5 ms·
> Part of studying was going quickly back, switching between X pages before and here, highlighting quickly, making quick notes on the side and so on. Whatever
by mmooss 2y ago
> Part of studying was going quickly back, switching between X pages before and here, highlighting quickly, making quick notes on the side and so on.
Whatever the other trade-offs, you can do all that even more easily with a good PDF application.
You also can open multiple instances of the same book, to have multiple pages open simultaneously.
- HPsquared 2y agoAnd the magic of Ctrl+F, highlights, and comments.
- ralphc 2y agoBut none of that mitigates the problem of screen real estate. Maybe I'm just an old but I like to see more of the page. The Chromebooks, do they have a jack for a second monitor? A good sized monitor could take care of a lot of these problems. Even better would be if they can also put books, pdfs etc. on an iPad for reading.
- skydhash 2y agoIf I'm going to stay at a particular place for working, I want at least 24" in screen areas. 4K if I'm going to stare at text. An iPad works great if you're reading only or working on the document itself (annotation). Not so great for quick browsing.
- Loic 2y agoIn a pdf book, what I am really missing is the spacial position of a piece of knowledge. Particularly for reference books (I am an engineer, I still have a large amount of reference books) I look up on a regular basis, I know/remember where I need to search without the need to express it in words to run a search through a 1000+ page book. But, maybe I am just an old guy and this is just because I learnt this way. Maybe the new generation is learning directly "digital" with other knowledge access mechanisms. For example, I intuitively store a "position" in the book, maybe they intuitively remember a "keyword" to search for in the book.
- ensignavenger 2y agoPDFs have pages, and I usually find that I remember about which page something is on in a PDF I am reffering to as I do when it is printed or in a book. I definitely think there is lots of oppurtunity to improve the UX, but there a a lot of advantages to electronic presentation.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoThis is exactly the reason I dislike reflowable formats. Younger people don’t seem to appreciate the benefits of the spatial position of information within a PDF/printed text. As an undergrad, by the time I finished a textbook chapter, I would have both the information and the general spatial layout of the text committed to memory. The latter greatly helped recall and cognitive integration. 30 years later, I can still pick up my undergrad textbook, dimly recall where the information is located, and quickly get back up to speed. The human brain has a powerful spatial ‘muscle memory’ for recalling information. This is lost when dealing with .mobi and .epub formats.
- adrian_b 2y agoAs another poster said, PDF files have pages. There are good PDF viewers (e.g. MuPDF), where you need only a minimum of movements for going to a page, e.g. pressing "719g" in order to go to page 719. Even when a PDF file does not have bookmarks and even when I do not remember the exact page where something is located, I can still know for instance that what I am looking for is about 20% before the end of the book, so if the book has 1400 pages I go quickly to page 1120 and I search around. With a good PDF viewer I can navigate through a book much faster than I can turn the pages in a physical book. Nevertheless, one needs to have a big high-resolution monitor in order to come close to the quality of a printed book. The current 4k monitors are a huge progress over the older 1080p or 1440p monitors, but their resolution is still insufficient to match that required to render correctly some of the typefaces that were popular for high-quality printing (but which have been rarely used after the transition to digital typefaces, being replaced by others more tolerant to low-resolution rendering). Because I read a lot of books, there are almost 10 years since I have last used a display with a resolution less than 4k and I have always used them only at their native resolution. I cannot understand why some people choose to use various scaling methods to make the text big enough (but ugly), instead of doing the right thing, i.e. the rendering of all typefaces at the maximum available resolution, but choosing their dimension in points big enough for comfortable reading (after setting the monitor dots-per-inch value to the true value for the connected monitor).
- croes 2y agoCan you name such an application? I can fold or flip a page so, that I can quickly view certain parts of the second page while I read the first one.
- mmooss 2y agoThe original specifications in the GGP: > switching between X pages before and here, highlighting quickly, making quick notes on the side and so on. Any PDF reader I've used will do those things, iirc. > I can fold or flip a page so, that I can quickly view certain parts of the second page while I read the first one. With PDFs, you can open it in as many windows as you like and arrange them for simultaneous viewing on your screen. Open a copy on another device too if you like. I'm not saying books have no advantage, just not for those functions IMHO.