect more would if it was cost effective - but since you can't use them in war it isn't cost effective so they don't)
- hollerith 2y agoNo one can "end the whole world" or bring about human extinction using nukes even if that were their explicit goal.
- SAI_Peregrinus 2y agoIndustrial civilization can be ended using nukes. Too many interconnected supply chains would fail, including those needed to produce fertilizer for modern agriculture. Possibly most human and land animal life could be ended if enough ground burst bombs were used to maximize fallout. Destroying all life is extremely unlikely, e.g. deep-sea hydrothermal vent ecosystems, cave-dwelling life, bacteria, and more will survive even deliberate coordinated attempts by all nations to nuke as much as possible with ground detonations to maximize fallout. Destroying the Earth (a 5,973,600,000,000,000,000,000-tonne ball of mostly iron) is not happening with nukes. When most people say "end the world" they mean "end modern civilization", not "make the planet Earth cease to be a body in hydrostatic equilibrium in orbit of Sol".
- hollerith 2y agoNukes cannot be used to end industrial civilization, either. Nuclear planners have always planned to use many ground bursts: on hardened targets like command bunkers, but also to destroy communications networks. Specifically, a "landing station" where transoceanic cables make landfall or wherever there used to be a 5ESS switch (the locations of which are publicly known) is a great place to hit with a ground burst to destroy much of the nation's non-wireless communications infrastructure. Estimates during the end of the Cold War are that about half of CONUS's area would be covered with lethal levels of fallout from these expected ground bursts. I guess if the Russians and Chinese were deliberately trying to cover as much area as possible with lethal levels of fallout (which they wouldn't because it is not an effective plan) they could cover 70 or 80% -- if they had as many nukes and means to "deliver" them intercontinentally as the Soviets did, which the Russians don't unless they've been hiding them from US inspectors, but I consider it very unlikely that they could've managed that. And bomb fallout is very different from radioactive contamination from accidents at nuclear power plants: basically no area continues to have lethal levels of bomb fallout 4 weeks after the last bomb explodes. The method for decontaminating your house is to get up on a ladder and wash down your roof with a garden hose, then wash down all driveways and sidewalks. So, again, nukes cannot be used to end industrial civilization. Note that this means that if the US ever nukes Russia with everything it has, Russia would bounce back and would again be a military threat (whether that takes 3 years or 15 years I don't know) so it makes little sense to nuke Russia unless the US is going to follow up with a long-term occupation of Russia's ports and maybe some key transportation hubs. The USSR knew it had no chance to occupy US ports or occupy a substantial portion of US territory: their plan for followup was to grab the rest of the European plain, which includes most of Germany and all of northern France to the border with Spain.
- oneshtein 2y agoCurrently, it's Russia leveling their own Russian cities with guided bombs.
- notahacker 2y agoI think the area bombing falls into the category of stuff which on an individual action level was a horrendous waste of life on both sides, but on a strategic level was essential to the Allied victory, because British bombing raids on German cities provoked Hitler into focusing German efforts on bombing British cities, which was considerably less useful to the Germans than the military targets they were hitting before, in the context of Britain desperately trying to avoid the Germans establishing the degree of air superiority that would allow an invasion of the British Isles. A corollary of this is that the sacrifices made on bombing raids later in the war, including by US forces, were a lot less relevant. US bombing strategy was typically more targeted towards military assets than UK bombing though (There is of course also the massive can of worms of how necessary the atomic bombs were: obviously unlike other bombings they actually did bring about immediate capitulation, but in the context that parts of Japanese High Command were opening tentative discussions in the full awareness that they were losing the war, and possibility the US might have been able to offer its surprisingly reasonable ultimate terms instead of unconditional surrender)
- dTal 2y ago>obviously [the atomic bombs] actually did bring about immediate capitulation Not at all obvious: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-stone-kuznick-hiroshima-obama-20160524-snap-story.html https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-stone-kuznick-hi... (this op-ed is the first thing that popped up on a quick google but it has been covered much more thoroughly elsewhere - the short of it is that having a city bombed to oblivion wasn't actually a terribly novel thing for Japan at this stage of the war, whereas the Soviet invasion of Manchuria was a Big Deal)