3 ms·
It would be nice, if us on HN, can crowdsource, some good KPIs/Proxies for the goals mentioned in the article. These ones: Goal: Educate children well Proxy:
by nobrains 2y ago
It would be nice, if us on HN, can crowdsource, some good KPIs/Proxies for the goals mentioned in the article.
These ones:
Goal: Educate children well
Proxy: Measure student and school performance on standardized tests
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Schools narrowly focus on teaching students to answer questions like those on the test, at the expense of the underlying skills the test is intended to measure
---
Goal: Rapid progress in science
Proxy: Pay researchers a cash bonus for every publication
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Publication of incorrect or incremental results, collusion between reviewers and authors, research paper mills
---
Goal: A well-lived life
Proxy: Maximize the reward pathway in the brain
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Substance addiction, gambling addiction, days lost to doomscrolling Twitter
---
Goal: Healthy population
Proxy: Access to nutrient-rich food
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Obesity epidemic
---
Goal: Leaders that act in the best interests of the population
Proxy: Leaders that have the most support in the population
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Leaders whose expertise and passions center narrowly around manipulating public opinion at the expense of social outcomes
---
Goal: An informed, thoughtful, and involved populace
Proxy: The ease with which people can share and find ideas
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Filter bubbles, conspiracy theories, parasitic memes, escalated tribalism
---
Goal: Distribution of labor and resources based upon the needs of society
Proxy: Capitalism
Strong version of Goodhart's law leads to: Massive wealth disparities (with incomes ranging from hundreds of dollars per year to hundreds of dollars per second), with more than a billion people living in poverty
---
I will start:
Goal: Leaders that act in the best interests of the population
Good proxy: Mandate that local leaders can only send their kids to the schools in their precinct. They can only take their families to the hospitals in their precincts.