4 ms·
> My daughter is 10 and she is learning factoring, long division, and other things that a calculator does very well with. But she’s not allowed to use it at thi
by ryandrake 2y ago
> My daughter is 10 and she is learning factoring, long division, and other things that a calculator does very well with. But she’s not allowed to use it at this stage because she can’t learn while using a crutch.
Which seems silly to me, but what do I know, I'm not a teacher. Nobody does long division in real life after K-12 school. It is not a useful skill to have, and it is not a useful concept to know. If I have to divide two numbers I just use a calculator like 99% of the humans on the planet.
Knowing what division is, and what it means to divide one number by another is valuable, but can you just teach that without teaching the mechanics of "divide the partial dividend by the divisor, then multiply the partial quotient by the divisor, and subtract from the partial dividend, extending to the next blah blah blah blah"? Are we really training the next generation for a world without electricity?
- ben_w 2y ago> Nobody does long division in real life after K-12 school. It is not a useful skill to have, and it is not a useful concept to know. To my surprise, when I did pure maths at A level I found the same ideas applied to dividing one polynomial by another. Of course as a mere memorisable algorithm a computer can also do this, so I'm not sure how useful it is even to pure mathematics, but there is (or was, 20 years ago) some use to the idea.
- nasmorn 2y agoMaybe learning to follow a simple algorithm helps some children to structure their thinking. Divisions are not hard to do. Doing a lot of them has little benefit though.
- Izkata 2y agoIntuitively knowing how it works means being able to immediately catch 110 is wrong when you tried to enter 55 / 2 (and mis-typed / as *), instead of blindly trusting it. This was a problem even 20 years ago. I remember one instance from my physics class in highschool, one student's result had gravity going in the wrong direction. The teacher used it as an example for why should understand what we're doing and not to blindly trust our calculators.