5 ms·
Right, so the first choice is door 1, and the host reveals that door 3 is a goat. The decision to switch or not is really a decision between door 1 and door 2.
by cconstantine 18y ago
Right, so the first choice is door 1, and the host reveals that door 3 is a goat.
The decision to switch or not is really a decision between door 1 and door 2. At this point isn't your first guess completely irrelevant?
I've heard this problem and the reasoning before, and for some reason I can't get myself to believe that switching is better.
- zack 18y agoYou need to switch in order to re-cast your guess.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- emmett 18y agoThere are two possibilities when you pick door 1: either you've picked a door with the prize behind it (33%) or you've picked a door with a goat behind it (67%). Assume you stick. In that case, you have a 33% chance you've picked the right door, as before. Opening another door doesn't change whether you've picked the right door or not originally. Assume you switch. In the case you've picked a door with a goat originally (67%), you will necessarily switch to the door with the prize. In the case you've picked a door with the car originally (33%), you will necessarily switch to a door with a goat. Therefore switching gives you a 67% chance of picking the door with the prize. Another interesting strategy to consider is "randomize" - what if you picked randomly between the two remaining doors? Then you'd have a 50% of getting the prize, since you're selecting randomly between two doors, one of which you know contains the prize.