3 ms·
The competition in AI editors is a bit silly at the moment. Everyone and their dog are "building" an AI assisted editor now by duct taping Ollama onto VS Code.
by smokel 2y ago
The competition in AI editors is a bit silly at the moment. Everyone and their dog are "building" an AI assisted editor now by duct taping Ollama onto VS Code. I don't like my data being sent to untrusted parties, so I cannot evaluate most of these. On top of that, the things keep evolving as well, and editors that I dismissed a few months ago, are now all of a sudden turning into amazing productivity boosters, thanks to developments in both models as well as in editor tricks.
My money is on Cursor [1], which does not stop to amaze me, and seems to get a lot of traction. The integration is very clever, and it is scary how it figures out what I intend to do. Then again, I'm probably doing mundane tasks most of the time. For the few bright moments in my day I tend to use ChatGPT, because most of my real problems are in application domains, not in code.
I am not a firm believer in forking large open-source projects, though, as it will take a lot of effort to keep up with future diversions. This makes me a bit wary of projects such as Cursor and Void [2]. Somebody needs deep pockets to sustainably surpass the popularity of VS Code. To point out just one problem with forking: VS Code works fine in Ubuntu, but Cursor does not work out of the box there. Having to disable the sandbox is a show-stopper for most.
In that respect, the extensions might be a safer bet, and I think Sourcegraph's Cody and Continue are making the largest waves there. Hard to tell with so many waves.
[1] https://www.cursor.com/ https://www.cursor.com/
[2] https://voideditor.com/ https://voideditor.com/
- troupo 2y ago> I don't like my data being sent to untrusted parties, so I cannot evaluate most of these. > ... > My money is on Cursor [1] Cursor also sends all your data who knows where
- smokel 2y agoIndeed. I am only using Cursor for some hobby projects. While we're on this subject, is there a simple way to ensure that VS Code extensions do not contact external servers?
- troupo 2y ago> is there a simple way to ensure that VS Code extensions do not contact external servers? Unfortunately, no idea, but it's a good question I'd like to have an answer to