2 ms·
Isn't it basically Argumentum ad personam? If a known liar and drug addict tells you that he have this theory, and proceed to make rational arguments for it, i
by ajuc 14y ago
Isn't it basically Argumentum ad personam?
If a known liar and drug addict tells you that he have this theory, and proceed to make rational arguments for it, ignoring him just because of his reputation isn't very scientific.
- Smudge 14y agoIt's ad hominem if dhechols' point was that a scientist's work should be ignored if he/she also holds religious beliefs. That's not how I read it. I see no fallacy in simply pointing out a disparity between scientific reasoning and (unscientific) beliefs.