9 ms·
John Wheeler saw the tear in reality
- MichaelZuo 2y agoHaving every ‘observer’ also ‘participate’ seems to just make it even more intractably complex? Since presumably ‘participators’ can influence each other simultaneously. So I just don’t see how any of these theories are attractive prospects, the infinite regress seems even more severe than superdeterminism theories. It’s quite a shame this man got stuck on something that may be literally impossible to prove.
- mistermann 2y agoUnderstandability to era-bound humans is not a prerequisite for existence luckily.
- ko27 2y agoIt's not like we are any closer to resolving the measurement problem today. I wouldn't be quick to dismiss Wheeler, all alternative theories for this problem are radical or "unattractive".
- svachalek 2y agoIt's not like being radical or unattractive has anything to do with validity though.
- kstenerud 2y agoExcept that Wheeler got a LOT of things right, and this was in his wheelhouse. And he wasn't making a statement of fact on this, merely expressing his confusion that it wasn't making sense (yet). And then he died before he could figure it out. All we have left are little strands of his thoughts.
- kps 2y agoThere is no other kind of observation. You observe a photon when it and your retina (or device) participate in a physical interaction.
- TheOtherHobbes 2y agoDefine "you."
- Finnucane 2y agoIt also seems a little narcissistic to assume that humans are the only 'observers' or 'participants' who are determinative.
- akira2501 2y agoObserve is bad language. It implies a conscious act. "Incident" or "Interact" seem like better roots but the conjugations are even more overloaded in terms of human meaning.
- nzzn 2y agoQuanta is such a great resource! High value spend from Jim Simons vast pool of dollars. I came across MTW’s “Gravitation” as a student in the 70’s and it inspired a positively unreasonable desire to own a copy just because it looked so beautiful. Couldn’t afford the doorstop of a book at that time but happily it is still in print 50 years later.
- oersted 2y agoThey are good at framing advanced science as intuitive and engaging stories, context is always appreciated. Although, frankly, whenever I see the Quanta URL I tend to skip straight to the comments. It's too verbose to my taste, I just want to understand what the discovery is about, get an understanding of the substantive details without too much prerequisite knowledge, and understand the impact on other research and possibly on applications. But I start reading the article, and it always reads like a biography. The writing is excellent, but I'm afraid I don't always have the time for the literary angle. I am willing to spend a while understanding it but focusing on the meat of the science, the peripheral story comes after if I'm curious.
- piva00 2y agoI tend to save Quanta's articles for my "slow reading" part of the day. Exactly because of the more literary prose that I know I will enjoy but need the time to appreciate. Also, I don't think I've ever had to spend more than 10 minutes to read one of their articles, it's time well spent, or maybe I'm just nostalgic for longer-form magazines that I miss from my younger years.
- abecedarius 2y agoSimilar. But I recently read this parody all the way through and lolled https://mathenchant.wordpress.com/2024/09/17/our-fractional-universe/ https://mathenchant.wordpress.com/2024/09/17/our-fractional-...
- hypertexthero 2y ago“Hope produces space and time?” The longer I live the more I appreciate Kurt Gödel’s proof that we can never know everything about the universe. https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-godels-proof-works-20200714/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-godels-proof-works-202007...
- rbanffy 2y agoYou’d need something bigger than the universe to represent everything in the universe.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 2y agoIt would be funny to find this out empirically. Like in the tower of Babel?
- rbanffy 2y agoAccording to the legend, they didn’t find it amusing.
- bumbledraven 2y agoNot if compression is involved.
- qingcharles 2y agoThis is why I have a totally unhinged belief that it might be possible to emulate the universe inside the universe itself.
- joseph_b 2y agoEverything sounds so simple until we try to explain it. If the emulation is contained inside the universe being emulated, do you think the emulated universe includes the emulation contained within it? Does the emulation now contain another emulation? If so, now many emulations?
- excalibur 2y ago[flagged]
- m0llusk 2y agoGoing from pregeometry to spacetime as information with observer participation might in ways relate to the law of increasing functional complexity. What if observers start as other particles but join together to iterate in increasingly large combinations in order to generate increasing complexity in spacetime phenomena? Exotic particles in space might be kind of like interesting minerals forming in comets and so on.
- rbanffy 2y ago> It is not a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon. It’s more palatable when we consider not the observation, but the information that was collapsed out of the superimposed states at the time of the observation. The universe uses lazy evaluation, and things only happen when they have effects on other things, and what we see as past depends on what we observe now, as both need to be consistent with each other.
- ricksunny 2y agoIf I'm not mistaken some gaming physics engines work this way too, am I mistaken? Something akin to avoiding calculating the details of a voxel until it is observed by the gamer?
- codetrotter 2y agoWhich raises the question, if a tree falls in-game, but only non-playable characters are there. Does the falling tree make a sound when it hits the ground?
- mabster 2y agoIn most games I would suspect the tree doesn't fall. Philosophy bypassed!
- gnz11 2y agoSound is only perceived, it’s not intrinsic to the event itself.
- codetrotter 2y agoDo the NPCs in the game perceive sound?
