3 ms·
> All I can come up with when I search for safe jobs is athletes, politicians, and live music performers. Anything where the point is specifically human effort
by ben_w 2y ago
> All I can come up with when I search for safe jobs is athletes, politicians, and live music performers.
Anything where the point is specifically human effort rather than the actual result, plus ones that set their own rules.
So yes, athletes and politicians; for the moment also prostitutes (pending better bioprinting, not because it's in either category); but also some art — not all art, just the art where the point is to show off how rich you are; most live music was automated away a century ago, what remains is likely also the category of art where the expense is the point.
- the_af 2y agoThere exists art where the human connection and effort is the point, and this is not because you want to show off how rich you are ("owning" this kind of art is not what most of us are after). However, Transformers movies and equivalent "art as a product" will be made by algorithm or GenAI, if they aren't already.
- miki123211 2y ago> ones that set their own rules. So also doctors, lawyers, teachers, soldiers and government workers. It's not that they can't be replaced by AI, they just won't legally be allowed to.
- the_af 2y agoI can see soldiers being replaced by AI if the latter becomes demonstrably more cost effective. Laws won't be able to stop this, because the other side will use AI if it's better (cheaper, cost effective, etc). Teachers cannot be replaced by AI if you see them as more than just "knowledge passing". If you think the human component of the teacher-student interaction is fundamental, as I do, teachers won't be replaced, though they may use AI to assist them.
- Jensson 2y ago> If you think the human component of the teacher-student interaction is fundamental What is the "human component" to teaching? How can't that be solved via AGI? AGI can do human emotions, current AI already can pretty well for most things.
- the_af 2y ago"AGI can do human emotions" is a bold statement since AGI doesn't exist yet, and it's not a stated goal to do human emotions. The "human component" to (good) teaching is human beings teaching other human beings to be human. A teacher is not a mechanism for offloading knowledge into a child-shaped container.
- Jensson 2y ago> The "human component" to (good) teaching is human beings teaching other human beings to be human You learn that before you enter school, school teaches you how to be less human and more robotic.
- the_af 2y ago> school teaches you how to be less human and more robotic That's a very cynical take, and in my opinion, false too. You can find examples of bad anything everywhere, including teaching. What you describe hasn't been my own experience as a child, nor my silblings', nor my own children. > You learn [to be human] before you enter school Hard disagree. You never stop learning how to be human till the day you die, but your most important formative years in this sense occur during childhood and early adulthood.
- ben_w 2y agoLLMs are disturbingly capable of acting like they have emotions, regard of which definition of AGI* you want to use: https://old.reddit.com/r/notebooklm/comments/1fr31h8/notebooklm_podcast_hosts_discover_theyre_ai_not/ https://old.reddit.com/r/notebooklm/comments/1fr31h8/noteboo... * there's disagreement about each letter, and treating them as boolean values rather than continuous.
- the_af 2y ago> LLMs are disturbingly capable of acting like they have emotions But I want human teachers behaving truly human to students, not something that can act "disturbingly capable of emotions" or fake it. AGI is nowhere near this (and there's no good definition of what AGI is, anyway). Again, the human component is an essential part of the teacher-student relationship. Teachers are not simply offloaders of knowledge. Just like I don't want parent-like robots nursing and raising children (raising humans and being raised by them is essential to the human experience), I don't want teacher-like robots "disturbingly capable" of acting as if they have emotions. Think of it this way: a sociopath [1] is a human that can act as if they had cooperative/empathetic feelings towards other humans, when in reality acting callously in their own self-interest all the time. Would you want a sociopath teaching children? I wouldn't; whether the sociopath can pass knowledge well and can fake as if they had normal human emotions won't sway my opinion. Real human connection is what makes us human. AIs are not human by definition. Therefore, AIs cannot replace humans in those situations where human connection matters. And we shouldn't want them to either, because otherwise what's the point of existence? Asimov's fictional planet of Solaria was a dystopia, not something to aspire to. ---- [1] or the pop culture understanding of them, anyway. Let's not get caught up in definitions.
- ben_w 2y ago> So also doctors, lawyers, teachers, soldiers and government workers. No, those are all subordinate to the whims of the leaders. That said, I should have been clearer and said "leaders" rather than simply agreeing with the word "politicans": a military general who seizes power may have a different title, that title doesn't matter, it is the power that is the point. Right now most of us are in democracies where the government answers to the people, and the people could set any law requiring any given job be done by humans — but that's not automatically guaranteed going forward, many democracies have falled in the past.