4 ms·
Teacher caught students using ChatGPT on their first assignment. Debate ensues
- lolinder 2y agohttps://archive.ph/bK8L9 https://archive.ph/bK8L9
- metaphor 2y ago.ph ccTLD mirror wouldn't load for me. https://archive.is/bK8L9 https://archive.is/bK8L9
- adityamwagh 2y agoThis is just sad.
- cosmotic 2y ago"say what you're hoping to get out of this class" is an invitation for bullshit, something LLMs are good at and at least this human (me) is bad at. This makes a lot of sense. Who's taking that class for a reason other than "it fulfills the required credit"? I'm sure it's not enough to expect a wide range of creative responses the instructor seems to have been expecting.
- kaonwarb 2y agoThe teacher notes in the thread (https://x.com/freganmitts/status/1828796730634330593 https://x.com/freganmitts/status/1828796730634330593) that this is not a GE class, and as it's peer-conversation based, so there was some basis for helping students get to know each other. I definitely took many classes in college for reasons other than getting credit, and I hope you did / do too!
- readthenotes1 2y agoIf it's a peer conversation class, perhaps it would have been more appropriate for them to report what another student told them what they hoped to get out of the class...
- throwup238 2y ago> The teacher notes in the thread (https://x.com/freganmitts/status/1828796730634330593 https://x.com/freganmitts/status/1828796730634330593) that this is not a GE class, and as it's peer-conversation based, so there was some basis for helping students get to know each other. Then why make it a written assignment? If it's a peer-conversation based non-GE class, why not ask them to stand up for two minutes and do the awkward intro thing in person on their first day? Then the professor could have had a dialog about what students hope to get from her class, if she really cared. This was pointless busywork through and through, the kind I'd expect ChatGPT to create for a lazy educator.
- cpitman 2y agoExactly, I was CS, but took Psychology classes for my own interest. It was fun bringing a different point of view and only realizing it once we started discussing the reading material. One time in a small seminar class on mental models the professor asked us to each draw a tree. Only once we were done and everyone started sharing their tree did I realize that I had gone straight to a directed acyclic graph. I completely forgot about the green leafy things. Everyone had a good laugh, and it was actually a good example for what were talking about. Asking ChatGPT for what I should say during a class is just play acting at education. Really feels liek a waste of time and money.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cosmotic 2y agoI took zero that didn't fulfill a requirement. I presume anything else would have been cost more in time and money than value I'd get from it. It would almost certainly delayed graduation and sucked up free time and added stress.
- PhasmaFelis 2y agoI'm not sure why you (and, apparently, several students) are assuming that a simple, straightforward question is actually a trick that demands a complex, rambling answer.
- cosmotic 2y agoI was asked this numerous times I college and it gave me anxiety every time I had to answer it. I simply could not understand why anyone would be interested in my response, so I couldn't synthesize anything to my audience (the person asking).
- PhasmaFelis 2y agoIt sounds like the trouble is that people are putting a lot of effort into trying to come up with a detailed lie that will flatter the professor's expectations, when (as I read the OP) the professor has no expectations and actually wants the simple truth. So everybody loses. Maybe teachers need to start putting a "there are no wrong answers" disclaimer on these things.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoExperience, I assume; IME, one of the more annoying things about school was that prose questions expected you to ramble on for pages and pages about something that really deserved about a paragraph.
- pseudo_meta 2y agoFrom the article: > "A lot of students who take philosophy classes, especially if they're not majors, don't really know what philosophy is," she said. "So I like to get an idea of what their expectations are so I can know how to respond to them." Sounds very reasonable to me.
- pyridines 2y agoI agree - if I was a student, I would be very tempted to use an LLM for this sort of coursework-irrelevant busywork assignment, especially if I had other work on my plate. It's not so hard to rationalize using it for this type of thing vs. an "actual" assignment, all due respect to the professor, who I'm sure means well
- beej71 2y agoAs an instructor, I suppose I'm happy to tailor the class to the AI's wishes. ;)
- treme 2y agotbh even functional role of a teacher is about to be upend with AI. All I know is I rather my children be taught something that will be useful with assumption that everyone will have access to have a tool like chatgpt at home/work.
