4 ms·
I for one don't agree with HFT. Why should our best hackers and mathematical minds be wasted on something so shallow as gaming the market? Would a small rando
by kristianp 14y ago
I for one don't agree with HFT. Why should our best hackers and mathematical minds be wasted on something so shallow as gaming the market?
Would a small randomised delay introduced by the exchange into each stock trade (or price datum) reduce the incentive for HFT?
- twoodfin 14y agoWhy should our best hackers and mathematical minds be wasted on something so shallow as gaming the market? If you think they're wasting their time, don't give them your money.
- drblast 14y agoI don't think it's as simple as all that. There are legitimate parties at either end of a stock transaction, and the HFT's are pretty much just siphoning off small amounts of the proceeds. The reason this can occur is that our government ensures that public companies have to do business this way. And all of these rules are in place for good reasons and it works pretty well, but HFT is an aberration. A good analogy is credit card companies; it's perfectly rational for a customer to use a rewards credit card and pay it off at the end of every month, and it's perfectly rational for a merchant to allow credit card transactions for convenience. Arguably, however, the credit card company is little else but a 3-5% drain on the economy, especially for brick-and-mortar stores. That said, credit card companies provide some value in the form of convenience, so maybe the transaction fee is worth it. HFT's, however, provide no benefit to anyone but themselves. The transactions would still occur whether or not the HFT existed. The distinction Mark Cuban makes between "investors" and "traders" is an astute one.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jamii 14y agoBrick-and-mortar stores themselves don't create anything. They buy in bulk and sell at a markup, thus adding liquidity to the grocery market. Imagine if you had to buy carrots by the tonne.
- ajtulloch 14y agoThis is flat out wrong. The correct analogy is: Before HFT, to execute a block trade, your only option was to go to a specialised liquidity provider a.k.a your friendly local investment bank - the CC company in your analogy - , who would take a huge spread - the 3%-5% drain on the economy that you mentioned - in exchange for taking that liquidity risk. Now, with HFT, the increased speed of markets has democratised liquidity provision. There is a corresponding larger supply of liquidity in the markets, and so spreads have come down - very significantly. The aggregate affect - it is now cheaper to trade on stock exchanges. What does this mean? When your 401(k), pension fund, mutual fund, etc. rebalances, it doesn't lose 3% of your money to an investment bank. It loses ~0.01%-0.05% (1-5bp) of your money as a transaction cost (earned by HFT firms as compensation for taking on the liquidity risk), and thus you keep more of your money. It's easy to say that HFT's provide 'no benefit to anyone but themselves' without any understanding of the historical context, but once you do, it's hard to see it in such black and white terms. Full disclosure - I was an algo trader in a previous life.
- mistermann 14y agoOk, this seems plausible, however, I am skeptical. Do you have any data or studies proving out these theories, including data that would give credence to the idea that the $ taken out of the market now due to HFT is less than that taken out by old fashioned liquidity providers?
- ajtulloch 14y agohttp://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1695460 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1695460; http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1722924 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1722924; http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1540-6261.2010.01624.x/pdf http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1540-6261.2010....; http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1970072 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1970072 http://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-02-10/s70210-122.pdf http://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-02-10/s70210-122.pdf
- javert 14y agoWhy should our best hackers and mathematical minds be wasted on something so shallow as gaming the market? Your mistaken premise is "our." That implies ownership. How would you rather allocate those minds, commissar?
- mistermann 14y agoTake the word "our" out, do you still disagree? One thing you will notice about certain topics is advocates of one side or the other will nitpick inconsequential portions of sentences rather than actually discussing the topic.
- overcyn 14y ago> Why should the best hackers and mathematical minds be wasted on something so shallow as gaming the market? Because it makes them money.
- javert 14y agoYes, I still disagree. I mean, even without that word there, the same premise is baked into the question the person I was responding to asked. I disagree with your claim that I'm nitpicking and not discussing the topic.
- mistermann 14y agoHis assertion is that they are gaming the market, with no net benefit to society (it could be argued that their actions are detrimental). Furthermore, bright minds such as these could be doing things that are a potentially large net benefit to society.
- ezl 14y agoI forget where I read this, but in an article by someone else I read something like: "[There's something very sinister about a company that takes society's greatest engineer and science minds away from important tasks for humanity and diverts them to the task of optimizing ads] A lot of people will say what you say about HFT, but have no qualms about Google and Facebook and Twitter. Why is that?
- clarky07 14y agoI for one would say this about HFT, Facebook, twitter, and google. Though to a lesser extent for google as they have lots of other impressive projects such as self driving cars that could have a good impact.
- whatusername 14y agoIndexing all of the worlds information isn't something for our best hackers? Setting up a global communications network where I can easily share photos videos with friends and families (helping millions and millions stay in touch) isn't worthy of some great hackers?
- infinii 14y agoSociety does nothing about underpaying the educators of our children; so they should deal with the fact that great minds will be lured away to less critical tasks.
- mistermann 14y ago> A lot of people will say what you say about HFT, but have no qualms about Google and Facebook and Twitter. Why is that? Because Google and Facebook and Twitter provide legitimate value and services (some more valuable than others), and offer something that wasn't there before. HFT does none of the above, unless you believe that lack of liquidity was somehow a big problem prior to them entering the market and generating 80% of the trades, and skimming off as much money as possible in the process.
- sskates 14y agoCan someone explain this mindset to me? That there is somehow a fixed amount of mathematical talent in the world and if there are people whose preferences make taking a job in HFT optimal then society is necessarily worse off.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jberryman 14y agoWell, speaking broadly about finance vs other more productive fields of human endeavor, there is a staggering amount of brain drain of the (very much finite) graduates of ivy league schools to the finance industry: http://www.wbur.org/npr/146434854/stopping-the-brain-drain-of-the-u-s-economy http://www.wbur.org/npr/146434854/stopping-the-brain-drain-o... I think it's obvious that that doesn't mesh with the narrative we tell ourselves about the importance of higher education to society at large.
- MBlume 14y agoUh, where do you think we can get more mathematical talent from? At the end of the day, there's only so many people at the right end of the bell curve.
- MarkMc 14y agoI don't think it assumes a fixed amount of talent. Perhaps a hypothetical analogy can help: Imagine that a tax of 0.000001% is applied to every stockmarket transaction, and the proceeds are given to the top 10 people who can best memorise the digits of PI. Most people would say that this scheme necessarily makes society worse off. Would you oppose this hypothetical scheme? If so, what is the significant difference between it and HFT?
- spamizbad 14y ago> Why should our best hackers and mathematical minds be wasted on something so shallow as gaming the market? The reason why these shops can employ the "best hackers and mathematical minds" is because they're willing to pay for them. Everyone wants to hire 10-to-1s but nobody wants to pay them even 1.5x the salary of a blub hack. These days people say "We pay market rate!" and wear it like a badge of honor.