3 ms·
Labor is the source of all wealth and all culture (Marx). They strike because they can, and their labor has value. If it didn’t, the strike would not be feared.
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Labor is the source of all wealth and all culture (Marx). They strike because they can, and their labor has value. If it didn’t, the strike would not be feared.
Why should we care if the corporation profits more? I am not in the top 10% owning 93% of total US equities, so I do not care. Automation so the wealthy get wealthier doesn’t help anyone but the wealthy, and they need no help. Consumer excess can come from there as well, vs the pockets of people who do actual work.
- seizethecheese 2y agoAutomation helps everyone via lower consumer prices. It’s really basic economic theory that capital would not capture all the gains here.
- ahupp 2y agoThe cost of shipping contributes to the cost of every product we export and import. Treating this as a purely zero-sum transfer between longshoreman and shippers is ignoring all the reasons this is interesting & important. As a hypothetical example, if there was some new method of transport that bypassed ports entirely at 1/10th the cost, would you support an effort to scuttle it to support longshoreman? This same issue played out with the introduction of the shipping container; if history had played out differently and we were still manually packing ships I don't think you'd choose that world over what we have today.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoGreat comment, and I'm glad you brought this point up so we can deep dive. If you read the book "The Box: How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger by Marc Levinson," (Chapter 6: Union Disunion) [1] it covers the historical negotiation and agreement between the longshoreman unions and shippers when the shipping container improved efficiencies; they split the gains from the efficiency improvements knowing it was going to reduce the need for labor into the future. If that was on offer today, I would have a different opinion, for sure. I would strongly support Automating All The Things. I think the grand bargain that was previously made when the world standardized on shipping containers was reasonable and fair. But that is not what is on offer. What is on offer is the Robber Barron equivalent of folks attempting to automate as much as possible to the detriment of labor for shareholder and management returns, and because of that, I hold the opinion that I do. With the decline in labor unions and lack of labor regulation in the US for the last several decades (since the Ronald Reagan era, broadly speaking), Capital has ground down Labor, and Labor needs to grind back to make up for lost time and ground [2] [3]. [1] https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691170817/the-box https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691170817/th... [2] https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ [3] https://www.epi.org/blog/growing-inequalities-reflecting-growing-employer-power-have-generated-a-productivity-pay-gap-since-1979-productivity-has-grown-3-5-times-as-much-as-pay-for-the-typical-worker/ https://www.epi.org/blog/growing-inequalities-reflecting-gro...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Labor is the source of all wealth and all culture Of course it isn’t. To make this construct work in the modern world requires amortising past labour across future automation in a way that almost deifies the first work.
- piva00 2y agoHow is that "of course not"? All wealth comes from labour, somewhere, somehow. To build automation requires labour, to create the machines (or the machines that create the machines), operate them, etc.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoLabor is a component. Often a required component. That does not mean it is the source and and value creation can be solely attributed to it. Labor by itself produces no value. Roll a rock up and down a hill and no value is created. The labor theory of value is Myopic in this respect.
- piva00 2y ago> Labor by itself produces no value. Roll a rock up and down a hill and no value is created. The statement isn't that all labour produces value but that labour is the source of all value. Without labour there's absolutely no way to provide value. I'd like to know an example of something that produces value without labour, I really cannot come up with one.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> I'd like to know an example of something that produces value without labour A painting by a long-dead artist. That’s what I meant by “amortising past labour across [the] future.” (I phrased it badly originally.) Also, natural resources. The total value of a chopped-down tree is well in excess of the labour used to chop it down.
- dudisubekti 2y agoIf you live in neoliberal capitalist country, your wellbeing is tied to the profit of the private company that runs the infrastructure… If they don’t find things profitable, then they would just not run said infrastructure, disrupting the lives of many people. This is why strikes make people nervous.