3 ms·
> Excellent move by Newsom. [...] It was basically a torpedo against open models. He vetoed it in part because the threshold it applies to at all are well-beyo
by dragonwriter 2y ago
> Excellent move by Newsom. [...] It was basically a torpedo against open models.
He vetoed it in part because the threshold it applies to at all are well-beyond any current models, and he wants something that will impose greater restrictions on more and much smaller/lower-training-compute models that this would have left alone entirely.
> Market leaders like OpenAI and Anthropic weren't really worried about it, or about open models in general.
OpenAI (along with Google and Meta) led the institutional opposition to the bill, Anthropic was a major advocate for it.
- worstspotgain 2y ago> He vetoed it in part because the threshold it applies to at all are well-beyond any current models, and he wants something that will impose greater restrictions on more and much smaller/lower-training-compute models that this would have left alone entirely. Well, we'll see what passes again and when. By then there'll be more kittens out of the bag too. > Anthropic was a major advocate for it. I don't know about being a major advocate, the last I read was "cautious support" [1]. Perhaps Anthropic sees Llama as a bigger competitor of theirs than I do, but it could also just be PR. [1] https://thejournal.com/articles/2024/08/26/anthropic-offers-cautious-support-for-new-california-ai-regulation-legislation.aspx https://thejournal.com/articles/2024/08/26/anthropic-offers-...
- FeepingCreature 2y ago> I don't know about being a major advocate, the last I read was "cautious support" [1]. Perhaps Anthropic sees Llama as a bigger competitor of theirs than I do, but it could also just be PR. This seems a curious dichotomy. Can we at least consider the possibility that they mean the words they say or is that off the table?
- worstspotgain 2y agoJust two spitballing conjectures, not meant to be a dichotomy. If you have first-hand knowledge please contribute.
- ForOldHack 2y agoOne of the very most apt descriptions. One company trying to raise alarms about another company in the same business. I have been following this since IBM released $67,000 "Intellect" "Business Intelligence." and Lotus HAL.
- arduanika 2y agoHe's a politician, and his stated reason for the veto is not necessarily his real reason for the veto.
- jodleif 2y agoMakes perfect sense since his elected based on public positions
- ants_everywhere 2y agoThis is the ideal, but it's often false in meaningful ways. In several US elections, for example, we've seen audio leaked of politicians promising policies to their donors that would be embarrassing if widely publicly known by the electorate. This suggests that politicians and donors sometimes collude to deliberately misrepresent their views to the public in order to secure election.
- jnaz343 2y agoSometimes? lol
- mistrial9 2y agoworse.. a first-hand quote from inside a California Senate committee hearing chamber.. "Don't speak it if you can nod, and don't nod if you can wink" .. translated, that means that in a contentious situation with others in the room, if allies can signal without speaking the words out loud, that is better.. and if the signal can be hidden, better still.
- duped 2y agoThis is an old saying in politics and you're misinterpreting it - it's not about signaling to allies, it's about avoiding being held to any particular positions. You're also missing the first half, "don't write if you can speak, don't speak if you can nod, and don't nod if you can wink." The point is not to commit to anything if you don't have to.
- raverbashing 2y agoAnthropic was championing a lot of FUD in the AI area
- inferiorhuman 2y agoNewsom vetoed the bill as a nod to his donors plain and simple. Same reason he just signed a bill allowing a specific customers at a single venue to be served alcohol later than 2 AM. Same reason he carved out a minimum wage exemption for Panera. Same reason he signed a bill to carve out a junk fee exemption specifically for restaurants. He's just planning for a post-governor career.
- ldbooth 2y agoSame reason the governor appointed public utility commission has allowed PG&E to raise rates 4 times in a single year without legitimate oversight. Yea unfortunately all roads point to his donors with this smooth talker, cost of living be damned.
- iluvcommunism 2y agoOn the east coast we don’t need the government to control electricity prices. And our electricity is cheaper. Go figure.
- ldbooth 2y agoCompanies like Dominion Energy, Duke Energy, and Consolidated Edison are regulated by state utility commissions, same as in California.
- ForOldHack 2y agoWhy did New Jersey get more toxic waste dumps than California has lawyers? They got first choice. We will trade Newsom for a failed reactor. Please.
- inferiorhuman 2y agoOh yeah I forgot this one — basically making it easier to force neighborhoods to abandon their natural gas infrastructure. Something I'd be in favor of were it not for the constant stream of electric rate hikes. https://www.kqed.org/news/12006711/newsom-signs-bill-to-help-california-neighborhoods-ditch-gas-and-go-all-electric https://www.kqed.org/news/12006711/newsom-signs-bill-to-help...