3 ms·
How will we identify a legacy admission? In the past they were identified, at least in admissions records, because they were legal. Now they'll be admitted as
by mmooss 2y ago
How will we identify a legacy admission?
In the past they were identified, at least in admissions records, because they were legal. Now they'll be admitted as a non-legacy student and then what?
Will someone sue the school, obtain the student's application and records, and create a case against their admission? Think of the student dragged over the coals publicly at 18 years old, accused of being too dumb for the school. How will they know which students' admissions to challenge? Who will have standing to challenge their admission - someone who didn't get in? The state?
If you wonder how a school will select legacy admissions, it seems easy: A private conversation with the dean. Also, any admissions officer will be expected to reliably know the landscape and act 'in th best interests of the school'.
- pessimizer 2y agoIt's like how you can't fire somebody for being black, but you can fire them for wearing an ugly shirt. If you can make decisions for arbitrary reasons, getting around specific prohibitions is just an intelligence test: are you so impressed with yourself, or so stupid, that you have to write down your illegal reasoning somewhere? Did you have to brag about it in an email?
- mmooss 2y agoI get your point, but it's also different in several ways: The fired person knows of the illegal act, knows the facts, and has standing and motivation to sue. For the legacy admission, nobody knows it happened, much less knows the facts (the student's qualifications), much less has standing to sue.