- inopinatus 2y agoNot quite like voxels, because that implies some higher existence defining a grid. Avoiding that requires a more local definition of existence in terms of adjacency. I’ve always encoded it thus: “All matter is information, all information is functional, and perception is therefore the lazy evaluation of the universe.” In the Greg Egan edition of this thesis, the speed of light emerges as a property of evaluative propagation through a functional universe, and new forms of consciousness are encountered living within the algebraic structure of the cosmos.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- excalibur 2y agoSeriously, this article brings to mind the classic short story about a simulated universe: https://qntm.org/responsibility https://qntm.org/responsibility And also the wildly speculative conjecture that our universe will be retroactively created by a super intelligent AI in the precise manner necessary to facilitate its own existence, from which it follows that we exist for the express purpose of creating it. (If anybody knows the source I might have stolen this one from please let me know.)
- pnut 2y agoMaybe "the last question"? https://users.ece.cmu.edu/~gamvrosi/thelastq.html https://users.ece.cmu.edu/~gamvrosi/thelastq.html
- collingreen 2y agoThere is a dark version of this (with some pascal's wager thrown in) called Roko's basilisk. Maybe that's what you're thinking of? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roko%27s_basilisk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roko%27s_basilisk
- pavel_lishin 2y agoThere's also a Stephen Baxter novel, where a splinter group of humanity called "Wigner's Friends", believes something like this to be the case. I forget which one it is, but it's part of the Xeelee Sequence.
- Vecr 2y agoRoko's basilisk isn't retrocausal, maybe you're thinking of some Nick Land thing? But even there it's hard to tell how literal he is being with the Terminator analogies (if you haven't seen the movie it has time travel in it), the sanewashed version of his thesis revolves around thermodynamics, chaos theory, and strange attractors.
- gom_jabbar 2y agoFor a detailed discussion of retrocausality in Nick Land's work, check out the https://retrochronic.com/ https://retrochronic.com/ introduction. There's even a dedicated Terminator section. Nick Land interprets Roko's Basilisk as "retrochronic AI infiltration".
- its_bbq 2y agoOn the blackboard he and his students wrote "Godel's Proof -- too important to be left to the mathematicians." As a mathematician, I'd love if anyone here knew the context
- floatrock 2y agoNot a mathematician and it's been a number of years since I read GEB, but my rough takeaway of the incompleteness is self-referential systems are magical because they can create statements that can't be proven in that system. "This sentence is false" or "Can God create a burrito so hot He cannot eat it" and all that. So if Wheeler is saying the universe comes out of quantum observation, then the connection seems to be a self-referential Strange Loop of consciousness/observation/participation along the lines of "we're just the universe observing itself"
- cosmic_dust9 2y agoWouldn't that be a limitation of language rather than the ability to form concepts?
- floatrock 2y agoAgain, not a mathematician so I'm likely butchering all this, but my layperson's understanding is Godel showed there's a kind of equivalence mapping between english language and mathematical symbolic language. It's all just information juggling (and you can use the equivalence to translate things you can prove with mathematics into the other trickier languages). So if sub-matter quantum-woo is just information juggling, then it's the ability to have self-referentiality that makes for some interesting properties.
- swifthesitation 2y ago> His incompleteness theorems meant there can be no mathematical theory of everything, no unification of what’s provable and what’s true. What mathematicians can prove depends on their starting assumptions, not on any fundamental ground truth from which all answers spring[0]. So why leave it solely to the mathematicians. [0] https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-godels-proof-works-20200714/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-godels-proof-works-202007...
- openrisk 2y agoThe really tough problems require minds that are wired differently and John Wheeler's mind was definitely a thing apart. Its the sort of unique mental fingerprint or aesthetic that characterizes great talents in this space (Feynman and Penrose are other examples of this trait, imho). Compare Gravitation (the bible) and its boldness, inventiveness and playfulness with the sterile presentation of most theoretical physics textbooks before and after. Anyway, he failed to bring on a new paradigm for "deep" physics. The intersection of geometry and quantum mechanics seems to be as elusive and mysterious as ever. But hope produced all our mental breakthroughs and, who knows, it may do so again.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pvg 2y agoCompare Gravity Total pedantipoint but the book's title is Gravitation of which he was one of three authors.
- zombiwoof 2y agoGod gives hope
- actionfromafar 2y agoWonder if the movie Interstellar was inspired by Wheeler.
- dcminter 2y agoNot exactly, but they had Kip Thorne as their science advisor and Wheeler was his Phd supervisor!
- ricksunny 2y agoIt's interesting we have such receptivity in the HN community here on physicist-proposed metaphysics (yay!), yet in an entirely similar light - an article covering physicist Roger Penrose's 'microtubules' on HN a couple days ago, we get the reflexive "but experts say this is bunk' treatment. Personally I don't know from Sam on either hypothesis. I'm just wondering for all things seeming equal, when do we get receptivity from the HN community and when to anticipate the knives coming out? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41696559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41696559
- PTOB 2y agoThe real question - which I do not intend to answer - is, "Are the same HN users who are receptive to the metaphysics here also providing the 'experts disagree' retorts?" If we were to categorize the different mindsets of HN users and study their reactions, we might be able to treat the whole as an organism and the different groups as organelles. Then we poke it with sticks for science!
