4 ms·
Task-Switching Experiment (2015)
- Balaakay 2y agoVery interesting. I will take some time tonight to run the demo. I am a big believer in not switching tasks if it can be avoided. I loved Cal Newport's book "A World Without Email" which discusses context switching in the 'information worker' space as something that brings productivity to a halt. I believe he is right.
- dtran 2y agohttps://www.psytoolkit.org/experiment-library/experiment_multitasking.html https://www.psytoolkit.org/experiment-library/experiment_mul... for the actual runnable experiment. Shared my results below (I'm pretty tired at the moment so don't feel my sharpest)— super curious what others got. I've been trying to eliminate multi-tasking as much as I can, but the nature of startups day-to-day and even what seems like a single/monotask when zoomed out now often involves context switching (For say, investigating and fixing a user-reported bug, I might have to toggle between VSCode, localhost in browser + the DOM inspector or console, our bug tracker, our support ticketing tool, Slack, and sometimes the Cody window in VS Code/ChatGPT/Claude: RT in pure trials: 448ms RT in mixed trials: 710ms Mixing cost: 262ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 710ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 975ms Task-switch cost: 265ms
- userbinator 2y agoFirst time: RT in pure trials: 490ms RT in mixed trials: 825ms Mixing cost: 335ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 825ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 969ms Task-switch cost: 144ms Second time (while listening to music --- I decided to do this since I've noticed it somehow decreases my latency in typing tests significantly): RT in pure trials: 436ms RT in mixed trials: 673ms Mixing cost: 237ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 673ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 746ms Task-switch cost: 73ms Edit: third time, also while listening to music: RT in pure trials: 435ms RT in mixed trials: 608ms Mixing cost: 173ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 608ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 700ms Task-switch cost: 92ms I suspect this "game" is also amenable to practice, and find it at least a bit weirdly addictive in the same way as Flappy Bird.
- darthrupert 2y agoFascinating that you're measuring milliseconds where I'm having context switches that cost me minutes to hours to days.
- userbinator 2y agoI don't think this game is all that representative of context-switching overhead, as my 4th attempt gives evidence that this improves quickly with practice: RT in pure trials: 422ms RT in mixed trials: 611ms Mixing cost: 189ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 611ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 602ms Task-switch cost: -9ms The "mixed trials" are naturally slower because I'm having to recognise 4 patterns instead of 2, but only by ~50%.
- dtran 2y agoWhoa, a negative task-switch cost! I didn't take it multiple times, but it makes sense that having practice at this specific task probably improves both your overall response times and maybe more specifically improves the different trials. What I'm curious about is whether we also get specifically good at say, task-switching between a code editor and say, Stack Overflow, over time
- dang 2y agoYeah it might be more fun to have that be the top link, so I've switched it from https://www.psytoolkit.org/experiment-library/multitasking.html https://www.psytoolkit.org/experiment-library/multitasking.h... now. Thanks! Interested readers should take a look at both of course.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rickyyean 2y agoHere's mine on first-try: RT in pure trials: 463ms RT in mixed trials: 833ms Mixing cost: 369ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 833ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 1040ms Task-switch cost: 207ms
- makeitdouble 2y agoIt's so interesting to be able to run the experiment and see for one-self, especially if it's really a matter of 10-15min. It should be noted that research in this domain is usually done with multi-sensory tasks (e.g https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31277054/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31277054/), and not same channel input like this experiment. It better balances the cognitive load and it's also more realistic, as most people multi-tasking will be using different resources, for instance filling a form while on the phone, or sitting a team meeting while releasing in production.
- LoganDark 2y ago> For example, no matter how deeply you concentrate on doing a task, if you hear someone shout "fire", you will process that information and act on it. Not necessarily with Dissociative Identity Disorder! (Or dissociative disorders in general)
- quzyp 2y ago. RT in pure trials: 511ms RT in mixed trials: 804ms Mixing cost: 293ms RT in task-repeat trials (in mixed blocks): 804ms RT in task-switching trials (in mixed blocks): 1026ms Task-switch cost: 222ms I think this is very easy to "train" and would expect to see significant improvements on the second and third attempt.
- PaulRobinson 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hislaziness 2y agoThe screen seems to be stuck at Wait a second... for me.
- swah 2y agoI thought that that was the test, stuck here, help.
- hippari2 2y agoThis is fun but I supposed you should not take this test more than a few times. After a while I notice that I read the whole ( shape, filling, position) as an input and it's quite a bit faster than initial timing.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoPerforming the test in fixed order creates a risk of bias due to either training or exhaustion. With a sufficiently big data set, it would be interesting to show the test to different groups in different orders, or at least repeat one of the "easy" tests at the end. I noticed that my performance significantly dropped towards the end because my brain was just fried. (Also, who else did the test while task-switching to HN while waiting for something to finish?)