3 ms·

If your mp3 is copy protected and your calculator bypasses that copy protection, it is in fact illegal (in the US)

by wilsonnb3 2y ago

altruios 2y ago
Such a translation would be "format shifting" which is protected under US/UK law (IANAL).
- wilsonnb3 2y ago
  I think you are correct in the case of an actual MP3 file and calculator. I was thinking they were metaphorical.
  - altruios 2y ago
    Not just a mp3 file. any media you have purchased can be format shifted by you for archive/personal purposes. regardless of DRM/copy protections. What is illegal is redistribution (thus the copyright). Again: ianal. But this is kind of a fundamental right. If you own something, it's yours to do with privately as you wish. If you don't own the copyright, then you can't redistribute.
    - zerocrates 2y ago
      The DMCA makes breaking DRM illegal, even when done for fair use purposes, if it doesn't fall into a small number of tightly-defined exceptions. And they can go after tools that enable people to do this, as well (think of DeCSS for example).
- kevin_thibedeau 2y ago
  The US AHRA requires serial copy management (SCMS or an equivalent) when using format shifting to digital media. Nobody bothers to follow that part of the law and it seems to have never been enforced.
textadventure 2y ago
There is no such thing as an mp3 being copy protected. A game on a cartridge is not "copy protected" either.
- johnnyanmac 2y ago
  >Copy protection, also known as content protection, copy prevention and copy restriction, is any measure to enforce copyright by preventing the reproduction of software, films, music, and other media. I don't see much point in making the theoretical argument of "nothing is unhackable". The point of protection isn't to make some absolute defense, it's to mitigate low effort thieves. Any house can bypass a lock by using a cheap hammer on a window, but I'd still call a house lock a "lock".

If your mp3 is copy protected and your calculator bypasses that copy protection, it is in fact illegal (in the US)

altruios 2y ago

Such a translation would be "format shifting" which is protected under US/UK law (IANAL).

wilsonnb3 2y ago
I think you are correct in the case of an actual MP3 file and calculator. I was thinking they were metaphorical.
- altruios 2y ago
  Not just a mp3 file. any media you have purchased can be format shifted by you for archive/personal purposes. regardless of DRM/copy protections. What is illegal is redistribution (thus the copyright). Again: ianal. But this is kind of a fundamental right. If you own something, it's yours to do with privately as you wish. If you don't own the copyright, then you can't redistribute.
  - zerocrates 2y ago
    The DMCA makes breaking DRM illegal, even when done for fair use purposes, if it doesn't fall into a small number of tightly-defined exceptions. And they can go after tools that enable people to do this, as well (think of DeCSS for example).
kevin_thibedeau 2y ago
The US AHRA requires serial copy management (SCMS or an equivalent) when using format shifting to digital media. Nobody bothers to follow that part of the law and it seems to have never been enforced.

textadventure 2y ago

There is no such thing as an mp3 being copy protected. A game on a cartridge is not "copy protected" either.

johnnyanmac 2y ago
>Copy protection, also known as content protection, copy prevention and copy restriction, is any measure to enforce copyright by preventing the reproduction of software, films, music, and other media. I don't see much point in making the theoretical argument of "nothing is unhackable". The point of protection isn't to make some absolute defense, it's to mitigate low effort thieves. Any house can bypass a lock by using a cheap hammer on a window, but I'd still call a house lock a "lock".