7 ms·
How SR-71 Blackbird Designers Overcame Canonical Jet Engine Limitations
- bcrescimanno 14y agoWhile it is fascinating, this is a really long-winded and sort of rambling approach to an explanation of how the J58 worked. Even the Wikipedia page does a better job of describing the engine without all the filler of the author's need to type through his "geek out" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratt_%26_Whitney_J58 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pratt_%26_Whitney_J58
- gcb 14y agoNot to mention that picture with the metal lighting up with the heat and the afterburner on full throttle
- Axsuul 14y agoAll that rambling is just his passion about the topic :)
- ktizo 14y agoHow is it long winded? I thought it was pretty concise. You could fill books on just that one engine.
- bcrescimanno 14y agoWhat's long-winded is the amount of text that's not actually related to the design and operation of the engine. The information he provided was actually fairly slim but there were a lot of proverbial "oohs and ahhs."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jluxenberg 14y agoNeat anecdote about the SR-71's speed from a former pilot http://www.jumbojoke.com/the_king_of_speed.html http://www.jumbojoke.com/the_king_of_speed.html (couldn't find a better link; this is an excerpt from Sled Driver: Flying the World's Fastest Jet by Brian Schul)
- fossuser 14y agoYou'd also probably like this speed story from (I think) the same guy: http://www.planeandpilotmag.com/speed-is-life.html http://www.planeandpilotmag.com/speed-is-life.html
- willvarfar 14y agoooo ooo ooo, any more stories by that chap?
- tjoff 14y agoTwo other stories mentioned among the comments on reddit: http://www.barthworks.com/aviation/sr71breakup.htm http://www.barthworks.com/aviation/sr71breakup.htm http://tailspinstales.blogspot.se/2010/01/slowest-blackbird.html http://tailspinstales.blogspot.se/2010/01/slowest-blackbird....
- excuse-me 14y agoThere is a great podcast featuring an hour long interview with an SR71 pilot and author http://omegataupodcast.net/2012/03/91-flying-the-sr-71/ http://omegataupodcast.net/2012/03/91-flying-the-sr-71/ And take a look at the other omegatau podcasts if you like geeky, if you speak German there are even more
- grecy 14y agoI've read a lot of the Blackbird stories, and that first one might be the best yet. Thanks! Damn, that's an expensive test flight.
- torrenegra 14y agoEven more fun when you listen to it: http://soundcloud.com/torrenegra/the-king-of-speed-sr-71 http://soundcloud.com/torrenegra/the-king-of-speed-sr-71 (This is one of my favorite stories ever. As such, I couldn't resist to get a professional voice to record it. I have tried to contact Brian Schul to transfer the ownership of the recording to him, but I have not been able to get a reply from him)
- WalterBright 14y agoIt always kind of irks me when people talk about the heat of reentry coming from friction with the air. It doesn't come from friction, it comes from compressing the air.
- Retric 14y agoNope, if it was just compression you would not leave a plasma trail that far after the shuttle. Drag aka Friction is rapidly slowing the ~100,000 kg shuttle down from Mach 22. You can get disk breaks to glow slowing down a 1,000kg car from 100mph to zero quickly this is dumping over 2.3 million times that energy mostly into a lot of vary low density air. PS: ((6.9 km/s / 100mph)^2 * 100) = 2,382,349.16
- powertower 14y agohttp://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/eng99/eng99460.htm http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/eng99/eng99460.htm
- Retric 14y agoSure, pressure does increase the temperature, but what's happening is your increasing the pressure of significantly heated air. As I understand it the shuttles bow shock stays under 3ATM during reentry which is hardly enough to be all that interesting by it's self. But, dump enough energy to get air to ~1000c at STP and increase the pressure and you get some real heat. Also the shuttle is descending (aka falling) from LEO which adds significant kinetic energy, but the ride get's a lot more boring at low mach numbers so when you look at the energy needs to dump in that 'glow/burn' phase it's about the same as orbital velocity.
- powertower 14y agoThe point was that heat of re-entry of a blunt object results from compression rather than friction (negligible part), once it reaches the atmosphere (at beginning there is hardly any air and hence temp/heat/compression is small). See more of the discussion here: http://www.rocketryforum.com/showthread.php?31212-Reentry-heat-air-friction http://www.rocketryforum.com/showthread.php?31212-Reentry-he...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- drats 14y agoPlease don't use URL shorteners outside of tweets.
- ballooney 14y agoInterestingly, right now in Oxford UK is being tested a precooler for the sabre jet engine designed to power skylon spaceplanes to Mach 6 in air breathing mode (before going to orbit once out of the atmosphere with stored oxidiser). This precooler is a crucial and fascinating bit of technology, cooling the incoming air down by 1000Kelvin in 100ms without itself frosting up, so it can be compressed and burnt. It is designed to solve exactly the problem outlined in the reddit comment. There was a fascinating BBC article about this recently: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17864782 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-17864782 Looks like a startup rather than 'dinospace' too, for what that's worth round here.
