3 ms·
A thriving underground economy is clogging the internet with AI garbage
- superkuh 2y agoThis is a bit backwards. The "economy", the for-profits, are clogging the internet with garbage. How or where they generate it hardly matters.
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoOf course it matters. Quantity has a quality all its own, and AI enables massive quantity.
- blakesterz 2y agohttps://archive.ph/YSqEu https://archive.ph/YSqEu "But the idea that AI has quietly crowded out humans is not exactly right. Slop requires human intervention or it wouldn’t exist. Beneath the strange and alienating flood of machine-generated content slop, behind the nonhuman fable of dead-internet theory, is something resolutely, distinctly human: a thriving, global gray-market economy of spammers and entrepreneurs, searching out and selling get-rich-quick schemes and arbitrage opportunities, supercharged by generative AI."
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- OutOfHere 2y agoThat's an extremely loaded title and article. If there wasn't good demand for the material, it wouldn't be generated. After all, the generation isn't free. AI isn't cheap. As for the quality, it varies, just like with human work. In any event, there will always exist repositories of curated works, such as reputable news sites, academic sites, and other scholarly sites. These should continue to remain sufficient to feed AI with quality training material.
- hfvbji 2y ago> If there wasn't good demand for the material, it wouldn't be generated. Ahh yes, the “market” for images of fake amputated uniformed soldiers begging for money, and starving tribal people. Seriously, “market forces” people are suffering from a mental illness.
- happytoexplain 2y ago"Demand" / "market" has to win the award for the words most used to paper over the hideous inhumanity of large systems.
- OutOfHere 2y agoThat's a bit of a generalization. Because humans themselves typically don't act in their own best interest, there is more interest in low-impact forgettable materials produced by AI than in good-quality life-changing materials produced by AI. Take for example a project I developed: https://github.com/impredicative/newssurvey https://github.com/impredicative/newssurvey which is absolutely intended to value one's humanity and help it. I'd like to think it has already enhanced the quality of life for multiple people with its revelations. Humans won't typically value anything so constructive though until it's too late for them individually.
- uhfido 2y ago> I'd like to think it has already enhanced the quality of life for multiple people with its revelations. Your definition of "revelations" seems to be: stripping any useful context and over applying underlying concepts wrapped in overly verbose prose. (Maybe have an LLM summarize these lengthy summaries, ala "Thanks to AI I don't need to read all those 300,000 words now, right?"[0]) For instance, from your "Nutritional Strategies and Supplements for Managing Anxiety in Adults" example, Section 19 Links Between High-Fat Diets and Anxiety Development: > Studies observing the effects of specific high-fat food components, like those found in soybean oil, suggest that these can disrupt gut microbiota balance, further aggravating conditions like inflammatory bowel disease, which are closely linked with anxiety disorders[49] Looking at [49] you get the article: Widely consumed vegetable oil leads to an unhealthy gut, finds mouse study. Your use of an LLM created slop that removed the context of it being a mice study, and instead stated the underlying conclusions as actionable fact for "adults". This is dangerous, and well, sloppy. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41646994 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41646994
- antisthenes 2y agoWell, the above-ground economy is also clogging the internet with AI garbage, so I guess there's not much news here. And frankly, the average public is pretty good at clogging the internet with regular garbage without AI's involvement.