12 ms·
Mega-victory: Kim Dotcom search warrants “invalid,” mansion raid “illegal”
- pdeuchler 14y agoDoes Dotcom have any legal recourse to sue the FBI/US Gov't if he is found not guilty/the case is thrown out? People need to realize that this kind of action is not O.K., and those responsible should be brought to justice.
- toyg 14y agoSince Mega/Dotcom had no representation in the US (on purpose), I'd say no. He could try going after the NZ police though.
- grecy 14y ago> He could try going after the NZ police though. According to the judge, the NZ Police clearly broke the law, so he should go after them.
- genwin 14y agoThe US gov't doesn't have to answer for its crimes, obviously. For example, to achieve everlasting immunity they simply don't subscribe to the international court.
- rhizome 14y agoNobody can sue the US Government without the US Government's permission.
- refurb 14y agoCorrect, it's called sovereign immunity.
- mkaltenecker 14y agoUS citizens most certainly can.
- 30thElement 14y agoOnly in specific circumstances. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_United_States#Federal_sovereign_immunity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...
- nnnnnnnn 14y agoNo, they cannot. Sovereign immunity is absolute. US citizens can only sue when granted permission. As 30thElement noted, the Federal Tort Claims Act grants this permission to sue. But there is no such right, and it is within the Federal government's power to change its mind and repeal the statute.
- mkaltenecker 14y agoYou mean civil lawsuits? That’s not what I was talking about.
- rhizome 14y agoWhat were you talking about then? "Suing" is always a civil action. Taking someone to court for a criminal act is called prosecution and can't be done by just anybody.
- PerryCox 14y agoPrevious discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4170398 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4170398
- w1ntermute 14y agoI hope Dotcom comes out of this victorious and relaunches MegaUpload. It was the best free one-click hosting site out there - everything available at the moment sucks. Not to mention it would be a wonderful "fuck you" to the US government, abusing its global hegemony for personal purposes.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoIf it does relaunch, the constant publicity Kim and MU have been receiving will only help their numbers.
- gscott 14y agoKim Dotcom might not be going to America but his money has already flown the coop. He is broke now, the United States will keep his money he will never see any of it back. He won't be able to pay for hosting, and because his servers are here in the United States the government won't let him have them back/turn them on.
- kintamanimatt 14y agoMaybe, but even if that's the case he started from nothing before. I honestly think he could even pull off a fundraiser. I thought his money has been seized by the NZ government though.
- steveh73 14y agoYes, NZ govt. Some of it has been returned to cover living expenses. Although I understand he also had/has some money in Hong Kong.
- Zirro 14y ago"Kim Dotcom might not be going to America but his money has already flown the coop. He is broke now, the United States will keep his money he will never see any of it back." If the seizure of his assets is deemed illegal by the court, must they not be returned? Potentially, along with compensation for the damages caused to infrastructure and reputation of Megaupload, not to mention the unnecessary force used with the raid of his house. After all this time and attention in media, such a sum would be enormous.
- wissler 14y agoThe US government has successfully destroyed the world's largest storage medium that they couldn't just walk in and spy on without detection (US-based companies are subject to The Patriot Act and other "laws" that stand in defiance of The US Constitution). I don't see how this counts as a "victory." It is probably all part of the game plan.
- flyinRyan 14y agoBut on the good side, it should be harder to get other countries to simply play the bitch and do whatever the US says in future.
- njharman 14y agoThat's not how these things work. Governments don't give up. Next time they will not make same mistake or get laws passed so this is no longer mistake/illegal or just do it again the same and gamble they get a more cooperative judge.
- flyinRyan 14y agoEvery country is not the US. There are still a lot of countries where the people have some say in what goes on and fight against such laws getting created in the first place.
- zaphar 14y agoI'm curious now. Does the warrant being invalid open the US up to a class action suite from people who lost data? I know nothing about the law regarding this sort of thing but its what immediately leaped to my mind when I saw this article. [Edit: spelling]
- maeon3 14y agoKim will get his servers and hardware back.... Pulverized to pieces by the might of a legion of pissed off FBI data workers who had their power checked and found lacking. You gotta set an example that even when you win a battle against organized crime, they make you pay dearly for every inch.
- danielweber 14y agoI thought he had leased them all.
- flyinRyan 14y agoWonderful! Kim Dotcom doesn't seem like the cleanest of individuals but the US government is even worse. I hope that people in NZ law enforcement suffer enough career damage that other countries think twice before simply bending over for US exceptionalism.
- res0nat0r 14y agoI asked this in the other thread but no one responded so I'll try here again: This appears related to Dotcoms house raid and seizure. Is the raid on all of the servers in VA still valid? I'd assume that is where the majority of all of the evidence in this case lies, and if that is still valid there is still a huge case to be had. Does anyone know?
- redthrowaway 14y agoThe raid in VA is "valid" until a US court says otherwise. The NZ court only has jurisdiction over those parts of the case that pertain to NZ, although it has ordered the US to turn over any evidence they have on K.C to his defense. Again, though, that's only as it relates to the extradition process.
- Squazic 14y agoHis wife is hot.
- vecinu 14y agoShe's only there for his money. Kim isn't a hero, nice or generous person. He's just a geek with money who is now 'abusing' his new found wealth. I don't look up to him, personally.
- J3L2404 14y agoWell you are one of the few on HN. Although a lot of it is probably more of a hate America thing, which is always popular.
- kaonashi 14y agoRight, because disagreeing with U.S. government policy is equivalent to hating the entirety of America.
- J3L2404 14y agoI meant a sympathetic view towards dingleberry was partly due to a dislike of America( government, corporations, certain people) and not because they think he is a swell chap.
- vecinu 14y agoMost people enjoy jumping on the bandwagon, I prefer to look at the bigger picture.
- drivingmenuts 14y agoCold comfort, since the FBI will keep his servers tied up in knots until the end of time and most likely, refuse to pay for the loss of business.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoInteresting comment stream. In one view you have 'America, World Police' being handed a defeat. That is a good thing because I believe that both the precedents the USA is trying to set on the world scene are wrong, they will also come back to roost in unpleasant ways. In one view you have a victory for the Libertarian Internet which gives us a stronger 'nation independent' view of the Internet, but this is part of a wider set of events which are trying to figure out the role of the 'information-state' if such a thing could exist. This is stuff SF writers have chewed on considerably and to see it in 'real life' is fascinating. In the third view we have someone who has many of the characteristics of 'nerds' which seem to have taken on some of the aspects of a counter culture. The interesting things is that this fiasco has neatly tied together three on-going 'conversations' [1] about the autonomy of the Internet, the role of nation states in world government, and the rise of 'nerd culture'. As we enter the 'post-American' century the discussion of world government will be be, by far, the most influential on our day to day lives, but the autonomy of the Internet will also become a central theme, much as human rights is a central theme in our interactions. The story of Kim Dotcom will then fade to being the tag line for one of the things that shaped how we feel about the first two. [1] The term 'conversations' here is used to indicate that its a topic of discussion at all levels of our society with various competing views fighting for dominance as the 'group consensus'. This is also the name of the process by which a community arrives at a common understanding much like two people conversing about the topic might come to a consensus.
- adamsmith 14y agoIf the 150 TB's slowed down local law enforcement enough to make them mishandle the warrant, any bets on how many petabytes he'll have waiting for them next time? : )