- Brian_K_White 2y agoMaybe an AI is best able to detect when another AI did someone's homework. The purpose of an assignment is not to produce a document, it's for the student learn how to synthesize information. Having an AI produce the document does not provide the student, or the rest of society who needs the student to be good for something, with anything. In this case it was even stupider. It wasn't a test, it was an informational question about themselves. What in the ever loving hell is the defense or value in having an AI fabricate a random answer to a question about what you think about something? At least outside of some marketing data gathering context where there is a reason to give false information.
- Animats 2y ago> Maybe an AI is best able to detect when another AI did someone's homework. That's a losing battle. The best CAPCHA solvers are now better than humans.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 2y agoChatGPT is a tool, and it's hard to argue that someone should be able to work without a useful tool. This is a great argument for advocating in favor of AI at work. Tools are great. However, education is not work. The point of education is not the production of a finished output. The point is to learn. If teachers let students defer their understanding to AI by using ChatGPT to write assignments that means education stops being about the thing they're meant to be learning and starts being a test of prompt engineering. That has it's uses, sure, but you have to be honest about admitting that's what you're arguing in favor of. Should education be about getting a real, fundamental understanding of a subject, or should it be about prompting an AI to do work in that subject area? I'd suggest the former is a lot more useful and valuable in the long term. If I was spending money on my education that's what I'd want at the end.
- raister 2y agoIf you have the time and the attention span: "ChatGPT is bullshit" https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-024-09775-5 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-024-09775-5 (although they concluded it's "soft" bullshit, as it doesn't aim to 'harm')
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pseudo_meta 2y agoThe fact that it's a class on ethics and technology is quite ironic.
- MobiusHorizons 2y agoThere is an inevitability to the tone of this article that I find really depressing (probably because I tend to feel the same way). That The ability of students to think deeply and learn well has been severely diminished over the last decade. That AI use is not even a cause so much as a possible means of escape from the problem. On the one hand this feels true to me given my own experience, but on the other hand I know I still manage to learn and undertake complex tasks, so why should "kids these days" be doomed? How are you all feeling your attention span change? Are you able to sit and think or read long passages without distracting yourself? Were you ever able to do this? If you find yourself struggling, how do you manage? I find myself reaching for audiobooks much more frequently these days. Longer tasks are still possible if I find sufficient motivation. Curiosity is not always enough. I have to craft specific goals for myself in order to maintain motivation, but this takes me quite far in my self-study.
- itronitron 2y ago>> The ability of students to think deeply and learn well has been severely diminished I think it just reflects that most students are just taking classes in order to fulfill whatever requirements they need to progress to the next stage. If it was my class I would have just passed out index cards and given the students five minutes to write their responses before handing them back in. The upside to all of this is that teachers will more highly value actual responses over the cliche responses that students currently think they are supposed to provide (and which they get from ChatGPT)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- elashri 2y agoIt is not strange that companies now compete for your attention. People who do things and learn stuff need to focus and have a long timespan doing anything they are trying to do. The world is now full with many things trying to get your attention. Practicing self restrain mentally would prove to be the most important skill anyone can have nowadays.
- khafra 2y ago> They are also using it to word the questions they ask in class This seems like a straightforward upgrade of the school experience. There truly are dumb questions; many of them get asked in class because speaking to a rubber duck first would be "disruptive." If you're going to take the whole class's attention down a tangent, why is it bad to get a smart generalist's opinion on the optimal shape for that tangent, first?
- Animats 2y agoThink of it as debate prep.
- preommr 2y agoThis is in no small-part due to how broken the system is in providing value to the students. Why do the teachers care? Let the students not learn and suffer from it. The only reason they pull stunts like this is because it actually doesn't have as much of an impact. Why do employers stop asking about grades, and instead focus on actual experience? Because all things equal, that's what matters more. So can we blame students for trying speedrun these barriers to get to what's actually important? And not what they're told is important by educators who have an obvious bias, but what they can see in the reality of the job market.