- szvsw 2y agoIt can be pure chance. Who commented first, who happened to click the article, the time of day it was posted, the style of the website the article was hosted on, etc etc. it’s easy to get sucked into the illusion that the commenting population is a stationary distribution when in fact it might be highly multimodal and each thread is not a representative sample of the overall population. Having said that, your question still stands, I suppose I’m just thinking it ought to be phrased differently? why does one article trigger more engagement than others, and why does one article trigger more engagement with certain subsets of the HN population? (Whereas your phrasing could seem to suggest there are monolithic grand narratives that describe what “The HN community thinks”)
- kayo_20211030 2y ago[flagged]
- westurner 2y ago/? "Wheeler's bags of gold" https://www.google.com/search?q=wheelers+bags+of+gold https://www.google.com/search?q=wheelers+bags+of+gold Holographic principle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holographic_principle : > The existence of such solutions conflicts with the holographic interpretation, and their effects in a quantum theory of gravity including the holographic principle are not yet fully understood. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Archibald_Wheeler https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Archibald_Wheeler
- hcarnot 2y agoThe source of his confusion is believing that all observers must share a single reality. This is not the case: as an observer of event A=a, you only share the same reality as all other observers who also measure A=a (or anything downstream of A=a). If some observer comes along and measures A=b, they split away from your reality. Only the version of that observer that saw A=a stays with you. There is no "remote synchronization" mechanism between observers. All observations are independent, and when an observation is made, the other outcomes are not discarded, they continue "running in parallel" until another observer comes along. That is to say, from the perspective of other observers, you and your measures are also an observation they have to make (and thereby collapse).
- bmitc 2y ago> The source of his confusion That's a fairly strong claim when referring to one of the greatest physicists and deepest yet wide ranging thinkers of the 20th century.
- Filligree 2y agoYet this is essentially the consensus interpretation of MWI.
- saulpw 2y agoDoes this make the Law of Attraction valid, then? That what we focus on determines the reality that we traverse.
- Vecr 2y agoNo. Or, maybe, but go demonstrate a merely gas-based Laplace demon first.
- hcarnot 2y agoNo, reality is not related to what we "focus" on. I don't subscribe to quantum observer anthropocentrism (which is also something that Wheeler fell prey to): an "observer" doesn't have to be conscious and doesn't have to be human. An observer is simply something in the universe whose state causally depends on some quantum phenomenon. For that thing to resolve its state, it needs to "measure" the outcome of the quantum phenomenon. That is all.
- bamboozled 2y agoHow can there be a tear in reality, surely, what's behind the tear is more...reality?
- grishka 2y agoWho said that consciousness is "private property"? What if it's actually shared between people, like a field of some sort or another dimension, but everyone somehow gets their very own part of it? We know nothing about the nature of consciousness, so let's not assume anything about it. It might arise from the physical processes in the brain and be bounded by our known physics, sure, but it might just as well be something else entirely.
- saulpw 2y agoWhat if awareness is a field instead of a process? Like a moving magnet induces electric current in a coil of wire, decoherence in microtubules could induce qualia in the awareness field. See also: Alan Watts.
- grishka 2y agoProcess is something that happens over time. We don't know what time is because it might as well be an artifact of consciousness itself, so this particular distinction between a process and a field feels pointless. Time might arise from us moving in that field for example.
- joshuamcginnis 2y ago1. Everything that begins to exist has a cause. 2. The universe began to exist. 3. Therefore, the universe has a cause. 4. This cause is uncaused, timeless, spaceless, and immaterial. 5. To create the universe, this cause must possess intentionality and decision-making capabilities. 6. Therefore, the cause of the universe is a personal, immaterial being: God.
- Vecr 2y agoWell, if you accept the argument it only gets you to an infinite or at least very large number of objects that meet the stated requirements. Not one object in particular. And here "object" is quite vague, I would assume almost all of the specifications would be unrecognizable as such to a human.
- joshuamcginnis 2y agoI'm more than willing to volley these ideas with you but I'm not following. I didn't once use the word "object" so I don't follow your refutation here. Could you elaborate? Are you saying that my conclusion collapses to a single "cause" (which I'm calling God and you're calling an object?)
- Vecr 2y agoNo, by the Principle of Multiple Explanations, every "object" that satisfies your conditions is equally viable, everything being equal. You can slap a hypercomputational simplicity prior on that if you want, but that probably militates against the object being God, because I wouldn't expect God to be "simple" under that definition.
- joshuamcginnis 2y agoIt's possible there are multiple explanations, I give you that. No one can know for certain. The argument against it; however, is more logically coherent and parsimonious than the multiple theory. Happy to dig into why that is if you want to go deeper.
- unparagoned 2y ago>Why don’t they create 10,000 separate space-times? How do we know it doesn’t? The whole wavefunction collapse and single world is an untestable and unprovable assumption.
- renox 2y ago> By choosing what to measure in the present, we participate in the creation of the past. Not everybody accept this interpretation of this experiment!!