2 ms·
Not sure this is a technology-specific problem. You can block a non-self-driving car by simply standing in front of it, too, as long as there is nowhere to reve
by ryandrake 2y ago
Not sure this is a technology-specific problem. You can block a non-self-driving car by simply standing in front of it, too, as long as there is nowhere to reverse to. In both cases, there's not much that the occupant can do without bringing unpleasant consequences onto themselves. What are you going to do? Drive over the person? Do it and you'll be in bigger trouble than the blocker. This is what makes those Just Stop Oil protests do-able: Because a law abiding motorist is largely helpless if a human is in front of their car and won't move.
- maxerickson 2y agoAt some point, sure, run the person threatening your safety over. Running over a protester isn't entirely comparable.
- tomcam 2y ago> Running over a protester isn't entirely comparable. What if they’re blocking emergency vehicles? Seems to me it’s very possible that they could be a few dozen cars back in heavy traffic. In the USA we don’t have good laws for this.
- teqsun 2y ago> In the USA we don’t have good laws for this. hence why it's a current go-to in the protestors playbook. If/When such laws are introduced, different tactics will be used instead, I predict.
- quantified 2y agoI haven't had to deal with this yet, but wouldn't moving slowly just push someone out of the way? If they are lying down I suppose that'll be a problem, but at least they can't spray-paint you.
- teqsun 2y agoI disagree. Blocking vehicles as a pedestrian is a nuisance regardless of motivation and ideology, but no one deserves to be run over unless they are presenting a threat that legally and morally justifies lethal force.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 2y agoAt some point ... threatening your safety I guess that isn't overly specific, but what the hell else do you think I meant?
- quantified 2y agoCue the trolley problem, like I'm trying to get my wife to the hospital. The South African cars outfitted with flamethrowers come to mind.
- infotainment 2y agoThe key problem is that there’s no threat of being run over with the self-driving car. With a human driver, there’s always a chance that the driver will choose to plow through you. Especially if it’s just one person, by moving forward slowly but deliberately a driver can create a distinct “if you don’t step aside you might be run over” type threat. With a robotaxi, you can be assured that a big company will never permit one of their cars to drive over you.