4 ms·
The survival skills of Helena Valero
- turtleyacht 2y agoFrom Internet Archive: Yanoáma: The Story of Helena Valero, a Girl Kidnapped by Amazonian Indians as told to Ettore Biocca (1996, translated from the Italian by Dennis Rhodes) https://archive.org/details/yanoamastoryofhe0000vale/mode/1up https://archive.org/details/yanoamastoryofhe0000vale/mode/1u...
- jonathaneunice 2y ago> The scarcest resource [in primitive society] wasn't food. It was protection. Interesting meta-claim.
- underlipton 2y ago>Her insights into a primitive (sic) society is worth more than that of the vast majority of anthropologists, for one simple reason: Helena was there for real, as a member of those societies. She didn't only study stone age life. She lived it. This reminded me of Zora Neale Hurston, who had taken a similar approach when studying the history and practice of voodoo in Haiti and Jamaica. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/claiming-space-when-happened-when-zora-neale-hurston-studied-voodoo-haiti/ https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/claimin...
- iwishiknewlisp 2y ago[dead]
- arter 2y agoI can't help it but I do not trust many of the told events here. Some of the events have as much twists and turns as a childish cartoon show. I can understand people killing for revenge but someone finding reason for revenge because a toddler took a piece of meat to eat and that led to a dead dog just seems so insane to me. Insane because these same people are capable of hunting, socializing and crafting stuff which definetely require intelligence. Yet the leaps of logic and reason they make to put the blame on someone to exact revenge on are enormous. Maybe it is all true but I cannot comprehend it.
- numbsafari 2y agoHave you looked at “our” political discourse?
- lovich 2y agoThe concept of zero had to be invented. Inferential logic appears to be a meme that spread early in our development but isn’t an instinctual behavior from our dna. Without memetic viral ideas like civilization we are very close to our other ape relatives like chimpanzees who live similar to this, in that they live very in the moment with a highly volatile social dynamic. It’s not outside the realm of reason that some random tribe/s of humanity didn’t pick up intellectual technologies that we assume are big standard because of how widespread they are in our civilization. That being said, I’d also not trust this 100% given the lack of sourcing or veracity and how many human opinions are interjected, I just wanted to point out that the story is plausible
- lovich 2y agoToo late to edit, I meant “bog standard” and not “big standard”
- Ifkaluva 2y agoI think the thing to note is that both of her primary partners were chiefs. I think such high-ranking men are probably not representative of the typical Yanomamo man. Rising to the top of such groups likely requires a good deal of psychopathy. A measure of charm, but also a reputation for intolerance of sleights, volatility, and gratuitous violence. The article also explains that she didn't accept any husband except the two men that explicitly threatened to kill her if she refused--so in a sense she was indirectly selecting for this type of man. An interesting read on this topic is the very book being dissed in the article--Napoleon Chagnon's "Noble Savages". According to this article, Chagnon met the Yanomamo in a state more exposed to our civilization, but even then many of the high-ranking men come across exactly as I described above: charming when they want, but volatile and gratuitously violent. Two episodes from the book stand out in my memory. - A chief encounters two young men from a rival clan. They are nervous because of this man's reputation, but he calls out to them and offers them food, charms them and puts them at ease. Then he walks behind them and kills them. In his opinion, this is hilarious. - A man suddenly believes his wife has cheated on him. He drags her out by her hair, punches and kicks her head repeatedly. Chagnon is aghast and almost intervenes. I don't recall whether the woman survives.
- throw63738789 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MichaelRo 2y agoWell you gotta look at it from an anthropology point of view. Should a Shamatari kid be born and raised in New York, it would be as civilized as New Yorkers, that is grow to be a rude, aggressive asshole of course. Joking :) These guys are situated in pre-bronze age level of civilization. By the advent of agriculture, society was probably too structured for these sort of primitive shenanigans to hold water much without the guy or the village being obliterated by the larger tribal community. Although I'm not entirely sure. Reading the Bible and Greek mythology, it doesn't seem to be those guys spent much thought before resorting to murderous violence. If kings stole a woman (Helen of Troy) I would suspect it might have been occurring in the common population as well. I'm not sure where the layer of civilization started imposing social norms but these Amazon tribes are (were) definitely preceding that.