- goatlover 2y agoNot everything in education is about getting a job. I took electives in college that weren't part of my degree, and they were interesting and enriching. They didn't help me get a job, and that's fine. There is the point of view that education should first be about produced well-rounded and informed citezenry, not just be a mill for producing endless young grist for corporations.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoYes, that's often the common contrast between higher education and the early years: first, you gain knowledge and learn facts, you memorize by rote, you pass standardized tests. In college/university, you learn how to think. You learn how to reason. You increase wisdom, solve problems, and reach an intellectual maturity. That's always been the value of college for me; a degree being a means to an end, perhaps, but the quest for wisdom and reason is far greater than that of career.
- randomdata 2y ago> In college/university, you learn how to think. I learned how to think on the farm after school. You don't have much choice but to when the shit gets real. Is the rise in college attainment directly a result of most kids no longer having access to farms (or even anything close to being equivalent)? > That's always been the value of college for me The historic value was collaboration on ideas. It is all well and good being able to think in solitude, but one can only think so much. Many people all thinking at once and sharing their thoughts is an incredible force multiplier. College offered a place for minds to come together. I'd argue that the internet has become that place nowadays. Which is perhaps why you see college as a metaphorical farm these days instead?
- anshumankmr 2y agoDo folks think ChatGPT soon will become a paid only platform or heavily curtail the free tier like claude.ai is to make Open AI profitable? Just food for thought. It really has become a defacto flag bearer for all LLMs in the market, and I don't know a single person who doesn't use save for my father who is from the boomer generation.
- kombookcha 2y agoIt's hard to see how they're gonna break even otherwise. The market position is only useful if it's also bringing in enough revenue for them to stay afloat and competitive. Maybe there's a layer of 'whales' they can access, like a premium tier for businesses that's got more bells and whistles than the living room variety? Other than that, who knows.
- elashri 2y agoThis comment reflects my personal opinion and experience [please take it with open mind] I really hate these type of questions. The open ended questions that is about myself is not something useful. Students will usually do it because they have and will come up with anything (even before LLM). I understand the point that part of that is for students to get to know each other and professor know more about their expectations. I was once a grader for Astronomy class in the summer for the public (anyone could take it). Part of the assessment was that in each assignment students will ask one question and each student should answer at least one other question. I really questioned my relation with the world grading those questions. Astrology was the common topic. Random questions from all about anything you could come up related to Astronomy (or you think it is related). I no longer teach or grade and my experience were pre-ChatGPT era. ChatGPT will change education and educators have to adapt. They were forced to do it and they just did it for the grade. The purpose was to encourage communication and collaboration but in my experience this rarely work. People will just put bare minimum to just do this. LLM makes this too easy and it will be too tempting to use it. Some people did good job both asking and answering. But many were just not interested and had to do it anyway. Scientists collaborate out of necessity and because most of the them have genuine interest in this field. They get trained during their grad school and usually they still don't do well communicating and collaborating with each other. They are human after all. For the case we have in hand I can see a student tempted to write poor version on answer to this question without having to worry about grammar, typos..etc and will ask LLM to write in an academic style. How would they practice writing academic writing and express their thoughts properly? Probably never but this is them tricking themselves. Another problem which makes this case unique is that this course is about ethics. So lets set plagiarism and university rules aside. A discussion on using LLMs would be better start for a class about ethics and technology.
- travisjungroth 2y agoIn your second paragraph, you said you didn’t find it useful and then you said why it’s useful.
- drivingmenuts 2y ago
- timonoko 2y agoI asked Gemini to add some grammar error that 13-year old might make. Worked very well, it added some teen-typical inflection errors. English is of course different thing, because there is no actual grammar, it is just word salad and everything goes.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mediumsmart 2y agoPart of the foundation a post knowledge storytelling society can stand on.
- adamcharnock 2y agoI found the linked Reddit thread to be particularly interesting (educators discussing use of ChatGPT by students, 1y ago): https://www.reddit.com/r/Professors/comments/17v6478/chatgpt_its_getting_worse/?rdt=63742 https://www.reddit.com/r/Professors/comments/17v6478/chatgpt...
- enriquto 2y ago> > a skilled LLM user can generate solid responses to almost anything. > I don't think my students, who often leave the "as an AI I have no opinions" in their essays, are skilled LLM users This thread is really funny; or really depressing, depending on your point of view. My conclusion: teachers should start using ChatGPT to grade these assignements. Without even reading them. That would be a win-win for everybody.
