12 ms·
the description of the previous (bad) law as 'rent control' represents malicious disregard for the truth. 'rent control' idiomatically means, in english, limit
by kragen 2y ago
the description of the previous (bad) law as 'rent control' represents malicious disregard for the truth. 'rent control' idiomatically means, in english, limitations on raising rents over the entire period of time a tenant inhabits a property, not over the predetermined term of a lease. the wikipedia article explains:
> The loose term "rent control" covers a spectrum of regulation which can vary from setting the absolute amount of rent that can be charged, with no allowed increases, to placing different limits on the amount that rent can increase; these restrictions may continue between tenancies, or may be applied only within the duration of a tenancy.
argentina has never, to my knowledge, had rent control in any of these senses. when the lease expired, after three years (or previously two) there was no restriction on how much the landlord could demand in rent to sign a new lease. commonly it would be several times the old rent, due to inflation. three years ago the dollar was 184 pesos https://dolarhistorico.com/cotizacion-dolar-blue/mes/septiembre-2021 https://dolarhistorico.com/cotizacion-dolar-blue/mes/septiem... so a 250 dollar rent would have been 46000 pesos. now it's 1230 pesos https://dolarhistorico.com/cotizacion-dolar-blue/mes/agosto-2023 https://dolarhistorico.com/cotizacion-dolar-blue/mes/agosto-... so those 46000 pesos would be worth 37 dollars without the yearly inflation adjustment
the text of the article sort of admits this by omission, while implying the contrary through its dishonest choice of wording. this is in sharp contrast to the integrity and reliability i normally expect from reason—i often disagree with their values but rarely with their facts
this has misled commenters here such as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659436 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659436
- engineer_22 2y agoThis law isn't rent control, because it's not strong enough to be considered rent control. OK, that seems like an acceptable argument. But, at least according to MSN, it did have effects on real estate concomitant to the arguments against rent control. Interesting result. Argentina is in the midst of a grand experiment.
- kragen 2y agoyes, i agree
- samatman 2y agoThis seems excessively prescriptive. If we're using Wikipedia as the referee today, this is what it says: > Rent control is part of a system of rent regulation that limits the changes that can be made in the price of renting a house or other real property. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent_control_(disambiguation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rent_control_(disambiguation) What you describe, and what Argentina had, is fairly clearly a limit on the changes that can be made in the price of renting. Requiring a certain term of lease, and prohibiting a lease which allows, for example, adjusting the monthly rate to match inflation, are both limitations which fairly belong in this category. You've accused Reason of dishonesty here, I don't think that's accurate. You might prefer the phrase to be used in some more restrictive or definite sense, but they describe the law in the second paragraph: > The 2020 Rental Law, enacted under former President Alberto Fernández, aimed to protect tenants. It mandated three-year lease terms and required rent to be paid in pesos—a currency rapidly losing value due to rampant inflation. Rent adjustments were limited to once a year, based on a central bank rate that factored in inflation and wage growth. The law also allowed tenants to dictate the conditions for lease termination. Is any of this wrong?
- kragen 2y agoyes, that paragraph you quoted from the article is correct, but it omits to mention that there is no limit to how much the landlord can raise the rent when the three years are up an employee who coaches his kid's soccer team on weekends isn't a 'whistleblower' even though he blows a whistle, a barium getter isn't a 'vacuum cleaner' even though it cleans a vacuum, and things like a three-year lease aren't 'rent control' even though they control the rent you already know this, since you're a native english speaker, but i'm commenting to keep you from confusing people who might not be