3 ms·
> Trust me, large language models are not anywhere close to being able to substitute as an effective parent, therapist, or caregiver. You're asking us to trust
by fragmede 2y ago
> Trust me, large language models are not anywhere close to being able to substitute as an effective parent, therapist, or caregiver.
You're asking us to trust you, but why should we trust you in this matter? Regardless of if I think ChatGPT is any good at those things, you'd need some supporting evidence for that one way or another before continuing.
- throwaway314155 2y agoIt's an expression. In this context I just meant "it should be obvious". Maybe try steel-manning my argument first. If you really can't see why that's likely the case after using a LLM yourself, then I'll be happy to admit that I'm making an emotional argument and you're in no way required to "trust me".
- eddd-ddde 2y agoHonestly I don't see it as an "obvious" thing. I won't be surprised if in a couple more years this kind if thing is the norm. I don't think there's anything inherently different from a person that listens to you.
- tempodox 2y agoI'm at a loss for words. If you really think there's no difference between a human and a machine, I don't know what to tell you.
- ben_w 2y agoIt wasn't obvious for a long time, but the closest we have to a relevant experiment* shows that physical contact is also necessary for parenting, especially soft contact: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Harlow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Harlow Humanoid robots are improving, so I won't say "never", but I will say "not yet". Not in isolation at least. * and likely the closest we ever will, because it was disturbing enough to a big influence on animal welfare movement
- fragmede 2y agohttps://chatgpt.com/share/6701aab3-2138-8009-b6b8-ec345b438282 https://chatgpt.com/share/6701aab3-2138-8009-b6b8-ec345b4382... Why is that "not anywhere close to being able to substitute as an effective parent, therapist, or caregiver."? Maybe I've had a bad parents/therapists/caregivers all my life, but it seems like an entirely reasonable response. If there's a more specific scenario you'd like me to pose and show me that it's advice is no good, I'm happy to ask it.
- throwaway314155 2y agoI gladly admit that I was making an appeal to emotional intelligence and you won't likely agree with me no matter what back and forth we go through.
- fragmede 2y agoI'm not sure why you assume I'm coming from a position of bad faith but to skip the back and forth, I'll just plainly state where I'm coming from. I'm agnostic as to the whole thing and ultimately, to be totally transparent, I still have a human therapist, for good reason. But he's only available during set hours so when I'm in crisis at 3am on a Tuesday, I also fully admit that I'll have conversations with ChatGPT. I'm sure I'm not alone in doing so. I'm not trying to convince you that it's, right now, a replacement for a human parent/therapist/caregiver. it's the "not anywhere close" part that I'm responding to. It's closer than talking with a speak and spell, or a See'n'say, for instance, but also ahead of static worksheets that you can't have a conversation with. I have no idea if this is good for society, and I have no idea where this technology will take us. I want to know the limitations of this technology, and I'm willing to be convinced that, hey, maybe what some of it's saying isn't helpful as a therapist, because that's interesting. The number of R's in strawberry, for instance has a specific technical reason it's bad at, because of how tokenization works. If, after being fed every psychology textbook, the advice it gives would be egregiously or subtly bad/wrong/harmful, or biased towards, say, giving a Freudian analysis when the industry's moved way past that, I'd like to know and hear about it, so I better know when not to trust its advice and be able to warn others.