- gcb 14y agoWhy would you cool down to later compress (and heat up again)? Sounds like a shotgun solution to the passer by such as myself Edit: it is a shotgunsolution... They just added an old turbine after the cooler component to test it.
- ballooney 14y agoAt Mach 6 it's just too hot and energetic to compress and stabley combust, as I understand. Recall that stagnation temperature is a function of the square of velocity. The reddit article says the compressor 'puts heat back in' but that's a byproduct rather than the aim. The aim of the compressor in this engine is to get enough moles of oxygen in the combustion chamber with enough moles of hydrogen to combust and produce enough thrust. You couldn't compress the air sufficiently to squeeze it into the combustion chamber if you didn't cool it a bit first. This is my understanding based on reading what's publically available on the net anyway.
- omegant 14y agoThey had to develope a special fuel for the SR 71. One with very high flash point. I imagine that the temperatures at mach 6 are too high for normal fuels too.
- z303 14y ago
- omegant 14y agoIf you like aerospatial history but also if you'll like to know how all this birds were made, you should read "Skunk Works". I have just finished reading it, and is a great book. It tells all the development of the U2, SR71, F117, and more. It's also greatly recomended for entrepreneurs, they worked as an small team, a very talented and focused group of people building unbeliable planes. At the end it has a great rant against all the bourocracy that has built up alog the years at the government. Just an amazing read!
- SkyMarshal 14y agoSecond Skunk Works. They really did some amazing things, and that is probably the best book on it. It reads like folklore.org, in that it's one of the principal people involved retelling the stories.
- whalesalad 14y agoMy dad worked at the Skunk Works for 20 years. I used to love skimming through that book as a kid. I bought one on Amazon not too long ago and still love it.
- D_Alex 14y agoUnfortunately, while the reddit post seems authoritative, it contains a multitude of errors and ends up somewhat misleading. The most significant error is: "What the front half of a jet engine (the intake/diffuser, and the compressor blades, i.e. all the stuff that happens before fuel is burned) does is; it heats up the air until it's hot enough for fuel to ignite" ...etc. The heating up of air in the gas turbine cycle (Brayton cycle) is an UNDESIRABLE, but difficult to avoid consequence of the ideal gas law. A higher efficiency and power output would be possible if this heating did not occur, hence measures such as water injection or intercooling on large stationary gas turbines. There are a number of other more subtle errors in the post.
- D_Alex 14y agoA bunch of redditors did in fact pick up on this, but their comments are buried deep down in the pile.
- screwt 14y agoThis. If you have any interest in manufacturing, IMO the turbine blades in a jet engine are incredible. Without going into loads of detail, 2 points that blow my mind: 1) Due to compression in the intake (and as per the ideal gas law D_Alex mentions above), the temperature of the air when it reaches the turbine is higher than the melting point of the turbine blades. The workaround for this is the blades are made with hollow channels through which cold air is blown, keeping them just cool enough. 2) You may be familiar with 'creep' - where materials under stress gradually relax to relieve that stress, even when the stress is lower than the yield stress of the material. Creep is made worse by (i) repeated stress cycles and (ii) high temperatures. In a typical jet turbine engine, you have blades spinning at 10000 rpm, at high tempratures, with a few microns clearance to the edge of the turbine housing. If they were to elongate and rake the edge of the housing at that speed ...
- yock 14y agois point 1 typical for all turbojet & turbofan engines, or is this specific to then J58?
- tocomment 14y agoHas anyone thought of strapping a rocket onto the SR-71 and getting it to orbit? (Obviously much more complicated than my whimsical comment but maybe do-able ...?)
- starpilot 14y agoThe SR-71 is probably too small to carry a space-faring rocket, but the concept is reasonable: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_launch_to_orbit#Supersonic_air_launch http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_launch_to_orbit#Supersonic_... This splits combined-cycle propulsion into multiple vehicles: air-breathing propulsion for the aircraft, chemical rocket for the spacecraft, thereby improving the efficiency of the whole launch.
- pkennedy 14y agoNot for orbital flight, but NASA did use one as a testbed for rocket engines, such as those for the NASP.
- elteto 14y agoIt's funny how the Internet works sometimes: I clicked on a link on HN to a random comment on a Reddit post, just to find out that I know the original Reddit poster (saw his pic on the post)!!! Haha :)
- cjdentra 14y agoWhat is really cool is to actually see an SR-71. The Intrepid in NYC has one on deck along with the retired shuttle Enterprise. There's a Concorde and some other cool aircraft too.