- adamcharnock 2y agoMy takeaway from the thread is that LLM-use seems to be the manifestation of student's disinterest, dissatisfaction, and potentially poor attention spans. Comment from one student (who, from what I glean from the thread, is probably more capable than average). There is one comment from a student in the thread. Sure they seem angry, but I also see their point: > I have used chatgpt in literally all of my essays this semester, and got an average grade of 8-9. > ... > But you know why, at least in my case, I always get away with it? Because all of the work I have to do requires ZERO critical thinking from my side. In fact, it is even worse to use it sometimes. Don't you even dare to come up with your own opinions!!! Just quote someone that is already quoting someone and so and so on. > I know most students don't give a single flick about your class and that unmotivates but damn it is the 5th year you ask for the same essay and we know you don't even read half of them. Why would I lose so much time doing something literally no one cares about. > TL;DR: If a machine can do most college essays it's because they were mechanical jobs already.
- DiscourseFan 2y agoIt's strange, all these professors asking students to generate outlines, when outlines are probably the worst way to write an essay. The kids don't want to write because they have no investment in it: professors ask for systematic, boring, easily interpretable essays, they get essays generated by a program that writes in the most easily interpretable way possible.
- blitzar 2y agoI imagine the output was something like this... >> Hi I'm ChatGPT and I can't take this class because I am a chat bot. The smart ones swapped their name in when they copy and pasted the answer and went undetected.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoA couple of years ago, one of the GE English courses I took was 100% oriented toward producing exactly one research paper. The class, therefore, involved laying the foundations, doing the research, constructing footnotes and a bibliography, producing a couple of drafts, and finally submitting a finished work. And so the instructor was there to shepherd us the entire way through the whole process, with oversight and feedback at every step. This was not simply, "OK you took a class on <X> and it's time to spew out a paper of <N> pages on it." This was learning how to correctly do a research paper from start to finish. It was fantastic because it really made cheating stupid. Whether you were going to purchase a paper online, or have an LLM write it, or pay a friend to do your work, every cheating method was profoundly irrelevant and useless in the face of this process. At the end, either you've learned something about writing a good college paper, or you haven't. I took other classes that taught about rhetoric, evaluation of sources, and extra credit was to read and analyze a novel. The instructors were top-notch and highly credentialed, at the top of their game. Especially for community college where I was taking on a FAFSA grant, I thought that the whole process was absolutely rigorous, educational, and extremely edifying even at my advanced age.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoI will say that in other classes, we had very short research papers to do in a brief time frame, and the most difficult aspect of those, for me, was paraphrasing. I could easily look things up in primary/secondary sources and know exactly what I wanted to put into the paper. But because it often involved technical, precise jargon to express my thoughts, I struggled to paraphrase, or put it in layman's terms or something, without losing the essential gist of it all. Paraphrasing from a source, I believe, may be a very strong suit of an LLM, where you could just paste in a block and say "rewrite it so I'm not plagiarizing", and that's powerfully dangerous.
- returnInfinity 2y agoFlip the script, ask the students to record videos instead and then use AI to extract text out of the videos.
- adamcharnock 2y agoThat... sounds like a fantastic idea. Having read the reddit thread linked in the article, I think the main problems would be one of (depending on the teacher): 1. Not wanting to 2. Needing funding/support to AI-transcribe all the video for each of their numerous students, but their institution not providing it. But those seem [eventually] surmountable. I really like the idea.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- qubitcoder 2y agoI'm part of a local physics meetup where AI is often a topic of conversation. One member is a well-regarded high school physics teacher (his students end up at MIT, Georgia Tech, etc., and some go on to get physics PhDs). He shared that some teachers now require AI/LLMs for homework assignments, such as writing essays. The actual assignment is to critique the output of the LLM. As a millennial, even our middle school classes taught information literacy in various forms in the "computer lab". And that was the nascent days of the web. AI is a tool, not unlike a calculator or Wikipedia. They were both controversial and even forbidden at times. Students adapted. So did education.