5 ms·
> It is not a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon. It’s more palatable when we consider not the observation, but the information that was collapsed o
by rbanffy 2y ago
> It is not a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon.
It’s more palatable when we consider not the observation, but the information that was collapsed out of the superimposed states at the time of the observation. The universe uses lazy evaluation, and things only happen when they have effects on other things, and what we see as past depends on what we observe now, as both need to be consistent with each other.
- ricksunny 2y agoIf I'm not mistaken some gaming physics engines work this way too, am I mistaken? Something akin to avoiding calculating the details of a voxel until it is observed by the gamer?
- codetrotter 2y agoWhich raises the question, if a tree falls in-game, but only non-playable characters are there. Does the falling tree make a sound when it hits the ground?
- mabster 2y agoIn most games I would suspect the tree doesn't fall. Philosophy bypassed!
- gnz11 2y agoSound is only perceived, it’s not intrinsic to the event itself.
- codetrotter 2y agoDo the NPCs in the game perceive sound?
- inopinatus 2y agoNot quite like voxels, because that implies some higher existence defining a grid. Avoiding that requires a more local definition of existence in terms of adjacency. I’ve always encoded it thus: “All matter is information, all information is functional, and perception is therefore the lazy evaluation of the universe.” In the Greg Egan edition of this thesis, the speed of light emerges as a property of evaluative propagation through a functional universe, and new forms of consciousness are encountered living within the algebraic structure of the cosmos.
- avaldez_ 2y agoNot specifically physics engines but graphics engines use "hidden surface determination" to avoid rendering what's outside the camera view. Frustrum culling, occlusion culling, LOD optimization, space-partition based clipping, etc. This video does an amazing job explaining some of those. https://youtu.be/C8YtdC8mxTU https://youtu.be/C8YtdC8mxTU (highly recommended channel too)
- chadcmulligan 2y agographics engines do, they only display the visible pixels, the others are culled out of the calculation
- krunck 2y ago> The universe uses lazy evaluation Brilliant.
- rbanffy 2y agoThank you. I doubt I’m the first, however.
- layer8 2y agoThe observer being part of the universe suggests that the observer becomes entangled with the superimposed states as well by the observation, and that nothing collapses. > The universe uses lazy evaluation […] That’s only a sensible notion if you assume that time exists outside of the universe instead of being part of it. Wheeler’s idea of space-time being non-fundamental suggests the latter.
- inopinatus 2y agoThis may be reconciled by defining the speed of light in terms of the latency of evaluation.
- dustingetz 2y agowhich experiment proves the universe uses lazy evaluation? this seems like interpretation
- akira2501 2y agoWheeler suggested to expand the observations of the "double slit apparatus" into the "delayed choice experiment" which was then itself expanded into the "delayed choice quantum eraser experiment." From the Wikipedia article: "Wheeler pointed out that when these assumptions are applied to a device of interstellar dimensions, a last-minute decision made on Earth on how to observe a photon could alter a situation established millions or even billions of years earlier." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed-choice_quantum_eraser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delayed-choice_quantum_eraser That's not to say that this is "proof" but I think this is where the notion is most directly apprehended.
- SilasX 2y agoWhich, to be clear, then invalidates at least one of the assumptions, right?
- martin-adams 2y agoI would guess the double-slit experiment to fit this analogy.
- wholinator2 2y agoIt is an interpretation, the Copenhagen interpretation. There are other possibilities and nobody knows the real ground truth yet. All our speculations are just that
- medstrom 2y agoSpeculations done correctly can have a good chance to arrive at truth. That's also known as reasoning. There's probably no experimental confirming or disconfirming this, ever, but that doesn't mean all theories stand on equal ground. After almost a century of discussions between smart people, the physics consensus has steadily inched away from Copenhagen. That said, that doesn't mean lazy evaluation isn't happening. You just can't use lazy evaluation to "explain" wavefunction collapse, it's more the other way around, that collapse can be a lazy evaluation trick. It'd describe only this simulation and say nothing about outer reality (thus no longer works as evidence for or against the simulation hypothesis, it's just a consistent part of the story given that it's true).
- bwood 2y agoI've been compiling a list of ways in which physical reality is similar to game engines or mechanical simulation in general. Here's my list so far: - The observer effect, quantum entanglement and wavefunction collapse --> lazy evaluation - Speed of light --> speed of causality to resolve the object interaction problem O(n^2) - Quanta of energy, Planck's length --> discretization of reality to limit computational precision - Unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics --> reality is implemented with mathematics - Parsimonious physics --> simple physical rules are less computationally expensive to evaluate - Entropy --> stability of the simulation and a guaranteed "wind down"
- szvsw 2y agoFor speed of light, a more direct analogue (though your example still makes sense) would be what is often called the “speed of sound” in numerical methods (like the finite difference method, aka FDM), which is often closely related to both temporal and spatial discretization schemes and can lead to numerical instability (cf. CFL condition, Von Neumann stability analysis, etc). It’s also related to things like stiff problems. It essentially has to do with how fast computational information propagates through the simulated domain. Note that it is still called “the speed of sound” even when you are not simulating the wave equation! (At least by my profs)
- state_less 2y agoThe simulation framing tends to draw deterministic connotations. I think when people think of a simulation or perhaps physical interpretations, they imagine life as happening to them, rather than through them. I think it’s easy to perceive it one way or the other, and what you seek you will find. But something like ‘lazy evaluation’ could provide a bridge between the two views. A choice is made AND a physically compatible path is observed as if it were always so from the past to the present. Personally, I think of the universe is alive with choice and we do get to participate. PS. I kept a copy of Kip Thorne’s Black Holes and Time Warps on my nightstand as a kid - it filled me with fascination. Thanks Kip!
- szvsw 2y ago> The simulation framing tends to draw deterministic connotations. I bristle at this because there is obviously a massive amount of probabilistic programming methodology and stochastic simulation techniques out there, but at the end of the day in terms of connotation you are probably correct…
- codesnik 2y agoall the wavefunction collapses only needed to compute future/far away collapses, we are all just thunks, evaluated because we needed for the final compute.
- perryizgr8 2y ago> The universe uses lazy evaluation That's a crazy assertion to me. Is this something proven using experiments or your conjecture? I would think a pebble floating in deep space, not interacting with anything, would still exist. If you go out there you would see it having a position and velocity. That information has to be preserved and processed continuously to ensure that an observer after 10000s of years still sees a consistent state.
- jdblair 2y ago> you would see it having a position and velocity but not at the same time!
- doodlebugging 2y agoIf a phenomenon is not a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenom and since the act of focusing on an observation yields information only about the phenomenon that we are attempting to observe, what happens to all the informations pilling out around it that becomes part of the unobserved phenomenon in the defocused region nearest the phenomenon that we are observing with highest focus? Basically, is it true that nothing exists until we observe it with high enough focus that the information it contains builds its own reality. If this is true then does it mean that I need to wear my glasses all the time to experience reality and when I leave them on my desk I'm slipping thru an unfocused stream of information that only loosely defines a reality because I am unable to adequately focus on those things that I need to be observing, therefore they aren't quite definable phenomena.
- keshet 2y agoAnd if I drink alcohol then my world also becomes kind of blurry.. then reality also becomes less defined? It sure feels that way. But not to my friend sitting next to me who chose not to drink. We live in separate realities at least as far as our individual experiences are concerned.