2 ms·
The use of WordPress.org shared resources and the WordPress trademarks? I think this isn't all that complicated.
by tptacek 2y ago
The use of WordPress.org shared resources and the WordPress trademarks? I think this isn't all that complicated.
- gamblor956 2y agoThe use of which were already allowed under the existing open source licenses... In other words, a shakedown by another name. Also, suggesting that WPE's contributions to the non-profit could be satisfied by paying Matt's for-profit company is almost the textbook definition of private inurement. I don't think he had lawyers familiar with non-profit law clear that offer before he made it. If I worked for the IRS right now WP and Matt would be pretty high on the list of organizations to take a closer look at.
- tptacek 2y agoCan you be more specific about where the WordPress licensing grants the trademark usage WPE is using? WordPress is GPL2, which doesn't have a lot to say about trademarks.
- graeme 2y agoIsn't it just the law? Not obvious that terms such as "Wordpress Host" violate nominative fair use. They're commonly used throughout the industry as well.
- tptacek 2y agoI would like to understand what "[t]he use of which were already allowed under the existing open source licenses..." from the preceding comment meant. I'm not a lawyer. Nominative fair use is complicated, as is WPE's use of the WP marks. All I can hope for here is to understand what claims people are making.
- graeme 2y agoAh, fair point. Yeah I agree, the open source licenses have no bearing on the matter. Only permissions would come from either trademark law or a negotiated agreement.
- FireBeyond 2y ago> use of the WP marks I realize you may just have been abbreviating, but until the middle of this current dispute, the WordPress Foundation explicitly allowed the use of "WP". Matt just edited it after framing it as a trademark issue.
- tptacek 2y agoYes, I'm just abbreviating.
- gamblor956 2y agoYes, it's basic trademark law. Matt's supporters are deliberately trying to obfuscate several issues to make it look like Matt is in the right. Matt's was alleging violations of the license and the trademark. And he's wrong on both accounts.
- graeme 2y ago1. The shared resources are baked into Wordpress code, and used by wordpress users no matter which host they are with. Does Matt wish webhosts to fork the repository? 2. Nominative use allows companies to refer to things by their name. It isn't obvious that "Wordpress Hosting" or "Wordpress plugin" is a violation or causes consumer confusion. Does Matt wish for all companies in the ecosystem to stop referring to their products as Wordpress Themes, Wordpress Plugins and Wordpress hosts? It's worth noting that for years Wordpress.org has routinely referred to companies as "Wordpress hosts" For example: https://learn.wordpress.org/tutorial/migrating-your-wordpress-website-to-a-different-host-and-domain/ https://learn.wordpress.org/tutorial/migrating-your-wordpres... They don't seem to find it confusing and I suspect it would be difficult for Wordpress to launch a legal claim given tolerance of and direct use of those terms.
- tptacek 2y agoSo? The GPL doesn't say anything about "baking resources into the code"; the point of the GPL is that you can change the code, and WPE, a gigantic company, should do so.
- graeme 2y agoWhat I meant was does Matt wish for all hosts to fork the repository so it is not a central place for plugins? To appearances Wordpress was architected to work the way it does, suggesting that he wished it to work the way it does. If the central repository is a problem, then each site draws on it in proportion to their usage and it isn't obvious why one site is an issue and others aren't. Hence my question, does he wish hosts to move away from a central repository? He certainly can advocate for that but it's a larger issue than WPEngine. Also sort of adjacent but Matthew Prince of Cloudfare has just offered to donate resources to fund the whole central repository: https://x.com/eastdakota/status/1841154152006627663 https://x.com/eastdakota/status/1841154152006627663
- tptacek 2y agoI don't think anybody, including Mullenweg, is seriously claiming WPE is threatening the integrity of the WP.org servers with all their load. It seems pretty clear that WP.org is a stick the Foundation is going to use to get commercial WP users to kick in resources, along with the WP trademarks. The norms of open source software don't really have much to say about this. Mullenweg is right: the typical thing companies that run GPL projects do when they end up competing with firms that don't pay their freight is to relicense. Being a little ruthless with trademarks seems strictly superior to switching to a "source available" license.