13 ms·
A lot of effort and money has been spent on trying to make this program sound more successful than it was. They put together a long, design heavy packet to spin
by Aurornis 2y ago
A lot of effort and money has been spent on trying to make this program sound more successful than it was. They put together a long, design heavy packet to spin the results for media: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fdc101bc3cfda2dcf0a2244/t/66a8cd0fc256a2303a8569fc/1722338580211/CGIR+LA+BIGLEAP+Final+Report.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fdc101bc3cfda2dcf0a2...
When you look at the details, the results aren’t as good as the headlines. There are major selection bias problems with how both the control group and the $1K/month group were selected and retained.
Even the results that differ between groups aren’t all that amazing and feel like they were cherry picked to be easy wins in a study like this. Of course giving people $1K/month results in that group self/describing as feeling like they’re in a better position to handle an unexpected $400/month expense because you’re literally giving them 2.5X that per month. It’s like the study authors handed themselves a guaranteed win and then congratulated themselves on it.
The claims about employment aren’t really supported by the data, either. The PR piece claims this:
> Guaranteed-income recipients also were more likely to secure full-time or part-time employment, or to be looking for work, rather than being unemployed and not looking for work, the study found.
But when I look at the data on page 57 of the report it shows the treatment group ($1K/month) had higher unemployment at 18 months.
If this was a study about a psychology paper or some social sciences hypothesis then the comments would be all over the glaring dishonesty of how these results are being spun. Something about UBI type research causes a lot of people to assume it’s positive and ignore the issues with the research, though. The numbers in this study do not support the enthusiastic headlines at all.