- krisoft 2y ago> I'm not sure where the layer of civilization started imposing social norms but these Amazon tribes are (were) definitely preceding that. Clearly not. The story is full of civilisation imposed social norms. Fusiwe was deposed as a headman because he made bad strategic decisions and made enemies. Helena was marked as a dead women because she poisoned some children. Akawe was warned that it is not fair "to hit someone three times without taking a blow oneself". Rashawe held a speech about the good reasons to not kill Helena. Etc etc. These are all social norms. Different in some sense from our ones, but they are definitely not without social norms.
- scotty79 2y agoThis story displays the typical murderous human idiocy that you can also see in the history of major and minor royalty of the middle ages just happening in days not years and on the scale of dozens of humans not hundreds or thousands.
- MichaelRo 2y agoI think I read this sort of "Fusiwe" tribesman story before but can't remember where. Anyway, the level of retardness is unbelievable. I dunno if anyone gave these guys an IQ test or if it's at all possible to conceive one for them but they are definitely not in the "average 100" range. More like 70-60, way smarter than any animal but too stupid to foresee consequences. >> Fusiwe located the Pishaanseteri and promised to kill the first man he encountered. That man turned out to be an old friend of his, a young man who had brought Fusiwe's family a lot of game in the hope of marrying some daughter that any of the wives would give birth to. The young man had parted with Fusiwe in grief when the group split. Nonetheless, Fusiwe chose to kill his former friend, because he happened to be the first Pishaanseteri he saw. Add being a psychopath in addition to severely mentally challenged and you got the perfect combination.
- inglor_cz 2y agoI don't see how this is reflective of low IQ. Ancient mythologies all around the world are full of stories of heroes whose oaths have turned on them. Heck, even Tolkien included the Oath of Fëanor in his mythology, and Fëanor and his sons were no morons. Boasting or tempting fate seems to be a common disease of males everywhere, and in a premodern society, your word is basically your only property and value. Breaking it is bad, similar to getting thrown into Alcatraz and having all your property confiscated bad.
- MichaelRo 2y agoSo .. someone steals from your garden and instead of investigating who is the culprit you decide killing a random person, first random person that you stumble upon? Well, that should send a message but still, first random person that you meet is an old friend and ally, one that has helped you in the past, can investigate in the present who's actually behind those ransackings and will definitely be a valuable asset in the future. Yet you keep true to the "oat" and kill him. Brilliant move, genius! >> Ancient mythologies all around the world are full of stories of heroes whose oaths have turned on them First those are dreamed up facts and not the real world, are you aware? Secondly, the "heroes" in that ancient world are a lot closer to "much muscle little brain" typology than such as Euclid and Einstein. And who the fuck is Fëanor? Some made up fantasy guy? Yeah, that definitely proves your point!
- scotty79 2y agoI think this neatly illustrates why intelligence occurred in humans. Looking at other species we might see that intelligence isn't particularly useful in struggle against environment, it's not greatly important, above certain level neither for predators nor prey. It's more economical to invest in other stuff than abstract intelligence. But when you have dense populations where individuals pose more threat to each other than other things threaten them with outside pressure of mildly dangerous environment that forces the population into groups despite that you just bound to end up with self referential highly advanced reasoning. In such environment there is a selective pressure to develop brains capable of modelling other brains in order to survive and keep your offspring alive. But as your brain gets smarter and more capable so do the brains you are trying to model. This causes tight (rather pathological in the context of living things in general) feedback loop that doesn't develop when predator and prey are of different species. So it really wasn't diet, or tool use or verticality, or brain facial air cooling. It was mostly just that murderous species bread to the point of being its worst enemy.