4 ms·

You forgot to mention the number of contributors who have been blocked. (It's five.)

maxlin 2y ago
That's like saying only 5 devs were shot, there's tens of thousands left. The behavior of the Godot Foundation is so out of touch with the community and the general idea of trying to provide a product/service that is not politically aligned by its base idea, and whose audience is politically diverse and don't expect Godot to engage with polarizing acts. I've literally never seen a Discord blow up and grow as fast as this one.
- favorited 2y ago
  Banning 5 people is actually not the same as shooting them.
  - maxlin 2y ago
    No, neither is my example, but in the parallel it communicates a tit for tat. Blocking work of actual devs off the cuff damns the stance of Godot.
    - krapp 2y ago
      Godot is doing fine. Most of the community is on their side, and they've gotten donations and support in solidarity for their stance. Development continues unabated. Meanwhile the only thing Redot has accomplished to date is an angy logo. Something tells me those "actual devs" weren't contributing anything of value, if at all.
      - maxlin 2y ago
        Congratulations you're spewing disinformation about Redot (it has pull requests take in while Godot is so pissed of it they just banned Redot's lead dev from Godot's repos, for doing the same unpenalizable thing, meaning telling Godot to not get in to politics and do games instead). Even if godot somehow "won" this, it's a pyrrhic victory where they've ruined their community and have made an example for future projects / and or other C# engines which are back in the spotlight. Your defense for Godot's actions of "Most of the dev community is intact". Yeah but how about ALL of it having been intact? Absolutely nothing was gained from this. Maybe some day they'll see their error but even then, they'll have achieved less in total.
      - ultra_chad 2y ago
        Nothing tells you that, of course.
  - ultra_chad 2y ago
    Indeed, banning is far worse.

That's like saying only 5 devs were shot, there's tens of thousands left. The behavior of the Godot Foundation is so out of touch with the community and the general idea of trying to provide a product/service that is not politically aligned by its base idea, and whose audience is politically diverse and don't expect Godot to engage with polarizing acts. I've literally never seen a Discord blow up and grow as fast as this one.

favorited 2y ago
Banning 5 people is actually not the same as shooting them.
- maxlin 2y ago
  No, neither is my example, but in the parallel it communicates a tit for tat. Blocking work of actual devs off the cuff damns the stance of Godot.
  - krapp 2y ago
    Godot is doing fine. Most of the community is on their side, and they've gotten donations and support in solidarity for their stance. Development continues unabated. Meanwhile the only thing Redot has accomplished to date is an angy logo. Something tells me those "actual devs" weren't contributing anything of value, if at all.
    - maxlin 2y ago
      Congratulations you're spewing disinformation about Redot (it has pull requests take in while Godot is so pissed of it they just banned Redot's lead dev from Godot's repos, for doing the same unpenalizable thing, meaning telling Godot to not get in to politics and do games instead). Even if godot somehow "won" this, it's a pyrrhic victory where they've ruined their community and have made an example for future projects / and or other C# engines which are back in the spotlight. Your defense for Godot's actions of "Most of the dev community is intact". Yeah but how about ALL of it having been intact? Absolutely nothing was gained from this. Maybe some day they'll see their error but even then, they'll have achieved less in total.
    - ultra_chad 2y ago
      Nothing tells you that, of course.
- ultra_chad 2y ago
  Indeed, banning is far worse.