3 ms·
Is there any route to automating America's ports? Could it work out in negotiations to give massive payoffs to current workers in exchange for allowing future a
by xnx 2y ago
Is there any route to automating America's ports? Could it work out in negotiations to give massive payoffs to current workers in exchange for allowing future automation?
- kelseyfrog 2y agoMaybe I'm understanding this wrong, but you're asking why dockworkers don't cash out and pull the ladder up behind them?
- xnx 2y agoThat is my question. People do it all the time in all kinds of situations, why not here too?
- underseacables 2y agoBecause dockworkers have a union that can use its size and influence to slow down the shift to automation. For them its job protection which is more important for them than increasing efficiency, lowering costs etc for the shipping companies etc.
- s1artibartfast 2y ago>For them its job protection which is more important for them than increasing efficiency, lowering costs etc for the shipping companies etc. Sure, but that isn't the question they were asking. They weren't appealing to the workers sense of efficiency. They simply asked if they can be paid off.
- Suppafly 2y agoI feel for dock workers, but the bulk of their job is one that is going to be replaced by automation. The industry as a whole should work on reskilling and encouraging early retirement and such for the existing workers.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoReskilling is not in their best interest. These people are paid enormous amounts of money because employment is so strictly controlled by their cartel. Reskilling would mean taking a paycut of $100,000+. The only way to buy these people out is to set them up for life
- Suppafly 2y ago>Reskilling is not in their best interest. Only because they think their job will still be around. You can only prop up an industry with inefficient fake jobs for so long, and dock workers are getting near the end of that cycle. >The only way to buy these people out is to set them up for life Or just let them fail when their job is eliminated. Having some plan to step down the number of employees gradually through buy-outs, retirement, and reskilling, is the better option.
- shortrounddev2 2y agoYeah the best solution is to automate the docks, but these unions are very politically powerful, which is why their jobs still exist in the first place. It's also a bad look for a democratic president to bust unions so if Kamala wins then I think these guys are safe for another 4 years. I don't think their strategy is sustainable, but I don't think it will be very simple to get rid of them
- s1artibartfast 2y agoIsn't the proposal under discussion exactly that, set them up for life and make it in their interest?
- johnnyanmac 2y agoThe jobs max out at $40/hour on the east coast. Lots of overtime pay as well, but that's not something to encourage. That's part of the issue. west coast shoremen do indeed make 6 figures. There's less to lose in the East coast unless you truly are a workoholic. >The only way to buy these people out is to set them up for life Pension plan would work fine too. But we know companies would rather die than bring that back. Loyalty is dead after all.
- nothercastle 2y agoThey probably could you would have to bribe both workers and leaders and probably something like 50-100k
- BugsJustFindMe 2y ago> Could it work out in negotiations to give massive payoffs to current workers in exchange for allowing future automation? Absolutely it could. The real obstacle is a pervasive Calvinist workism that rejects paying people to stay home (essentially severance pay) even when it would be better for everyone. The ports could easily make this offer, and the offer would easily be accepted by the union at some threshold of payout. The ports just don't make the offer.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoPretty much. It's not enough to be more productive. There's still a "butt in seat mentality", and corporate cannot imagine paying someone who's no longer working for them. And given the US's pathetic string we call a safety net, the businesses need to foot that bill if they really care about efficiency and long term benefits. But it's never truly about "advancement" for these people. It's control.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI think that is a reasonable direction to explore. Another one would be long term job security for current individuals, but unrestricted headcount. While I think progress is important, I dont think we should repeat what we saw with NAFTA or heavy industry. It simply isnt realistic to expect every 50 year old dock worker to be able and willing to retrain and retool as a software engineer (not that that is a particularly good option right now). I think a reasonable compromise between the unions and ports could be found where they essentially freeze hiring and allow headcount to dwindle as folks age out. perhaps some internal retraining would be possible as well so that people aren't just sitting on their hands.
- rasz 2y agoThe way things are going it might be easier and cheaper to build brand new west coast automated port and outcompete incumbents to the ground.