3 ms·
While I do agree that social interaction is key to innovation, it is also becoming less and less bound to geography. All the studies and books presented are ba
by rglullis 18y ago
While I do agree that social interaction is key to innovation, it is also becoming less and less bound to geography.
All the studies and books presented are based on the data that is older than the Internet. Hacker News is as good as a city sidewalk for the exchange of ideas. And it doesn't cost me 2k/month in rent.
- pchristensen 18y agoI think the Internet will strengthen the trend, rather than weaken it. People outside of a specific innovation cluster can take part in it through the internet. People that live in that cluster can participate through the Internet and in person. That's a big advantage that will only become more pronounced over time. Face to face is so much higher bandwidth that important parts of it will never be reproduced online. Why do you think YC requires you to be in person?
- rglullis 18y agoActually, I think that will be more important is the ability of people to come and go. It's the velocity of social interaction between talented people that it's important, not the amount of aggregated "human talent capital". YC requires people to be in person, but only during the 3 month period. That is the time it takes to make all the social interactions that are needed for that stage. If Internet access, smart people and population density were important to innovation, Tokyo would give birth to the majority of tech startups and cultural achievements. It doesn't.
- pchristensen 18y agoPopulation density and personal interaction are important to innovation, but only certain kinds of innovation are highly profitable. SV has a big edge there because it has the highest density of people with the resources (mental, financial, relationship, etc) to produce tech startups. Ditto for film in LA, fashion in Milan, finance in NYC, etc.
- h34t 18y agoI agree, and I'd say these differences between cities fall under the label of 'culture'. Population density and personal interaction are necessary but insufficient. I taught SAT prep in China for a couple of months. If population density and personal interaction were all that are required for innovation, my students would have been creative geniuses. Instead, the results of cultural patterns such as fear/obedience/submission to authority dominated my impressions of all but a few.
- DaniFong 18y agoHonestly the bandwidth on HN is pretty low. You still have huge advantages if you're meeting or working with someone in person. Written communication is different though. Like photographs, sometimes the snapshots of written thought are more expressive than the moving, interactive thing.
- h34t 18y agoI agree, geography is becoming less important. I've done a lot of my best work from tiny outposts in rural Canada where the internet was my only lifeline to people who even knew what Javascript was. The internet has really transformed possibilities for a lot of people who are otherwise trapped in intellectual wastelands. I think culture far outweighs other factors. Hacker News is useful because of its culture, not its algorithm (otherwise Digg would be just as good) or the size of its user base. The internet lets you find and connect with a culture that amplifies your instincts and interests. When that can lead to in-person interaction as well, all the better (and there are definite advantages to that).